@monkey13 - did CMU look in your D’s book before they asked her to sing from Chicago? B/c a similar thing happened to my D in 2014. She sang, was asked to sing again, then they looked through her book and asked her to sing something else entirely. She gave it a go (it was a song she knew- but hadn’t prepared). We have a friend (and CMU student at the time) who was working auditions- he said that was a good sign, they want to see if you will give it a try.