Parents are making me think twice

I was confident going into college apps and was pretty sure with my college list. But, now my parents and had I talk and it has made me reconsider what colleges I should be applying to. I was hoping anyone that stumbles upon this post would help me out and finalize my college list.
AP Chem: 3
AP Bio: 5
AP Calc AB: 5
Currently taking AP Calc BC, AP Comp. Sci., and AP Physics Mechanics
GPA: 3.73(UW) 3.91(W)
SAT: 1540
ACT: 34
Tennis Captain- Junior Year
HOSA Event Captain for Public Health at my high school
Placed 1st at HOSA Nationals at Public Health

Original:
U of M
MSU
Wayne
U of Toledo
Ohio State
UC Berkley

Feel like most of these colleges are out of my range

New:
Wayne State
Michigan State University
U of Toledo
Grand Valley State

Please help me decide what I should do, Thank you lots!

Was the discussion about what your parents could afford? If money doesn’t matter, I see nothing wrong with your first list.

Do you have a guidance counselor helping you at school…what do they say? Does your school have Naviance?

It’s impossible to chance you without knowing how many core classes you have taken, their rigor, number of honors/AP classes, essays, rec letters, etc.

With that said it is absolutely reasonable to have a balanced college list…a couple of reaches, 4-6 matches and 1-2 highly likelies. Do you have any budget limitations (how much will/can your family pay each year for college)?

No, my parents are really doubting my first list because of the difficulty. They believe I wouldn’t get into most of those colleges, so they want me to reduce the level of difficulty of the colleges I’m applying for.

I did talk to the counselor, and she told me to go for these colleges; but, my parents didn’t believe this was the correct decision.
I believe we are still using naviance. I updated my original post, and my parents are willing to chip a good portion of the tuition for undergrad.

No guidance counselor? Who is helping you with your apps? Who is writing your counselor rec?

What is your home state? Budget? What major are you considering?

Again, what most people do is have a balanced list which includes some reaches, targets and highly likely schools.

I do have a counselor helping me out and writing my counselor rec.
My home state is Michigan and was hoping to go in-state to save money.
I was hoping to go under the biology major and follow the pre-med track.

Those numbers might be in reach for Case Western and Rochester.

OP’s parents seem pretty realistic with that list of schools. Medical school is going to be expensive plus maintaining a high enough (~3.7 at a minimum) GPA will be difficult at some schools.

The Michigan schools on the list should be a match/safety for the most part.

Berkeley is not a good idea for premed, as it’s going to be expensive and a grade deflator. Agree with OP’s parents about removing it.

At Berkeley you fill be full pay as an OOS student. Ohio State will be relatively expensive compared to your in-state options, unless you get significant merit aid which is very competitive.

You should still apply to UM EA… again making that recommendation in the absence of lots of germane data.

Not sure of Toledo’s costs, but run each school’s net price calculator to get an estimate of your cost of attendance.

I see no reason not to apply to U of M and Ohio State as well. Maybe consider keeping the 2nd list, and adding back U of M and Ohio State. If you don’t get in, you don’t get in, but there is no harm in trying. You certainly are in range for those schools.

I don’t know what the costs would be, but the University of Cincinnati should be considered. Plus they have a medical school associated with it.

Keep UMichigan - as an instate applicant, you definitely have a chance.
I wouldn’t apply for Biology though, there’s currently an oversupply of them and the ROI is bad - look at all possibilities and be a bit creative. Do they have Biological Anthropology for instance? Also, look into LSA Honors.

TOSU is definitely a possibility, including honors college.
I’d definitely remove U Berkeley and replace it with UCincinnati (again: do your HW and look at all the majors they offer. Dig.)

Grand valley state had an excellent honors college. (Do apply!) UToledo would be another safety and it may offer a full tuition scholarship to a full ride.

I believe you can get into UMichigzn and Michigan State honors, so you’ll have excellent choices.

I like your first list except Berkeley. You have good stats. You’ll get merit at some schools. Knowing your budget would help. Maybe add Cinci or Dayton or Wooster.

With you being in-state in Michigan, I would definitely apply to the University of Michigan. Your SAT score is slightly above the 75th percentile for Michigan, and way above average. Your GPA is close to average for accepted students at Michigan. It is not a safety. However, my best guess is that it is a solid match and you are very likely to get in. Michigan is a great university, and I at least loved Ann Arbor when I visited (even if it was a bit cold the week that I was there). Being in-state will make it a bargain for you, particularly when you consider what a strong school it is. It will be academically challenging, but your strong SAT score suggests that you can handle it if you want to put in the effort. Please leave it on the list.

I am with your parents regarding UC Berkeley. Being out of state, it is a reach for you and will be expensive if you get in. I don’t see any advantage over Michigan.

I would leave Michigan State on the list. It is a very good university and is more certain than Michigan. I would leave Ohio State on the list also.

Basically I think that your original list is very good, except that I would drop Berkeley and add one more safety (probably taken from your second list).

“I believe you can get into UMichigan and Michigan State honors, so you’ll have excellent choices.”

We are all guessing, but I believe this also.

Just to clarify, the average uwGPA for the Class of 2023 was 3.9. And depending on the school at UMich, like Ross or CoE, the uwGPA might be a tick higher than that.

From the stats that I collected here on CC in the last admissions cycle, a 3.73 uwGPA would put you on the low end for accepted (they were deferred EA) in-state applicants. CC is a small potentially skewed sample size so please take it for what it is.

Also, the two most important factors per the CDS for UMich are uwGPA and course rigor.

The in-state acceptance rate for the Class of 2022 was 41%. A breakdown of the Class of 2023 instate vs OOS stats aren’t available yet.

I would definitely apply to UMich.

Please dont sell yourself short and believe in yourself. You have an excellent resume. You have a great shot at all the schools on YOUR list.

As much as I love Berkeley [came down for law school in 74 and never left], I cannot recommend it for OOS over Michigan. The two schools are both excellent. If you are going to reach, reach for the one that you have a better shot at and that would be more affordable.