One Month Left -- Should I Expect All Rejections???

There’s only a little over a month left until Regular Decision results come out, and I know that I should just suck it up and wait until they come out, but it’s really freaking me out. I’ve received three results so far: UChicago (Deferred EA, withdrew), Northeastern (Accepted EA, 12k/year merit Dean’s scholarship, no Honors), and U of Delaware (Honors, 15k/year OOS merit scholarship, Distinguished Scholar which is for top 100 applicants). Waiting on Penn, Columbia, Emory, WashU, Georgetown, and Fordham. What worries me is that at Northeastern I did not get into Honors and got one of the smaller scholarships. And this scares me because NEU was one of my safety schools and I feel that if I can’t even get into their honors program or a decent scholarship I literally have no chance at any of my top schools. The only things that might help me with my RD applications are my essays (which I rewrote after submitting NEU application), an additional recommendation, a few awards, and some minor changes to my overall application. Based on my credentials below, do I stand a chance at any of my top schools, or should I prepare to transfer to a top school after my first year?

I’ll try to be as specific and clear as possible to be chanced accurately.

GPA: around a 3.9, straight A’s junior and senior year
Class Rank: 2/115 as of end of junior year
SAT: 1550 single sitting, 16/24 essay
ACT: 33 superscored, 9/12 essay (only sent to Penn, Georgetown, WashU, and Emory)
SAT Subject Tests: 680 Literature, 700 Math Level 2, 650 Biology-E (first sent to Columbia, first two to Penn, and all three to Georgetown)
APs Offered at School: 8, taken all of them
AP Exams: Calculus AB (5), English Language and Composition (4), Computer Science Principles (not reported), Biology (not reported), Chemistry (not reported), Macroeconomics (self-studying, taking), Government and Politics (taking), Human Geography (self-studying, taking), English Literature (taking), Calculus BC (self-studying, taking)

Senior Schedule: AP Literature, AP Computer Science A, Economics (no honors available), AP Government, Psychology/Sociology (no honors available), Honors Physics (no AP available), Gym/Health (required), Study Session (no classes available during this period), Calculus 2 at local private university for first semester (unable to take anything second semester)
Mid-Year Report: not sent yet, but all A’s

Awards:
two-time qualifier for National Championships of US Geography Olympiad
qualified for National Championships of US History Bee
helped team qualify for National History Bowl
qualified for National History Bee
1st place individual at Open Division of Quaker Fall Open*
1st place individual at Big Lake Brawl II and most powered toss ups award*
2nd place individual at Fall BrainBusters*
3rd place individual at Tri-State Tussle*
3rd place individual at Lehigh Valley Academy*
4th place individual at Manheim Township Academic Challenge*
lead team to qualify for three national championships: SSNCT, HSNCT, PACE NSC*
competing at SSNCT in Chicago at end of April for past three years
lead team to win NEIU Academic Challenge*
two-time winners of WVIA Scholastic Scrimmage*
NEIU Scholar of the Year (top senior selected from each school)
Outstanding Senior award for February
High Honor Roll every single quarter
AP + PLTW Student Achievement in Engineering

*refer to quizbowl competition

Extracurriculars:
Quizbowl Team (team captain, nationally-qualifying team as mentioned above, compete at tournaments around the area, plan to continue in college)
Minimum-wage job (nothing special, pretty typical, however I really love working, plan to hold a part-time job in college)
Writer/Editor-in-Chief of School Newspaper
Alto Saxophone player in Marching Band
Currently working on independent behavioral psychology project for PJAS (lol it’s pretty bad not gonna lie)
Staff Writer for online Democratic political publication (selected through application, spend a pretty decent amount of time and effort per article)

*I did a bunch of other extracurriculars throughout high school, and I mentioned them briefly in the Additional Information section. However, I explicitly mentioned that I chose to report these few because they are my most important.

Selected Major: undecided at most RD schools

Common App Personal Statement: rewrote for most of my RD schools, my first one was pretty bad and probably hurt my application, however this one is much better and most likely will help me a bit, worst case scenario it will be a neutral part of my application

Why Penn essay was pretty strong in my opinion, will probably help me a lot. Columbia essays were…interesting, let’s put it that way. Two Georgetown supplements were good, the other just eh. Emory both decent. No supplements for WashU.

Upper middle class male from Northeastern Pennsylvania, not first-generation, no legacy

Small public school, does not typically send students to top 50 schools with few exceptions, mediocre for our area

On my Penn application I explicitly said that I will commit if accepted.

Have already had two interviews for Penn and Georgetown. Both excellent I think, probably will help my application. Columbia interview is this Saturday.

So how do I look? Am I as bad as I thought? Do I stand a chance at all? Thank you for taking the time to read all this.

Doesn’t Northeastern have a sub-30% acceptance rate? Your list may have been kind of reach-heavy if that was your safety.

@bodangles It’s around 28% but it might be lower because of them having both ED and EA. It was more of a match than a safety. I treated it as a safety though because I know two people from my school who got into their Honors program with big scholarships and felt that if they could get in, I could too. It doesn’t really matter at this point though because I got in.

Your class rank is outstanding. Your numbers are very good (1550 SAT, 33 ACT superscored & 3.9 unw GPA) but your SAT subject tests are not. You certainly should be accepted to Fordham.

No sports, no leadership position, but editor-in-chief of school newspaper is noteworthy.

