<p>This is official!!! I just received the email</p>
<p>The Columbia community is committed to environmental responsibility; in keeping with this commitment, we will provide some admissions decisions only online, not via regular mail. You may request that a copy of your decision letter be mailed to you after you receive it online; further instructions will be available when you check your decision. We plan to post all decisions here on Thursday, December 10, 2009, after 5:00pm (Eastern Time).</p>
<p>Yeah I can’t understand for the life of me why anyone would want a rejection over being deferred. Don’t get me wrong, I can understand where having a plain yes or no would be nice, but if I’m deferred I’ll still be able to hold onto some hope about getting in (being the optimist I am) and can analyze what went wrong ED and try to prove my worth in RD. Bottom line, I know that they saw something that made me worth a second look. Heck, even if they weren’t to accept me RD at least by the time the actual rejection came around in April (I hope) I’d have some other acceptances to ease my mind and fall back on. Getting rejected now, I’d have nothing to hold onto and very little confidence while completing my other apps. to highly competitive colleges (although I’m sure those of us who get rejected will still go great places!) So those of you who say getting deferred is worse than rejection, I highly doubt that you’d be saying that come Thursday. Then again, maybe I’m missing something…</p>
<p>BUT DON’T GET ME WRONG, I WANT A FREAKING ACCEPTANCE. :)</p>
<p>Well, I see it this way: either get rejected and move on, knowing you have nothing else to hold on to, or if you’re accepted… well then college apps are over for you! But if you’re deferred, you’re going to be clinging on to the hope of RD admission while working on other apps, which I think will definitely be detrimental to aforesaid apps.</p>
<p>I don’t think the essay can count for that much. I’d like to think it counts for a lot, but essays can be written by non-applicants like tutors, paid students, or even parents. I don’t know how much they can trust the essays.</p>
<p>I disagree. From every admissions officer I’ve spoken to at all sorts of schools (big, small, private, public, Ivy, etc…), I’m confident that they would never asssume the worst about essays. If they were to be overly cautious about essays, they’d do the same for activity sheets/resumes and even recommendation letters.</p>
<p>As far as I know, nobody will look at your application and make the assumption that you may not have written your essay yourself. That’s partly why they have the agreement you have to sign or check off on every app - the one that says something along the lines of “I verify that all the info on this application is my original work, and that it is all true.”</p>