Out of these two applicants, who would you accept to Harvard?

applicant #1
35 ACT, 4.0, 5-6 AP classes, student body president, Eagle Scout, NHS member

applicant #2
33 ACT, 3.997, 10 AP classes, NHS officer, science club president, but has to take care of family due to low income

This is super brief, but what do you think?

From the brief thumbnail, they are statistically the same. The difference is validation by the full student body for a leadership position versus compassion and overcoming hardship while simultaneously maintaining scholarship. Conventional wisdom would either say a dead heat, or give the tiniest sliver of an edge to the second candidate.

Why the “what if”?

In reality, in a real scenario, the recommendations and personal essays will sway the outcome more than these facts.

Applicant 2. I would be amazed by anyone who has to take care of their parents and still manages to take 10 AP classes (assuming they get 4s and 5s on them).

@KW1217 - Adding to the comment from @ItsJustSchool - Harvard won’t be choosing between them. Both are sufficiently qualified, and they will be considered separately, not matched against each other. The decisions will hinge on other parts of their applications. Remember there are two other possible outcomes - both will get in, or neither will.

The most likely outcome is that neither are accepted.

Neither. Apparently, they both forgot to write their essays.

Applicant #2

http://talk.collegeconfidential.com/massachusetts-institute-technology/939227-reminder-no-one-not-even-me-can-give-you-an-accurate-chance-at-mit-p1.html

This is fun!

Applicant #2

Guys, the OP likely understands that essays and recommendations will determine who’s admitted and who’s not. Set aside all those extra factors and just consider the application as is. The OP just wants to know who YOU would want to accept to Harvard, not who you think HARVARD would accept. It’s a personal choice hes asking you to make.

Both seem kind of weak for Harvard. What about ECs that aren’t “brain-based”? Sports, band, arts…

The only issue with applicant 2’s hook of taking care of family is proving it. Working a full-time job while in HS would be tangible proof of that.

NFN, interviewing for an Ivy I have seen MANY highly qualified low income applicants with great backstories of overcoming struggle who have been rejected.

Oh, and NHS is completely meaningless at most schools. Maybe clarify hours of community service (and hours of work can be compared to that).

Regardless of what OP would like us to do, it’s important for OP to understand that this sort of choice simply cannot be made without a fuller view of the candidates. I once had an opportunity to see a candidate’s file for a different school. If I showed you the quick credentials, you’d all be saying wow, this kid is a lock. It seemed that way to me too. But I was able to read her essays and see what her teachers said. It added dimension to the application and when this kid was denied, it wasn’t surprising. It cannot be stated strongly enough that we are not seeing enough here to make anything close to an informed judgment.

Can we say whether we value caring for a family member over a higher ACT? Sure. It just doesn’t get us very far.

Hmm… well #1 is weak if they don’t have stellar EC besides those listed. #2, is just like #2 but they have the family hook, and have more AP classes. SO, if they can prove they are really the lead of the family, they may have a better shot.

If you left it to the first three items, I might suggest that #2 is the stronger candidate. Maybe.

But it is impossible to compare the ECs without more context.

For example, it’s easily to imagine an NHS president who does very little for the organization while a “mere” NHS member does quite a bit.

Likewise, at some schools, student government positions go to the popular kids, not the ones who really get things done, while on the other hand a science club president might initiate a ton of new activities.

And how in the world can we compare, say, an Eagle Scout whose service project was providing meals to shut-ins with a kid who works an extra job to care for his family? Activities like these are not easily measured.

1

What do you even mean by this:

How exactly? Isn’t that the purpose of rent assistance, food stamps, Medicaid, day care assistance, free lunch, WIC, HEAP, ect.? How exactly is a teenager “taking care of the family?”

Many teens from all walks of life are employed in high school and help around the house and help care for siblings. When did this become a bump in college admissions?

@ProudMomx3, it might be far from your kids’ experience, and far from my kids’ experience, but it does happen and it can materially affect a child’s time management. My parents, for example, were immigrants and expected me to take care of my baby sister to an extent that would probably be frowned on today. Different times, but an ongoing issue for some kids today.

Applicant 2

Both the “applicants”, as presented, are boring and I am not eager to admit either. They both seem adequately academically qualified, so I would put both through to a “serious review” - read both their files and make my decision based on what I learn from their essays, teacher’s recommendations, etc.

Applicant #3: me.

But seriously, everyone is going to say #2 because they have the hardship aspect, but I don’t know how much that buys at colleges.