Parents of the HS Class of 2026 (Part 1)

Yeah — that’s fantastic!!! So happy for her!

Oof, that’s a good reminder!

We put down a housing deposit at a school, because S26 applied for a specific LLC and you could only do that after paying a non-refundable housing deposit. So we did, though we have not yet paid an enrollment deposit. I will have to go back and read if that forced us into a housing contract. Although I think this is the school he will likely end up at.

This school is a regional public and is not my favorite. BUT, their communication is absolutely incredible and what I was used to seeing from LACs when D22 applied. Very personalized, warm, welcoming communication. It oozes “we want you”. I never expected that from a public school. S26 turned 18 on Sunday, the Business School sent a text message. The coordinator for the LLC set up a groupme for all accepted students to meet up and get to know each other. In person events in our city attended by deans, etc. S26 and I discussed this this weekend and he agreed that they make it very hard for his other schools to catch up. Those are remarkably quiet in comparison.

5 Likes

If that is the case for my daughter’s options -she’s just going to end up with last pick housing. We just can’t afford to put down multiple housing deposits.

But that WAS the case for my son’s school. Howeer, we were lucky and knew that he wanted to go there very early (state public). His early deposit allowed him to enter the lotto early for housing and he ended up with a room with a bathroom attached! But honestly -it was STILL your typical dorm. If he had done it late, he still would have gotten a room -so in the end i’m not sure how much it mattered. (Although he said having a toliet and shower he only shared with his roommate was awesome.)

1 Like

In the case of UNM that I mentioned, the problem appeared to be that there was no communication between the enrollment/admissions department and the housing department. The parent & student assumed that if you did NOT pay the enrollment deposit, that UNM would automatically know/see that the student wasn’t enrolled AND then would automatically cancel the housing contract for them.

None of that happened. So both the parent & student never actually cancelled the housing. And the college’s policy is to bill you anyway even though you’re not officially enrolled. If you don’t want a housing bill, then you have to notify housing that you’re cancelling your housing sign up.

2 Likes

Not only is that ridiculous on the face of it, it would make me worry about other disconnects behind the scenes at UNM.

4 Likes

Lots going on here this week and next week!

  • big presentation today in D26’s science capstone class
  • big presentation in the math capstone class
  • completing recorded/video presentation w/BFF for their Spanish capstone class
  • big 50+ page project/paper due end of the week in her Middle Eastern Culture & History class. Hers is on Turkey. So now we ALL know a lot about Turkey because she talks about it a lot. :slight_smile:
  • senior walk next week, senior pics for the yearbook
  • 1st official weekly blog post for senior projects
  • senior trip

Counselor told everybody in the college counseling class that you shouldn’t pay an enrollment deposit at >1 school because doing so is unethical. Also said to not pay an enrollment deposit until you’re absolutely sure that’s where you want to attend.

D26 still needs to decline the offers from the 3 other colleges she got into. That hasn’t been a priority yet. She’ll probably do that in the next week or 2.

2 Likes

I’ve noted this before - we are in an extended good friends, friends and then the acquaintances crowd here. Mostly Upper Class (outside of the Middle class income band) folks - lots of double professional couples, business owners, and olde family money in these overlaps. We are personally aware of a number of families who have done exactly that (paid deposit down on more than one school so they’d have more time to decide / visit) and done it for multiple kids over time. These are the type of folks that always share how they have ‘gamed the system’ one way or another - they share how they are sometimes able to get it refunded when they tell the school their child was taken off the wait list for another/other school. I don’t generally say much (Spock eyebrow) but I find it distasteful considering knowing there are kids on wait lists who would love to attend the ‘second choice loser’ in these tactics.

People.

5 Likes

Woohoo! Your D26 has some amazing options! We love Pitt in this house - my D26 is seriously considering it and we have a nephew there right now. Reach out if you have any questions.

2 Likes

It looks like many of your kids are already narrowing down their final decisions. Unfortunately, we have a very long way to go before we get to that point. Although my kid has 3 solid acceptances (woohoo), she is still waiting on 8 more decisions, including 2 deferrals and 6 RDs! Two of these schools (one hard target, one reach) have been in her top three since the very beginning.

8 Likes

The waiting game is SO HARD!

