Opportunity to Advocate for Ethical Use of the Wait-list

The National Association for College Admission Counseling (NACAC) Admission Practices Committee is in the process of updating their Code of Ethics into a Best Practices document. Yet, NACAC does not offer a membership category for college applicants so the voice of those most affected by NACAC’s policies is missing from the discussion. Also most colleges pay membership dues for their admission staff which creates a potential conflict of interest in which admission staff are more apt to advocate for the needs of their college over the needs of applicants.

Now is the time to advocate for NACAC to outline best practices for ethical use of the wait-list to address the needs of applicants.

Every wait-list offer should include:
1. Number of wait-list offers the college is extending
2. Details on how wait-list applicants are reviewed and it the process differs from the regular admission process (ex a need blind school becoming need aware, if a wait-list is ranked etc.)
3. Three years of historical data on how many applicants were offered a wait-list spot, how many applicants accepted a spot and how many applicants were eventually admitted from the wait-list
4. A regularly updated wait-list information landing page where an applicant can go to find relevant wait-list information for the current application cycle
5. The gold standard is to have all wait-list offers include a financial aid award letter

Some wait-list data that college’s withhold in wait-list offers is available on the Common Data Set, but this is very granular knowledge that some first generation college students might not know. This results in first generation college students making decisions without details available to more college savvy applicants.

Email NACAC’s leaders and Admission Practices Committee members and let them know you support the ethical use of the wait-list.