Parents of the HS Class of 2014

<p>

I guess. If the teachers filled out the MIT LOR form, they will be well prepared for the CA LORs. In addition to the “essay-like” LOR (which while more directed than the typical LOR, is nevertheless recyclable for other schools), the MIT form also asks some specific questions (e.g., Do you have any reservations about the applicant’s character? If yes, please explain on a separate sheet of paper.").</p>

<p>I can’t imagine a situation where, having done an MIT recommendation, the teacher is put out at having to do the CA LOR. I’m not sure that it works in the opposite order :-)</p>

<p>For those of you whose kids took Sept ACT, S’s writing score was just posted (so now I’m assuming it will get sent).</p>

<p>collage1 - I know what you mean about the supplements. With my S, he has come across several schools that ask him to expand on a significant EC and that is exactly what his CA essay is about. He is a theater kid so a lot of his ECs are related to theater. At least the ones which are most meaningful to him. So it’s hard to find a different spin on the same subject so it doesn’t sound like the same thing or make it sound like that’s all there is to him.</p>

<p>It looks like the glitches with the Common App are taking their toll. Apologies if this is a re-post, but Duke has already announced that it is pushing its ED deadline back a week to November 8th since everyone is having problems with the system. </p>

<p>Since I don’t have a 14er, I haven’t looked to see if other schools are also doing this, but my guess is that y’all should be able to compile quite a list of these delays. FWIW, many schools delayed ED/EA deadlines last year by a week or more due to Hurricane Sandy without appearing to have any adverse effect on their ability to make decisions by mid-December. </p>

<p>[Duke</a> Pushes Back Its Early Decision Application Deadline | Duke Today](<a href=“http://today.duke.edu/2013/10/earlydecision]Duke”>Duke Pushes Back Its Early Decision Application Deadline | Duke Today)</p>

<p>incadinca: No need to panic. The toughest part is to get him to write something down and he has done that!</p>

<p>“I don’t want to make him start from scratch because feel that will just demoralize him further.” Completely agree.</p>

<p>Take a good long look at his first draft and identify his main theme (his response to the prompt). Then look for anything in the essay that supports that point. Isolate each of his examples (Maybe you can think of an experience in his life that might also support his main point. Ask him about that.)</p>

<p>Consider sitting down with him and ask him questions about each of those incidents that he is using to support his main point. The key is to get him to tell a story about each of those incidents. Take notes (Boys often talk more creatively and discriptively than they write). Use his words telling you about these events to enrich his first draft.</p>

<p>You will likely end up with too many words (more than 650). That is okay. It is easier to edit and revise down to 650.</p>

<p>Don’t be discouraged at all - he is well on his way.</p>

<p>Want to thank everyone for sharing their circumstances and journeys. It has been most helpful to me as I have been reading through the forum. For me, I can’t believe how detailed this process is. We are very lucky that my daughter really has one school that is her favorite and, from what we have heard, she will get very good merit aid there. However we are being conservative and she is also applying to a state school (safety in acceptance and cost) and another LAC (mainly to compare the financial packages). And to make it exciting she is also applying to a reach school.</p>

<p>We did have a disappointing thing last night. She has asked two teachers for LOC to upload to the CA (for the school she loves and the reach school). She got her first one last night and it was…well, bland. It was very positive but was mainly a recap of her “resume” sheet. He was her teacher for three years, teacher advisor when she was Treasurer of the Sophomore class and she is currently one of his 2 teacher aides. And he couldn’t add a “personal” paragraph about any of that? And he seemed to emphasize her activities that were lower on her resume…he went on and on about her involvement in our school’s Key Club and never mentioned her 6 years of working with disabled kids on weekends. Just disappointing. We are really hoping the other LOR will be more personal. Have any of you ever experienced this?</p>

<p>Thanks for letting me join you on this bumpy journey!</p>

<p>Good morning! I apologize if this question has been asked and answered! </p>

<p>On the CommonApp, if honor societies (NHS etc.) are listed in the Education/Honors section, should they be listed again in the Activities Section?</p>

<p>Thanks!</p>

<p>Glido, thank you for the encouragement! You are right, getting started is the hardest part.</p>

