Ohio LAC Wooster, Denison Are expectations too high?

First post ever. Long time reader. Hope I don’t annoy or disappoint. I’m a father of a 2019 Daughter (D?). D always assumed she would go to Ohio University. She wants to teach HS English and I am an OU alum. I never understood the LAC concept and my uninvolved parents didn’t take me on visits, etc. I’m learning a lot, but still playing catch-up even though I have a BBA. So I am committed to allow my daughter to explore all possibilities. So off to Denison for an official visit we went. Suffice to say D and the whole family were more than impressed. We sat down with the Education Studies Chair for an hour and got the whole LAC explanation. We also spent an hour with the softball coaches. Couldn’t have been more impressed. Beautiful campus. Nice students. Overly helpful professors. So now D really wants to explore the LAC’s in Ohio. Going to John Carroll soon as well as Wooster. Wooster is moving way up her list. They actually offer a path to a teacher certificate as well as the LAC education. The senior project/thesis sounds awesome too.

At any rate, I am realizing that I am woefully uninformed with this process. Gone are the days of a 3.0 being a good GPA. D has a 3.5 UW through sophomore year. No junior grades have posted until after final quarter. She has 2 AP’s and several honors and on pace to get a 3.8 for junior year. Calc/Physics/2 AP’s for senior year. So I anticipate her end of junior year grades to be 3.5UW/3.6W. She is a 2 sport varsity athlete, service club, choir, youth group. Some other small EC’s. She may not have patented an invention but she went all out in the EC’s she took part in. No weak EC’s that were rarely attended on her resume. And honestly, I have no idea how kids these days find time to do more than that because she is rarely home before 8PM as it is. She is a big reader/English type. She has only received one set of ACT scores. Got a 23. 29E 24R 22S 16M. Both schools superscore (Wooster for sure) and she has been concentrating on math and science. I would anticipate her final ACT to be 25-27 range.

She is pretty set on the LAC concept for college. But am I setting her up for failure taking her to see these schools? Seems like most kids on CC have a 3.9 and a 30 ACT. Is there any hope for a 3.6/25ACT/very busy girl to get into Wooster/Denison. Since when is a 3.5 a bad GPA? Assuming she has good recs/interview/essay, does she even have a chance or should I lower her expectations. She attends an extremely (overly) competitive public school. Thanks for any advice on school selection, chances for acceptance for a good LAC.

Welcome to CC. I have a whole bunch of thoughts running through my head, but I will try to keep it short so as not to overwhelm you.

First, both Denison and Wooster are schools which are featured in a book called “The Colleges that Change Lives” by Loren Pope. The premise of the book is that these schools do a great job of educating students who may not be the tippiest top students in their classes. By no means are these the only schools that do that. They are just the ones this author chose. The schools featured in that book established a consortium and they take their show on the road every year. You can see if they will be coming to a city near you at https://ctcl.org.

Second, my S18 applied to both of those schools. He applied early action to Wooster and was accepted with significant merit aid. He should be hearing from Denison any minute now. His GPA is similar to your D’s, but his ACT was significantly higher. Work on the ACT, but know that I think both of these schools have gone test optional. You can find the list of schools which have test optional admissions here: https://www.fairtest.org/university/optional.

Third, start familiarizing yourself with something called the Common Data Set. You can search for them on each college’s website. It took me forever to find Wooster’s, so I will post the link here: https://wiki.wooster.edu/download/attachments/114884994/2017-18+Common+Data+Set.pdf?version=1&modificationDate=1520478374437. These reports follow a standard format, so you can head directly to the subsections of most interest to you. Some schools provide extensive information; others leave sections blank. Wooster’s is good in the area of most interest to you: GPA and test scores in section C.

An ACT score of 23 is quite low. Apply, hope for the best, but prepare for the worst by applying to several less selective schools.

Congrats on your daughter! She sounds like a strong student with well defined interests. Try not to compare too much to the CC world! There are many wonderful choices in Ohio and I don’t think you are setting her up for failure. The ACT is a bit low for Denison and Wooster, but there is time for improvement. Does she know what math sections she didn’t do well in? You can request the test answers back and brush up on areas needing it. Or she could take the summer to focus on the multiple areas by taking practice tests at home. It’s definitely doable to increase 3-4 points with effort.

Do you know what you can afford? If a top choice college turns out to be unaffordable that would be unfairly getting your daughter’s hopes up. If you haven’t already, run the net price calculators to get a general idea what various schools will cost. Most are pretty accurate unless there are circumstances such as divorce, business, farm, etc.

