Official Columbia Early Decision Class of 2015 Results-ONLY STATS

<p>

You are not naive, but perhaps a bit too trusting - it is indeed a fact that no college is need blind. The only colleges that are truly an exception to this are colleges that in all honesty did not ask for your income or financial intents before or during the application reading process. And unfortunately, I know of no colleges that have not already gathered information about this extremely critical and touchy private matter. If you look in ANY college application ranging from common app to the UC app, somehow somewhere, they will ask or inquire about your monetary intent to have at least a good assumption of your payment method. I do not know of any colleges that do not ask about this. If you know any please enlighten me, and if you think that it truly has 0% impact on your admission when you read the “need blind” statement right before you answer their question, then maybe you truly are naive. I’m not saying that it is a make or break factor, but it is indeed a factor unfortunately. This isn’t the Soviet Union (thank god), but that means money is indeed everything even with an endowment of $6 billion like Columbia.</p>

<p>Decision: Deferred - SEAS</p>

<p>Stats:[ul]
[<em>] SAT: 2070
[</em>] SAT IIs: Math II 630, Physics 600
[<em>] GPA: 99 Unweighted
[</em>] Rank: 2/365
[<em>] Other stats:
[/ul]Subjective:[ul]
[</em>] Essays: Strong
[<em>] ECs: Captain Varsity Softball Team all 4 years (selected to all-division team 2010), National Honor Society, Math Honor Society, Spanish Club, Vice President of Art Club, Flautist in Symphonic Band, absurd amount of Community Service with Juvenile Diabetes Research Foundation, Breast Cancer Walk, Relay for Life,
[</em>] Teacher Recs: Superb.
[<em>] Counselor Rec: Not sure, because I didn’t see it, but he loves me, so I assume it was good.
[</em>] Hook (if any): Legacy (both parents attended), female going into engineering field
[/ul]Location/Person:[ul]
[<em>] State or Country: Upstate NY
[</em>] School Type: Fairly Good Public
[<em>] Ethnicity: Whitey White White
[</em>] Gender: Female
[/ul]Other Factors: None really.
General Comments: At first I was absolutely crushed, but after seeing all the rejections I feel quite lucky to have been deferred. At least my dreams can go on until March. Congrats to everyone who has been accepted!</p>

<p>gold3n, have you talked to admissions officers? do you think what you’re saying is true?</p>

<p>students sometimes refuse to fill out what their parents do for a living. and so i asked the admissions officer, what do you do - well she said you can only decide with as much information as the student gives you. that student could be dirt poor, or their family could be significantly wealthy, and so you admit the student based on the case they make for themselves.</p>

<p>but then there is the issue that knowing your family’s socioeconomic background is helpful in determining what kind of background you have, what were your opportunities, etc. indeed knowing your financial background - without knowing the specifics of your financials (columbia’s system is such that you have to be a financial aid officer to look at financial information, it is not housed in the same way), a broad understanding of your family’s financial background is of course important and usable in discovering whether or not you have gone above and beyond what is available to you. if this is what you meant, then yes, your family’s socioeconomic background is taken into account. but as with the above example, at NO time are you admitted to columbia domestically on the idea that you are a full-payer.</p>

<p>there are a lot of schools out there that look for full-payers, or will cap (or could cap) finaid they give out and only give the rest of their admissions to full-payers. but with very good source on admissons, i can say this is not the case for domestic students (and canadians and mexicans) to columbia.</p>

<p>and i believe that deep springs college application doesn’t ask for financial information.</p>