<p>Another question, what do people think about submitting an essay on the shorter side (say 350-400 words)? Part of the problem with S’s essay is that he padded it out with extraneous stuff to make it close to 600 words. He is afraid to submit something much shorter.</p>

<p>girlsmom–how did your daughter get to see the LOR? She didn’t do the FERPA waiver waiving her rights to see it, or your school asks the student to upload them to CA? I’m wondering if the teacher, knowing your D would see it and read it, made it really “safe” and bland. Whereas if they thought she wouldn’t see it, he might have been more open and specific. </p>

<p>incadinca – I read on this blog that if it shows the personality of your kid and makes the reader feel like they’ve met him, then it’s long enough.</p>

<p>^^ classof2015 – she just asked him for a LOR and he actually gave a copy to my other daughter16 (since D14 was sick) and said he didn’t know how to upload to CA and to get together with Guidance if she needed it uploaded. Actually we thought he would give to guidance and then let her know it was turned in. We figured he was the “expert” in this as he has done several letters every year. But you make a good point - -we might not even see the other teacher’s LOR. So I guess you are just kind of blind when you chose which one to send?</p>

<p>Classof2015, I’m not sure that you can see a LOR before it is submitted even if you didn’t waive your rights. I think you have to request a copy from the school that you’re applying to, but I’m not sure.</p>

<p>My son has seen one of his recommendations, another teacher said that he’d be shown a copy but he hasn’t seen it, and the third has been mum on the topic. Officially, DS waived his right to see them.</p>

<p>EDITED TO ADD: cross-posted with girlsmom14and16’s response</p>

<p>Yes, usually you are submitting LOR’s blindly. I taught 8th grade math last year, and got asked to do a few LORs for private HS admissions, and I did send copies to the parents after writing them, but I also sent them directly to the schools (as requested) and they didn’t see them until after I had sent them. </p>

<p>At our HS, certain teachers have reputations for writing great LORs which a lot of kids rely on for deciding who to ask and which letter(s) to send. For DS11, as it happened, both the teachers he asked gave him copies, which helped us choose which to send where. For DS14, one teacher has already given him a copy. The other teacher has not and most likely will not, but she made the offer rather than DS asking her, and what she said to us in that offer led us to believe that it will be a good letter (DS14 is in a kind of special situation that caused her to make the offer). The one we have the copy of is nice and personal, but because the teacher was for a non-core subject, it will probably be the “backup” letter for schools that allow two. (Nowhere that he’s applying requires two.)</p>

<p>Received emails from two of my S’s CA schools. One said that they are just now able to download the applications and the other said that they have been verifying the information they received. They both said we should receive a confirmation email soon. At least they both new an application was submitted. So it seems like they are starting to get a handle on the CA situation.</p>

<p>Ixnay – you’re right – you can only request to see them after a school makes its decision (I believe that’s how it works). I just wasn’t familiar with the student being able to submit them (our school uses Naviance). </p>

<p>I feel bad for girlsmom’s D – a lackluster LOR when there was a lot they could have said to make it stand out. Some teachers I think are just phoning in these letters. S has one who is known for writing good ones (like at mathmomvt’s school). The other teacher, according to the local gossip mill, “hates boys” and S is…you guessed it…a boy. But he said she liked him and he did well in her class, so fingers crossed.</p>

<p>Yeah, I had the exact same question … how did the family get to see the LOR!?</p>

<p>Very odd.</p>

<p>All college admin officials we’ve met say they “disregard” non-waived LORs.</p>

<p>For my older son a much sought after teacher approached us about writing his LOR (I actually cried - lol) He was the top english teacher in the school talking about my math/science kid Recommendations were much needed in his apps, and we never saw it, but I assume it was very good.</p>

<p>For my d - she wrote a list of who she wanted to write for and then the teachers write down who they’re willing to write for - then the admins match them up. No clue what the letter looks like, thankfully her schools don’t rely that much on them. I only say that because I was surprised by who she ended up having write it. </p>

<p>I just want to be done with this already. I feel like I could really go for a cocktail or two over this. And yet, as much as I want to know, and go dorm shopping, etc. at the end of the day it will be one empty house and I’ll be a little out of sorts.</p>

