Out of these two applicants, who would you accept to Harvard?

@albert69 Hardship really boosts up a candidate. My friend had a 3.3 a 1530 SAT but her high school only had up to Calc AB so she rode the bus for an hour to take classes at a community college, she wrote about that and how she cared for her disabled grandmother and 4 sibilings while her mother was working 70 hour weeks and she’s going to Stanford

@turqluv - was that 1530/2400? For Stanford?

^ If it was 1530/2400, I suspect she can dunk a basketball.

“so she rode the bus for an hour to take classes at a community college”

Lucky that there was a community college within an hour and a bus to get her there. Rural kids aren’t so lucky.

I would say Applicant +1. Due to the Eagle Scout. You have to be very dedicated to become an Eagle Scout. Just my opinion :slight_smile:

@BldrDad. I could understand the hardship/having to work full or part-time to help a struggling family being helpful…but, whenever I see anonymous posters post anecdotal statements like:

attending Stanford…I just shake my head. But, I know the admissions office at Stanford don’t mind getting these “unrealistic” apps…after all, what’s another 5000-10,000 apps?

I’d say neither; both only have follow-the-dots pre-fab activities such as student govt, boy scouts, school clubs, NHS. I get no idea who these kids are, what interests them, what they’re good at.