<p>**Decision: Deferred **</p>

<p>Stats:[ul]
[<em>] SAT: 1550/2280. 780 Reading 770 Math 730 Writing
[</em>] SAT IIs: Lit 780. Math I 740. Math II 700.
[<em>] GPA: 3.9/6.2
[</em>] Rank: Don’t know… I think 2nd, 3rd, or 4th.
[<em>] Other stats: 5 5’s on APs.
[/ul]Subjective:[ul]
[</em>] Essays: Very strong. Written almost like a fiction piece. A series of flashbacks depicting my car accident and several other events pivotal to my admission in to the bespectacled world.
[<em>] ECs: Founder of Speech and Debate club-a few minor awards in Group Interp and Original Oratory. Chess and Philosophy Club VP. NHS officer. Newspaper Editor in Chief. Some writing awards. Worked in daycare. Volunteered at Science Museum. Ballerina. Blah, blah, blah some minor others.
[</em>] Teacher Recs: One came from the English teacher who gave me the department award last year- so excellent. The other- didn’t read, but assume it was also very good.
[<em>] Counselor Rec: Fair.
[</em>] Hook (if any): Eh… Didn’t really capitalize on anything.
[/ul]Location/Person:[ul]
[<em>] State or Country: FL, USA
[</em>] School Type: Full-time Dual Enrollment Public. 46th best public HS in country according to Newsweek 2010.
[<em>] Ethnicity: Russian- no boost there.
[</em>] Gender: F
[/ul]Other Factors: Essays were a bit on the risky side, but well-written (as is my way).
General Comments: Happy to have been deferred (obviously acceptance would have been optimal). If Columbia deferred me, then I have a sure shot at the other schools I’m looking into.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>That’s the way I see it. :)</p>

<p>admissionsgeek, that is actually what i meant mostly when it comes to financial aid. I never made the argument that it is THE FACTOR that can open the door or shut the gates for you. If you reread my post I made that statement clear. However, you’d be extremely hard pressed to argue that when an adcom skims over the application questions he/she would not do a double take at the “parent occupation” section if it happened to say senator/(insert extremely wealthy occupation here) rather than a blue/white collar worker.</p>

<p>I feel sooo horrible.</p>

<p>does anyone ever get in after being deferred? my stats are nothing compared to the 2300s+ and valedictorians i have seen get rejected on this page</p>

<p>Oh. I forgot one of my most important ECs. I also design websites. </p>

<p>To think that it’s only been 3 hours since we found out the decisions… I already feel so at ease. When I first got the news, I froze, then started doing push ups, and then ate 3 chocolate-covered marshmallow desserts. THREE! </p>

<p>@InvisibleMonster, that’s the only way to see it and maintain calm. With your amazing record (in fact, all the profiles I have seen on CC are exemplary, if not downright godly), you will end up in an excellent school. The trick is to step back, put everything into perspective, and breathe. Columbia has limited space, but we have limitless futures. Huzzah!</p>

<p>I just want to tell you guys that I think you are such a talented group of young people. It’s been a privilege sharing the past few months with you. My S was accepted and is beyond shocked and thrilled. I would post stats, but they are his to share, not mine, so I’ll encourage him to set up an account. </p>

<p>If there were one piece of advice I could offer, it is to reiterate what admissionsgeek and jgaugust have already stated: tell the school what you can bring to their community, not just what you want from them. It is a relationship that you want to develop, a give and take. </p>

<p>I have come to “know” you guys in different ways and think that collectively and individually you are an AMAZING group. Congratulations to everyone here for being risk-takers, an achievement unto itself. I will continue to follow the boards and look forward to seeing where everybody lands.</p>

<p>iwanttobegandalf, I have a feeling you’re gonna be one of the few that get in from deferred. Just have a really confident outlook and send them a letter in writing to the admission office like the informative post on the previous page stated.</p>

<p>Wow, if these ED results stay consistent through RD, it looks like this is going to be an extraordinarily tough year for Columbia wannabes. I’m thinking that Columbia’s admissions office is preparing for a fairly large bump in RD applications as a result of switching to the Common Application.</p>

<p>tonerre: Congrats!!! You started a quidditch club; you deserve to go.</p>

<p>g0ld3n, you’re right, i think columbia probably is more willing to admit someone who comes from a very underprivileged working class background and is impressive, than someone who is middling but a senator’s daughter. at least that is my feeling knowing the office culture.</p>

<p>I’m checking tomorrow so I could cry over the weekend lol. i notice however that the lower SAT scores are getting better results then the higher ones. Interesting.</p>

<p>Reposting this. Accepted through the Questbridge College Match, got my acceptance letter with the EDers. </p>