Some good advice I’ve learned here on CC is to be sure to have a range of schools. They can be called reaches, matches, and safeties (or likely’s). These are schools where your daughter will range from bottom 25-30% to top 25-30% in the stats. Denison and Wooster are both great schools. (For disclosure my senior son has been accepted and is strongly considering attending Wooster next year (didn’t care for the hills at Denison).) My advice would be to keep the list larger now and let it narrow next year. Maybe add a few more schools. Mount Union is strong for education and has many student athletes. We know happy students there. Otterbein, Capital, Baldwin Wallace, Butler, and Slippery Rock are other possibilities.

Good luck and enjoy the ride. The next year will go by fast!!

We looked at five Ohio schools, Denison and Wooster among them. My impression is that significant merit is easier to get at Wooster than Denison. Nudge those test scores up a bit (maybe ask your daughter to try a SAT practice test to see if she does better with that format) and I think these are realistic options for her.

They are both lovely schools.

Wow!! Thank you so much for the great details. WE, D and I, are willing to do what we need to do to pay for either school. So if she gets in and wants to go I will make it happen. Do kids with average stats that are fortunate enough to be accepted still get some decent merit aid? I ran the calculator and it had us getting around 22k I think. Not need based. I understand that is just an estimate. I’m still thinking D would be lucky to get into Wooster. And if that’s the case why would they give her merit aid. Isn’t that reserved to woo the top kids? Don’t worry about overwhelming me. I’m grateful for the response. Very impressed with the folks on this site.

Good luck with upcoming admissions. Let me know how it goes. Do you know if test optional is a good idea? Isn’t that like screaming to admissions that your ACT is no good? And if that’s the case is a 3.6 enough to make up for it? What about this ED business?? It almost sounds like we will have to go ED to have a chance. We can pay 30k maybe but can’t pay full money. Will ED cause us to lose out on what little money we could otherwise be lucky to receive.

I agree 23 is low. But it was a first go at it. Plenty of other opportunities. And superscoring should help. Or test optional. Thoughts?

I’m trying to reply specifically to each person but I’m not sure if it’s working. The Common Data Set info was very encouraging and a great resource. I have literally spent a couple hours a night with D researching schools for a couple months now. I actually enjoy it. Glad I can help her. I actually think if her essay and recs are superb, and she can scrap together a few extra points by super scoring, maybe go ED, she could have a shot at Wooster. Otherwise she will do well at Ohio U, Mount Union, John Carroll etc. and have a blast I’m sure. I do fully believe that if you seek opportunity in college and engage the faculty, it’s hard to go wrong. All these schools will bring out great things in those that seek the guidance.

First – welcome! Second – breathe. Denison is test optional, and gives merit awards to test optional kids. Wooster requires scores, but my kid who turned out to be a miserable standardized test taker submitted his scores to Wooster and still got substantial merit award. The beauty of holistic admissions is that it really is holistic – the whole kid. I think the fact that my kid’s portfolio told a story – from his essay to his recs – about what kind of kid he was (not at the front of the pack, but a kind, thoughtful person who got along well with all kinds of people) helped with merit. So, for a student who is genuine, and makes the effort to connect, and understand the culture of a school, there are wonderful options. You might also take a look at Earlham, test optional, and just across the Ohio/Indiana border.

@topwop If she prefers ACT over SAT, we found the on-line practice through ACT’s website to be well worth the modest charge (she would get a year’s access). If she goes with SAT, Khan Academy is free and interactive and very helpful.

With her GPA and ECs, I think Wooster would be a match.

You may find this long thread from last year very helpful. It was for 3.0-3.4 GPA students with test scores consistent with those grades. Some kids had relative strengths in one or the other. The takeaway is that many students with equal or lesser stats than your daughter got into great places and many got merit.

Towards the end of the thread, results were compiled with reference to the applicants’ GPA and test scores so you can get some comparisons.

http://talk.collegeconfidential.com/parents-forum/1871275-parents-of-the-hs-class-of-2017-3-0-to-3-4-gpa-p1.html

Khan Academy is a free online resource to prepare one for the SAT (or to strengthen weak areas in math for the ACT).

It is free & it is outstanding. Good Luck !

Thanks!!

@Topwop I am not an expert but learned just like you. I went through the college search back-to back with my two oldest sons last year and (currently) this year.

