Received a similar email from my counselor as well.
It seems that UChicago’s yield is very, very high this year, which is shown by the absence of many acceptances on this thread prior to May 1. It might be one of those years when the waitlist is barely used; if that is the case, we might be notified of the waitlist’s closure as early as the end of next week. The preliminary estimate was about 80 for waitlist acceptances, but it seems like the actual number may be way lower (this includes the waitlisted people who have already been accepted).
I highly, highly recommend that you take your mind off of UChicago over the next few days and focus on the schools that accepted you. Given the high yield rate, interest in the school will not matter as much as the type of people that the school needs for a balanced class (e.g. a tuba player, a wrestler, etc.). It seems that EA applicants will have the advantage over RD applicants due to implied level of interest (the majority of waitlist acceptances this year have been deferred to waitlisted EA applicants).
One thing that UChicago does is that it courtesy waitlists many people (this may be a way for them to increase application numbers, since a waitlist is commonly seen as an “I’m almost there” for many people). Looking through many of the old threads (as well as the results of students in my school district and neighboring school districts), most of the RD rejections are EA applicants who did not make the final cut, and EA applicants who are waitlisted tend to have the upper hand in the waitlist pool. This does not mean that an RD waitlistee has absolutely no chance of getting in; it just means that it is harder to identify that person’s position within the waitlist pool. They say that the waitlist is unranked, but some posts say otherwise: http://talk.collegeconfidential.com/discussion/comment/18366292/#Comment_18366292
The waitlist is bigger than you may think, so don’t keeps your hope up. The waitlist size was 2,892 (Source: Niche) three years ago… with the growing applicant pool and dropping acceptance rate every year, this year’s stats should be a lot different. In addition, approximately 78% of users on the CC UChicago thread were waitlisted; I know that CC is not a representative sample of the entire population, but it does bring up some questions…
I don’t mean to turn this negative or anything… I just want to make it more realistic. The chance is still there, don’t get me wrong. It’s just that you shouldn’t depend on it anymore given the high yield rate this year.
Good luck to all!
EDIT: The waitlist seems to be closed already, and some sources online said that it closed around April 20 last week. The admissions officers seem to be giving out gap year acceptances this week, and a formal rejection should arrive on our portals by Friday, May 13th. There will be a few saved for the extended waitlist due to the summer melt. Sorry guys. 