<p>eyemamom–You’re just now thinking about cocktails? Way ahead of you–since the first PSAT last year! :)</p>

<p>go2girl is inching toward hitting send. I have a feeling we will be up against the early application clock deadline. Why her teachers have decided to inundate seniors this fall semester with research papers, etc. is beyond me. </p>

<p>I’m finding that the LORs from independent reviewers for school-sponsored scholarships to be even more daunting. </p>

<p>Duke/UNC-Chapel Hill’s Robertson scholarhsip was on the list until we looked at the crazy questions they want answered from recommenders (keep in mind, these would not be teachers but coaches, extracurricular mentors, etc. who probably have demanding jobs and families of their own…) </p>

<p>Recommenders will be asked to respond to the following questions:
• What sets this individual apart from his/her peers and/or other people that you know?
• How does this student inspire and generate energy in others? How does s/he command the attention and respect of others? Has the student truly motivated, delegated to and led others or simply held a position and done all the work himself/herself?
• How is this student motivated by her/his curiosity and passions? How does s/he exhibit a thirst for knowledge and improvement?
• How has this student dealt with transition or uncertainty? We are especially interested in resiliency and resourcefulness.
• How does this student demonstrate integrity and moral courage? Has there ever been an instance in which the student took a different stance on an issue than his/her peers?
I’m surprised they forgot to ask “Describe the contents of his/her soul?”
Needless to say, school has come off the list. And it’s too bad–maybe it’s their weeding process but from where I sit, it’s one thing to ask the kids to write numerous essays; it’s another thing to ask recommenders…</p>

<p>With the FERPA waiver I don’t even think you can see it after the admit (or deny). Just think if students demanded to see LORs after signing a waiver and being denied admission so they could dissect each part of their application. LOR’s would never have any personal statements and the FERPA would be meaningless. Both my boys signed FERPA waivers at school to cover the GC, transcripts, etc., and also signed the electronic FERPA on the Common App. I do know that some teachers will give copies of the letter to families. With S2 the teachers mailed them directly and he was never given copies. With S3 we opted to have the teachers give the completed, sealed (signed across the seal), LORs to us for mailing. There were a certain number of CA’s, and a certain number of generic for non-common app schools. Some had to accompany the transcript so we needed to get it to the GC, some schools only took one. With the amount of work they had already done, and the number of exceptions we felt just giving it back to us was easier. So, we made sure all got where they needed to be. He ended up with two extra copies due to schools he’s not applying to. Until the process is done and he’s totally sure they sit in a safe place. then they will be returned to the teachers. TBH I haven’t been the least bit tempted to look, and if he has been he certainly hasn’t mentioned it. I specifically do not want to read them for the exact reason that girlsmom14and16 is disappointed now. Why read something that is done, sent to the schools, and can not be changed? It will only cause undue stress if it is not a personalized LOR you felt the teacher was going to write. Then there is weeks/months waiting for decisions worrying if it harmed admissions chances. Don’t misunderstand me, I am not insinuating girlsmom did anything wrong! If the letter is given to you to see what else do you do but read it? I’m just pointing out I have never seen any of my boys and am very glad.</p>

<p>The kid waives his or her <em>right</em> to see the LOR. The teacher has not promised not to provide a copy of it to the kid. Some teachers will provide a copy, but once the waiver is signed, it’s completely within the teacher’s discretion to do so or not – although I agree with the comment above that I wouldn’t have wanted to read them for my older kid. Just one more thing to fuss over that isn’t within your control anyway.</p>

<p>

Hummm, it could be um different (I’ll avoid the word ‘worse’). This is our caboose so technically we should be empty nesting. S1 (21) is still in permanent residence, works, pays his own bills, etc. After a couple of semesters at CC he decided it wasn’t what he wanted. Some don’t always launch right away so as hard as it is, this is what we’ve raised them to do. When they take a different path it can be frustrating. S1 will get there, but he has definitely made a few things harder on himself. Having said this, he’s a joy to have around, never drank underage, doesn’t stay out late, no trouble in or out of the house, and they love him at work. He has a few friends that did launch on time and were home for good by May due to too much partying and not enough studying. I’ll take indecision over substance abuse any day.</p>