1 Like

So as we hear back from schools, I’d love to hear some of the criteria on your kid’s decision making spreadsheets. One thing we didn’t consider with our older kid was ease of getting to and from campus- he ED’d to his favorite school, we had only visited once and didn’t really think about it. Now we’re looking at admitted student days at various places and seeing the differences in airfare is eye opening! Anything specific on your kid’s list of must-haves?

3 Likes

Funnily enough, a new criteria that just recently was added (or D26 is considering) is language requirements. She’s not historically worried about this at all, but AP Spanish is taking its toll. She’s the only non-native speaker in her class, so her set of struggles is completely different than her classmates. So, the need to continue a language or even get a high score on the AP exam to place out of a language is now a potential consideration. This, however, may change depending on how she does on her next exam, lol.

Other criteria really hasn’t changed much. She’s becoming much more open about her major, so it’s not just about how good a school is in one field, but how much opportunity she might have if she switches major. Location was always important (accessible to transit, walkable areas, etc.), so that’s still an important criterion, but it narrowed her initial list at the beginning.

In fairness, she’s really still not thinking about anything until she gets her March decisions in hand, so I suspect more changes in thinking before we even get to admitted student visits, etc.

4 Likes

Here’s how things played out for D26:

  • Not too far away from home = 1 day’s driving distance or max 2-2.5 hr plane ride on a direct flight
  • Not too cold in winter = snow a couple of times in winter is ok, but prefer being able to get away with a heavy sweatshirt most of the time outside in winter
  • strength in major = Is it on the NSA’s list of colleges considered an Academic Center of Excellence in cyber operations/cyber security?

The ‘final score’ for each decision factor = the score * its weight. So 5 * 5 = 25.

Priority (H, M, L) Score (1-5, 5=high) Weight
(High=5, Med=3, Low=1)
U of A final score Score (1-5, where 5=high) Weight
(High=5, Med=3, Low=1)
UTSA final score Score (1-5, 5=high) Weight
(High=5, Med=3, Low=1)
UTulsa final score Score (1-5, 5=high) Weight
(High=5, Med=3, Low=1)
Univ of Incarnate Word
Cost high 5 5 25 5 5 25 3 5 15 1 5 5
Not too far away from home high 5 5 25 3 5 15 2 5 10 3 5 15
Not too cold in winter medium 5 3 15 5 3 15 2 3 6 5 3 15
Strength in major high 5 5 25 5 5 25 5 5 25 5 5 25
major doesn’t require physics or chem high 5 5 25 5 5 25 5 5 25 5 5 25
major doesn’t require 1.5 yr of Calculus + Linear Algebra high 5 5 25 4 5 20 5 5 25 5 5 25
Ease of getting internships med-high 5 4 20 3 4 12 5 4 20 ? 4 0
good job placement #s at or after graduation med-high 5 4 20 4 4 16 5 4 20 ? 4 0
Campus safety medium 4 3 12 3 3 9 5 3 15 ? 3 0
On campus community of nerdy students low 5 1 5 ? 1 0 5 1 5 ? 1 0
Final total score 192 162 161 110
6 Likes

So, there was a spreadsheet initially with various things but some are now crystallizing as decisions come in and things that fell under the “con” column get looked at again vs other admits. In particular here one school with secondary admission to major no longer a real option (no admit yet - apparently no place to withdraw app on portal or they would’ve already), and one largely commuter school - initially thought large dorm population and close knit major would offset that but rethinking now (not totally out of consideration yet though)

Ease of getting to - yes and no. Everywhere is a flight away and I don’t think there’s a significant enough difference in airfares between destinations for that to factor in. At some schools it’s easier to get to the school from the airport than others. Is ease in the plus column, yes. Is it a dealbreaker for the others for something that’s only happening a few times a year, probably not.

First cut was just offering the major - a lot of colleges don’t - and being in a blue/purple state (this is about LGBTQ and reproductive rights in state law - not about politics on any particular campus). Those two already cut a lot of potential colleges out. Must haves include being able to sing in ensemble etc as a non music major. Ideal is a Pokémon club.

Trying to remember other factors. I know food was not on there! Weather C26 is not fazed by - all the options have a real winter. I probably left something critical out!!

