<p>Went to the 8 of the Best Colleges tour. My initial impression: It was three colleges too many. Right after the presentation, we were all comparing notes and found ourselves blanking on who said what, so we each walked away with a general positive or negative impression, but few specifics. But that’s OK. I guess ds can use this as a stepping-off point for rather he wants to do more investigation.</p>
<p>After the welcome they did a presentation of how they’re similar (small, selective), what a liberal arts education means, etc. Then there was a portion about what they look for admissions-wise and about financial aid. I thought the financial aid portion was odd. The guy recommended figuring out your EFC so you know but not to let finances keep you from applying wherever you want. Really? </p>
<p>The rest of the presentation was a PowerPoint. Each rep got about six minutes a piece. Some people came across as very dry; some were funny and entertaining. If they reflect their schools, it was easy in my mind to come away with favorites and not-so-favorites. </p>
<p>The best thing to come out of it for me was that it confirmed my favorable impression of Macalester. Ds is going up there with friends this summer to tour and interview there and at Carleton, so I was glad we liked the rep and presentation.</p>
<p>The next best thing it did was knock Colorado College off the list (in my eyes; we’ll see what ds thinks).</p>
<p>A surprise favorite for everyone (but me) was Grinnell. I’d always thought that would be a good place for ds but never pushed the issue because it’s in the middle of Iowa.
We have all this literature from them; I wonder whether ds will want to pursue it.</p>
<p>Dh loved Kenyon, ds2 and I loved Haverford, and ds1 liked Connecticut College, though he couldn’t identify why afterward.</p>
<p>Claremont McKenna gave us good info since ds is interested in Pomona :). Sarah Lawrence is a no-go.</p>
<p>I think this kind of multi-school presentation is best if you know you’re interested in a particular school and then can use it to get some face time with the rep. If you had no idea about any of these schools going in, I don’t see how you could discern between them to come up with a clear favorite or three afterward. It was too dark to take notes.</p>