Parents Don't Want Me Going Out of State

I’m from Minneapolis, Minnesota and I got accepted to all the schools I applied too. Two of them which are Macalester College in St Paul, MN and Notre Dame in South Bend Indiana. My stats are 3.96 GPA (unweighted) and 29 ACT score. My parents want me to stay in Minnesota and they don’t want me to go far away. Now, I got the financial aid letters from both schools and these are important bc I’m a low income first gen student. Notre Dame would be free of cost while I’d have to pay around $3,200 dollars for Mac. However, if I were to get the wallin scholarship I applied for, both schools would be free for me. (I get to know by april 15).My parents would obviously want me to go to Mac bc it’s free and close to home. I want to major in biology and follow a premed track btw. I’m leaning more towards going to Notre Dame and my college counselor also supports me with this decision. However, the only barrier are my parents. What should I do?

Why did they let you apply to Notre Dame if they won’t let you go?

Same question I’m wondering

Can your GC speak with your parents?

Is Macalester affordable if you don’t get the scholarship?

To be fair, a lot of parents who felt comfortable with far-away colleges at the end of 2019 are now feeling much less comfortable with distance because of the pandemic. It’s not a completely irrational concern.

OTOH, it’s about an 8 hour drive from Minneapolis to South Bend. At least it’s driveable in a day if need be. It’s not like, say, a student from San Diego going to Cornell.

That said, Macalester is an excellent school, and certainly worthy of consideration. Congrats on having great options!

Try to bring your parents concerns into focus. Is it that they want to be able to see you more often? Is it that they’re worried about how you’d get home in an emergency? If Notre Dame is really what you want, try to problem-solve their specific worries - for example, look at the academic calendar for times when you could visit, and for the most affordable ways to get home. Show them information about the parent programming at Welcome Weekend and how they could be part of that. Validate their feelings and concerns and see what you can suggest to make the greater distance work for them.

If your parents want you to stay close to home and that means attending a great college like Macalester, then you stay close to home and attend Macalester. They’re your parents, They have their reasons. They’re entitled. End of conversation.

^^^Found @Spideruwu ’s dad^^^

If both are free, it’s not their money and therefore the child’s decision.

Acknowledge you understand their opinion but you feel more drawn to Notre Dame. Research transportation options home.

I agree with @aquapt. Find out the specifics of why your parents don’t want you to go to ND. Is it the virus? Is it the transportation to and from (it’s not the easiest drive since you need to go through Chicago)? Is it that they think you’ll do better at a smaller LAC for pre-med?

Once you understand their specific reasons for preferring Mac, you can develop mature and solid counter arguments for ND.

Congrats on great options!

Congratulations on having two excellent choices. My son is at ND and his best friend from HS is at Macalester, though neither are premed. We live on the west coast.

For us, part of the agreement of him going so far away was that he could only come home for Christmas and summer. He stayed on campus for Thanksgiving and went to a friend’s house for spring break.

The two other kids we had dinner with in February are both premed at Notre Dame. ND has unbelievably good advising across the board, plus extra for those looking at med schools, plus academic support and roughly 80% placement rate for those who choose to apply. Most do. It does not tend to weed out a bunch of kids along the way like some colleges.

Someone more familiar with Mac can answer for them. S2’s friend is ready to graduate and move on, though he has liked the school.

However, it may require their cooperation on financial aid forms to make them free. Given the lack of financial obligation on the parents’ part (and the fact that the student’s preference is the less expensive one), many here would say that it should be the student’s choice, but the parents have all of the power in this situation (as with most traditional college student situations) and can force their choice on the student (even though many do not do so if cost limitations are satisfied).

The student’s perspective of what is more cost effective often is not the same as the parent’s perspective. Equal tuition does not always equal the same COA. Parents do have a say and are not necessarily trying to ruin a students experience by setting limitations. Most parents want the best for their children and sometimes the students need guidance. Other times the COA will determine the quality of life that the family members back at home will have. Students, including my own at times only have tunnel vision and want, what they want, when they want it. Part of adulting is compromise, listening to another perspective and considering others.

@Mwfan1921 I would have to take out loans to attend Mac if I don’t get the wallin scholarship. However, my parents and I don’t want to take out loans.

@aquapt @momofsenior1 before it was because they wanted to see me more often and the issue of transportation. Now it’s all that plus concerns about my safety and health (bc of the virus).

Do your homework about their concerns…

I have a few thoughts to get you started:

  • arrange for weekly facetime visits with your family
  • research transportation options to/from ND - is there a university ride share board? Typically that would be your most convenient and cheapest option. Public transportation options?

In terms of the virus, it’s a scary time for parents. Again, equip yourself with statistics.

  • I would remind your parents that Mac is in St. Paul which is a much bigger, more populated, area than South Bend.
  • MN has almost double the number of positive cases than IN (as of basically now).
  • Research how ND has handles their Covid-19 response too.

Good luck OP. Stay calm and present facts.