4 Likes

We have a TON of waiting still do – so we are in the same boat as you. Some good acceptances so far - but still more EA and more RD (including some deferrals). Her favorites are in the RD batch although she has tried not to get her heart set on any one college.

She is dealing with the anxiety of waiting by embracing her favorite acceptance so far (St Olaf). Toward that end, she has started practicing Norweign on DuoLingo :rofl: (that is likely the language she would take if she attended St Olaf).

9 Likes

A Target and at least one really good thrift store. These never would have even come up if we hadn’t visited Miami University -which doesn’t have a Target :rofl:

But more seriously - I think the big take away for her is that she defintely needs to see the surrounding area as well as the college campus. This is something we didn’t think about before.

3 Likes

Timely that this came up here as we just spent 60 hours ‘all together’ at home over the weekend and are doing the "here are the 5 schools you are in and you’ll hear from the other 4 that would be in your still candidates list within the next 3 weeks or so - can we maybe start thinking about how you’re going to choose…and don’t say “hat please”.

Outside of Academics, Ranking/Prestige, Career Placement / Starting Salaries, Grad/Prof School Placement, COA…

Weather:
Cold-ish / Cold versus Hot (Child, pray tell why you’d apply to Texas, Florida, Florida State and Georgia if this was going to be a deciding factor)

Travel:
Car vs Flights, Car Drive in hours, Travel to Airport, School shuttles or Uber?

Student Recreational Center:
Size, Quality, ‘classes’, Campus location
(This may be a cut threshold as she’s been to Texas Recreational Centers and thought they were awesome - but just wait til she see Cordova at Purdue. I’ve never seen anything like it.)

Ramen:
Dining hall availability or immediate off campus and QUALITY?

Grocery Store Options:
(example - Ramen components)

Boba:
See Ramen

Campus area Record Stores:
Yes, music records (never you mind that you can order them on Amazon and have them delivered to your dorm in 72 hours or less)

5 Likes

Probably should have added ‘vibe’ to the list, but that sort of came later on in the decision process.

A lot of schools never made it on the list to apply to. Some of them eliminated from the running were places like:

  • UNLV - had the right major, was affordable, warm weather, fit the bill for the location criteria. But D26 hates Las Vegas. Like she REALLY can’t stand it.
  • Univ of Nevada-Reno - counselor suggested to consider, but that got axed because it’s definitely too cold there.
  • Univ of Utah - counselor suggested. Too cold. Kid didn’t want to live in Utah.
  • Univ of Alabama-Huntsville - too far away. But it would have filled every other category.
  • Univ of Houston - specific major she wanted wasn’t at the main campus, I think. And D26 was like “Eh, I don’t know if I want to live in Houston.”
  • UT-Dallas - “feels like a sad office park here.”
  • couple of college in Florida - too far away. But would have fit all the other criteria.
  • UNM - fit all the criteria except D26 didn’t like the vibe there.
  • NMSU - same as above.
  • University of the Pacific - counselor suggested. It’s in Stockton, CA. Hard to get to from where we live. NOT close to an airport. Would require a plane change just to get home to AZ. Hard no.
  • University of Redlands - didn’t have right major.
  • Univ of Colorado-Colorado Springs - had the right major, would have been affordable. Got axed because “too cold.”
  • couple of public universities in Virginia (no, not UVA) - had the right major, but were ‘too far away’ and too close to a toxic grandparent. D26 didn’t want the grandparent to be close enough that grandparent would just suddenly show up on her doorstep (which the person has been known to do before).
1 Like

I love the part about your daughter learning Norwegian! Absolutely agree about delving more into the schools that you already know want you!

3 Likes

I was super excited about the spreadsheet I had created, but I don’t think she will be using it. She’s down to 2 (waiting on 1 more) and I think it will come down to how she feels at the admitted students days. And both schools we (parents) will be perfectly happy for her to attend. If there isn’t a clear “winner” then I get to pull out my spreadsheet! And if neither give her good feelings, then we will be scrambling to add OOS admitted students days. At this point she has decided to stay in-state though.

D26 got an admitted student packet from a smaller school today (she mostly applied to big schools) and they win for best packet - they sent a brochure to our dog (with his name on it) letting him know his human will be going off to college AND a bandana for him with the school logo. SO cute.

14 Likes