University of Delaware has offered a good package. If you really want Northeastern, then try to negotiate into the Honors College/Program.

With the ridiculously inflated SAT scores after the last two recentering of scores, it is very important to take the hardest courses offered at your high school & to do well.

My best guess is that your essays/personal statements may be a deciding factor.

Why is Penn your first choice school ? What do you plan to study ?

I would guess – which means nothing – you’ll get into Fordham, maybe one of Emory/Wash U/Georgetown, and maybe a 20-25% chance of getting into Columbia or Penn.

You’re already in with options, though, which takes off a lot of weight.

@Publisher I do have a leadership position, captain of quizbowl team, but that’s the only one other than editor-in-chief. I do not yet know what I’ll study, maybe Economics or English or Comparative Literature or Math or something else. Applied as undecided due to being unsure. Penn interests me because it’s pre-professional, would let me do a dual-degree with Wharton, urban environment, social life, overall fit, etc.

Why on earth would you expect all rejections?

And if that’s really what you think, and not another humble brag, then do something about it and apply to a safety with rolling admissions.

Why didn’t you apply to any LACs ?

@bjkmom I’m expecting all rejections because I see a ton of more qualified and more accomplished applicants on here applying to the same schools and it makes me feel uncertain about my chances. This is not a humble brag, and no I won’t apply to a safety with rolling admissions as I’ve already gotten into two pretty good schools, both of which I’d attend.

@Publisher Don’t like the small student population at LACs, most of them too rural for me, none of them really piqued my interest

@summerhazed
RD is hard to chance but ill do it anyway, only because you seem stressed.
Penn- Reach They love a high ranking however would have been better off not sending those SAT 2 scores

Columbia- Reach for everyone

Emory- Low reach, Great stats and love high ranking as well, They so not super score the ACT, so hopefully you sent your SAT to them as well.

WashU- Low Reach High stats and great ranking

Georgetown- Reach, They love a great ranking but you SAT 2 scores are again low

Fordham- Safety, they might yield protect you, so I would show some last minute demonstrated interest.

Thank you to everyone who responded!

Hey @summerhazed, I’m right where you are. We all are. The people you see and believe are competitive are also TERRIFIED OUT OF THEIR MINDS because we see people like you on here! Take a deep breath and eat some ice cream. You’ll be fine wherever you end up (:

You already have two schools under your belt. No reason to be freaking out. What will be will be. Most of the schools you are waiting for, especially the ones in the top 20 have less than 10% acceptance rate, so it will be anyone’s guess who will or will not get admitted. Just chill and forget about college for now. Since no matter what you do now, it really wouldn’t change anything for the better.

Update:
Accepted to Fordham with Dean’s Scholarship and both Emory and Oxford
Waitlisted at WashU and Georgetown
Waiting on Penn and Columbia

So I guess I was worried for nothing :)) I’m currently rejectionless!

@prezbucky You were right, I did get into Fordham and one of Emory/WashU/Georgetown!!! I’m just hoping your prediction of a 20-25% chance of acceptance to those other schools comes true

All right – Emory vs. Oxford poses an interesting choice if you decide on Atlanta: would you start out in the LAC-like atmosphere at Oxford or go to the U (Emory) all four years? That’s an interesting dilemma, as Emory College is the more “prestigious” route but that LAC/U hybrid education seems like an awesome opportunity too. I see pros and cons for both paths. Maybe @bernie12 can shed more light.

On a side note, i’m delighted that my guesses were more or less right, for once! lol

You got into Fordham and one of Emory/WashU/Georgetown.

I’m sticking with a roughly 25% chance at Columbia or Penn. Regardless, you’re more than good already.

No I definitely won’t go to Oxford, if I go to Emory I’m 100% going to Emory main campus @prezbucky

That will work!

And the Fordham scholarship is pretty sweet too. Fordham is a really good school in a great, great city. My family and I just spent a few days in NYC and i walked past, through and around the Lincoln Center (?) campus – my wife and our exchange student daughter spent a couple hours at AMDA, so I had time to kill. (and the LC campus is very close to AMDA…). You may be at Rose Hill primarily, but even if you had some LC classes, it’s in a really nice area with a ton to see and do.

If someone really wants to be in NYC at a 4-year school, it makes sense to apply to Columbia, NYU and Fordham – they’re all good, and they’re all right there. If you decide on NYC, you now own the privilege of studying there. At a big discount. Which is awesome.

Columbia or Penn would be icing on the cake, but your cake is already better than Betty Crocker.

@summerhazed : Then I am confused why you applied to Oxford…but I get the feeling I rather just not know. Also, NEU is a stats whore school, while it may be a “safety” for those with high stats, I don’t see how anyone can EXPECT high levels of merit aid from such a place. Overall, looks like you’re going to be alright regardless of what happens with the others.

@prezbucky Actually Fordham is still a bit too expensive for me still, especially since Lincoln Center (where I chose) is in the middle of Manhattan which is already crazy expensive. It’s nice to have the option, but unfortunately it’s not a choice for me.

@bernie12 I applied to both because there was no extra application fee and didn’t know much about the differences between the campuses at the time I applied.

@bernie12

Apparently you have not looked at Northeastern’s EA and RD decision threads here on CC. More 1500+ and 35+ applicants were denied than admitted. They do not like being considered a safety for anyone.