One of the big challenges is figuring the size of school that your child likes and what would be best for them. You have accomplished that hurdle. And, it sounds like you may be focusing on Ohio which is another accomplishment (we are from NE Ohio). I would start making a list of the LAC / smaller schools with education programs and softball (it sounds like she is interested in continuing with her sport). You can easily find academic offerings and team information/strength online at the school’s website. Also, your daughter may use Naviance (or something similar) at school which can narrow her search down or pop up schools that she didn’t think of.

Many have mentioned to try to get her ACT score up which I agree with. The need for it to go up is not just for acceptance but, for possible merit money. Many schools do not publicize their cut-offs or chart for merit scholarships so she should get it as high as she can. Both my sons did an ACT prep course, one did it end of Junior year and the other beginning of Senior year. Their HS has a company who comes for two weeks and does group sessions (must reserve a spot and there is a charge). Check with your school and see what they offer. You can also research programs in the area. One S increased his score by 5 points (not normal) and the other by 3 points. They teach you how to take the test, shortcuts and teach you the math formulas that have been seen on recent/past tests. In order for a student to do well on the math portion, for example, they need to have taken Calculus. My S1 had Calc Senior year and S2 was in Pre-Calc Senior year. The class taught them things that they had not been exposed to yet. I would recommend to keep taking the test whenever it is offered, especially if you are interested in schools that superscore (certain sections can be heavily focused on when studying). My boys got angry at me about the multiple tests I made them take. This past Fall, S2 had a merit scholarship at one of his admitted schools and after his final ACT score was sent, they sent him a revised merit scholarship going from $6,000 to $8,000/yr.

I don’t know your financial situation but, I recommend you look at the “price tags” of the schools now rather than later and try to get a grasp on your EFC. FAFSA opens up in October. I have read horror stories on this site of people doing their FAFSA late in the process , just to realize their EFC was quite high and the school their child wanted to go to was not doable. Planning ahead now and asking questions is the smart thing to do! Good luck!

Colleges such as Wooster appear in a U.S. News list of “A-Plus Schools for B Students”:

https://www.usnews.com/best-colleges/rankings/national-liberal-arts-colleges/a-plus

As the title implies, these schools should be realistic admissions prospects for a potentially B+ student such as your daughter. Students with A averages may also, of course, choose to attend colleges from among those mentioned.

Are the GPAs listed online and in common data set UW or W. My D has only had 2 weighted AP classes. So
not much different. But it is a tenth. At this point, other than finishing Q4 strong, the only way to raise the GPA much is to use a senior year submission. But we won’t be able to do that if we go ED.

The Common Data Set and the articles posted here have helped tremendously. D has to keep working hard and get math and science ACT up. Then she’ll have a shot. Ball in her court. Lots to do between now and November!! Thanks to all.

I think the CDS is unweighted GPA. You should know that every college treats GPAs differently. They take the transcript and reconfigure the GPA based on what they think is important. No one knows how any particular college calculates GPA. I’ve heard some say they start with the grades then add/subtract rigorousness. Some only look at core courses (English, Math, Social Studies, Science). So, who knows?

My son’s first practice ACT was not so far off your D’s. He took a course where there were about 5 timed practice tests. His score improved about 5 composite points on the practices. For both of my kids, I think the practice tests were harder than the actual test. On the actual test, which he took only once, his composite was 7 points higher (not normal, but we were extremely pleased). The other thing that happened with the course was that his initial sub-scores were all over the place, but his official results had all sub-scores within 4 points of each other. So, definitely work on the practice tests for free/low cost on her own (if she’s that type of kid) or invest in a course (I knew mine would not do it on their own). Definitely have her try a practice SAT. Some kids do way better with one compared to the other. I had both my kids try both and then I let them pick which one they felt better about. There are a number of reputable online courses where cost is minimized there’s no classroom or travel. Also, look into what’s offered by your D’s school, your local library, etc.

@Topwop College of Wooster has non-binding EA and my impression was that acceptances are semi-rolling. My daughter applied in October and got a response by mid December including a generous merit scholarship. So ED might not be necessary and your daughter could keep her options open.

Also if you are willing to look outside of OH within a day’s driving distance, I can recommend Lawrence and Beloit (WI), Earlham (IN), Knox (IL) and many LACs in PA where your child might be eligible for merit money.

I was curious because you mentioned meeting with a coach. If your D is likely to be a recruited athlete, a lot can change for her. Does she want to play sports in college?