<p>Decision: Accepted to CC (Match)</p>

<p>Objective:[ul]
[<em>] SAT I (breakdown): 700 CR 610 M 770 W (2nd sitting) = 2080
[</em>] ACT: 30 (not submitted)
[<em>] SAT II: 700 Lit, 650 USH, 750 Span w/ List
[</em>] Unweighted GPA (out of 4.0): 4.0
[<em>] Rank (percentile if rank is unavailable): 1/135
[</em>] AP (place score in parenthesis): World History (4), Spanish Lit (3), US History (5), Eng Lang (4)
[<em>] IB (place score in parenthesis):
[</em>] Senior Year Course Load: Physics, AP Eng Lit, AP Gov, AP Calc AB, AP Span Lang
[<em>] Major Awards (USAMO, Intel etc.): Arts scholarship for creative writing (state level), Questbridge College Prep Scholar
[/ul]
Subjective:[ul]
[</em>] Extracurriculars (place leadership in parenthesis): Student Government (Freshman and Sophomore Class President, Student Body President my junior and senior year), Marching Band (First Chair/Section Leader), Drama Club (Treasurer), Academic Decathlon<br>
[<em>] Job/Work Experience:
[</em>] Volunteer/Community service: Volunteering as a cabin leader for an elementary school outdoor education program (forgot to list)
[<em>] Summer Activities: Governor’s School for the arts (creative writing), TASP
[</em>] Essays: Super polished.
[<em>] Teacher Recommendation: Teachers who legit knew me as a student and as a person. They must have been amazing.
[</em>] Counselor Rec: Explained my socioeconomic situation well, my family’s small business, etc.<br>
[<em>] Additional Rec: From Academic Decathlon adviser. I’ve been working with her throughout my four years of high school. Explained how I was the only freshman in a team composed of all seniors my freshman year and went on to become a leader of the team in the years following.
[</em>] Interview: No Interview
[/ul]
Other[ul]
[<em>] State (if domestic applicant): CA
[</em>] Country (if international applicant):
[<em>] School Type: Small, rural public
[</em>] Ethnicity: Mexican
[<em>] Gender: M
[</em>] Income Bracket: Poor enough to get Questbridge.
[<em>] Hooks (URM, first generation college, etc.): URM, first generation [/ul]
Reflection[ul]
[</em>] Strengths: I’m confident that my essays had a strong influence. For this QB app, we had to write three. I utilized every space that I could to highlight different aspects of my life and how they’ve influenced me. I believe I succeeded in concisely conveying an accurate picture of myself, my circumstances, and my passions. I wrote my heart out and was completely myself.
[<em>] Weaknesses: My math subscore is obviously subpar or whatever, but hey. They were able to overlook it, I guess. My USH subject test was also meh, but I think the 5 I got on the AP test made up for that?
[</em>] Why you think you were accepted/deferred: I come from a severely underrepresented part of the state. I think it was evident that I was doing all that I could with the resources that I had at my small town high school. I was involved in a handful of ECs (listed above) since my freshman year and had legit leadership in each and every one. Quality vs. Quantity and whatnot. Also, I ranked Columbia as my first choice in the College Match as it has been my first choice for years. My “Why Columbia” was very strong. My passion for the school was definitely conveyed. All the knowledge I had acquired about the school over the years from reading this forum, Bwog, etc., made it so that I could be super specific. I knew what the “Columbia experience” was and made sure they knew how badly I wanted it.<br>
[li] Where else were you accepted/deferred: Also ranked Yale and Stanford as they were non-binding. I’ll never know if they wanted me or not. [/ul][/li]General Comments: I started reading CC in the fall of my sophomore year and it opened my eyes to so many things. Without it, I never would’ve realized that going to these prestigious schools was at all attainable. It’s been a whirlwind that led up to my senior year of high school and this application cycle. The information I’ve collected throughout these past couple of years has been invaluable, as I’ve mentioned above and it saddens me that there are so many viable applicants out there in underrepresented areas who just don’t KNOW. They just don’t know that this is possible. But it is. And I’ve made it. And it’s an absolute dream and part of me still cannot believe it. So while the “chance me” threads, obsession over scores, and other CC BS are super frustrating and quite disgusting, I put up with it. I post these results stats in hopes that somewhere, someone will read this and KNOW that this is possible. Work hard, play your cards right. It all works out in the end. This has been such a journey. Peace out.</p>

<p>Decision: DEFERRED</p>

<p>Stats:
SAT: 2050. 720 Reading 650 Math 680 Writing
SAT IIs: US History 750. Bio-M 680.
GPA: 102.83 (weighted)
Rank: 3/396
Other stats: APs: 4s on US & Lang; 3 on Bio</p>

<p>Subjective:
Essays: Common App essay: Excellent. Definitely one of the best essays I’ve ever written. Why Columbia? essay: Good but I felt it could’ve been better. I just couldn’t get the correct hook.
ECs: 300+ hours of community service via 2 self-created projects: teaching French to elementary school children & creating a sitting area at a local handicapped-accessible nature trail, French Club (Vice President), FBLA (Treasurer, received 3 awards at state level competition), Student Gov’t (Junior Class Treasurer and Senior Class Student Advisor), NHS (Tutoring Center Coordinator), Drama Club (all four years involved with school plays & musicals), Mentor, French & Spanish Honor Societies
Teacher Recs: One was excellent, the other was decent
Counselor Rec: Good
Hook (if any): Had an interview with a Columbia University Trustee Emeritus </p>

<p>Location/Person:
State or Country: New York
School Type: Public
Ethnicity: Caucasian
Gender: Female
Other Factors:</p>

<p>General Comments: While not “happy” per se, I’m glad to be deferred because I was expecting to be rejected, and it means that my dream is alive for a little bit longer. Congrats to those who were accepted! To those rejected, just remember that it’s not the end of the world. There are plenty of amazing schools out there!</p>

<p>Rejected</p>

<p>[ b]Stats:[ /b][ list]
SAT: 2250
SAT IIs: Math II 730, US History 700, Bio M 750
GPA: 98/100
Rank: 1/400
Other stats: Most rigorous AP classes
Subjective:
Essays: Spectacular
ECs: Crapload of community service, leadership in two honor societies and other clubs, etc. not gonna post it all.
Teacher Recs: Good
Counselor Rec: Alright
Hook (if any):
Location/Person:
State or Country: NY
School Type: Public, crappy school
Ethnicity: Asian
Gender: Female</p>

<p>General Comments: I guess it hurts that no one in my school has ever been accepted to Columbia. Oh well. Moving on.</p>

<p>Almost the exact same stats as you gilly624</p>

<p>Decision: Accepted CC</p>

<p>Stats:[ul]
[<em>] SAT: 2290
[</em>] SAT IIs: Math II 790, USH 790
[<em>] GPA: 3.9 UW
[</em>] Rank: top 2%
[/ul]</p>

<p>Subjective:[ul]
[<em>] Essays: I think was the strongest part of my application; took a unique take on the supplemental essay
[</em>] ECs: Quiz Bowl Captain, Mock Trial VP, Future Problem Solving VP, interned at Alzheimer’s Center, and service clubs
[<em>] Teacher Recs: Both excellent
[</em>] Counselor Rec: Excellent
[<em>] Hook (if any): none
[/ul]Location/Person:[ul]
[</em>] State or Country: NC
[<em>] School Type: Public
[</em>] Ethnicity: Asian
[li] Gender: Male[/li][/ul]Other Factors:
General Comments:</p>

<p>So unbelievably happy right now. For my fellow ED applicants: if you got rejected/deferred, don’t lose faith and know that as long as you work hard and are respectful to other people, only good will come. </p>

<p>For future applicants: it’s ok if you don’t present yourself in a well-rounded light, for example, my math/science is pretty weak, but you must find a way to demonstrate passion, be it through your ECs or essays. Good luck with your application!</p>

<p>Thanks CC for being there for me when I had any questions and giving me valuable insight into the college application process. I probably won’t visit as much, now that I’ve finally realized my dream and gotten into college, but I know I wouldn’t have been as successful had it not been for your support. I realize this sounds a bit melodramatic, but I’m really giddy and ecstatic right now.</p>