Is there any way you’ve helped her think about that prioritization/elimination? To be fair, my D26 is sitting at 4 acceptances right now and they’re all options for different things. Well, Pitt is the one that she doesn’t know much about. It was my suggestion to just send the app in early and see what happens just to get the very early “You’re going to college!” thing. But I have done more of the research on Pitt than she has, which is turning out to be remarkably useless right now (and it’s turning into one of my favs!)
It has not been easy! My D is notorious in our household for having trouble deciding things (if we go out to eat for example, we’re always having to send the waiter away for a bit while she agonizes over her dinner order)… And because it was hard for her to decide which schools to apply to in the first place, she applied to a lot, so she has a lot to choose from now (and will likely have some more when decisions arrive in March)! ![]()
We have been watching videos, looking up specific things offered at each school (related to her very niche interests in music / art / sports), talking about pros and cons, and compiling a big spreadsheet with the curriculum for her probable major at each school with info about what she could skip based on her AP credits, etc… But in the end I think it comes down to a gut feeling where she is asking herself, “could I realistically see myself choosing this school over all the others?”
This sums up my D’s journey, too. The only consistent feature for each school is a solid nursing program (direct admit, good access to clinicals, etc.). After that, she is all over the place – with things that she likes and dislikes about each. We have tentative admitted student visits scheduled for Tennessee, Pitt (it will be her second visit), Case Western (will be her second visit), and now she wants to add UMiami. (Honestly, I can’t imagine two schools more different in vibe than Case and Miami!). Personally, I think Pitt is the Goldilocks school. It has a little bit of everything she is looking for… But I am staying quiet for now.
The admitted student days will be a scramble for us. I’ve tried looking up when they all might be held but until we know where she gets in & the dates are posted it’s all up in the air. Frustrating since I can’t take vacation days during the 2 week period when most of them will be held in April due to a huge event at work. If people do happen to know admitted students days for particular schools, feel free to drop them in those schools’ RD threads!
This is my S too! No strong preference for small OR big schools, private OR public! It’s driving this planner-mom crazy! You’re lucky you got your D to watch videos about each school. I can only get 3 minutes here and there, but no in depth conversations about his options.
How many schools made it to her short list?
That awesome! It’s nice to have options to choose from! Direct admit for nursing is often really hard to get. Your D should be really proud of herself. ![]()
I thought of your family earlier today when I read/watched the following news report from a Tucson news station. They interviewed a mom and daughter. The daughter applied to ONLY Univ of Arizona. Just the one school. Nowhere else. Applied as a nursing major. Assumed she would get admitted because, I’m paraphrasing the mom here, “You’re an auto admit as long as you have a 3.0 GPA and she’s got a 3.1 so we thought she’d get in but she got rejected! It isn’t fair!”
You know what’s not fair? That none of the counselors at that kid’s high school told her that direct admit nursing is super hard to get. Nobody told them and the family just assumed.
She applied to 24 total schools… that is how indecisive my D was ![]()
The other reason to apply to a wide range of schools was to compare merit offers. My D is very cost conscious, and her hope is to save some of her 529 for her next step in life.
She has been admitted to 11 schools (mostly with merit/honors), deferred at 4. She is still waiting on 9 more that release decisions in March (UW Seattle, Cal Poly, and 7 UC campuses), plus waiting for March for the 4 deferrals.
Of her acceptances, she has 3 on her short list currently (UBC, Pitt, WPI). For the March decision schools, if admitted, I think she would strongly consider UCB, UCD, UCSB (CCS), and UW.
Congratulations to all the students who have been admitted to all the schools. My D26 has 3 admits to her safety schools. We are still waiting on 4 CSUs, 8 UCs and a few schools elsewhere but mostly on the West coast where it seems like that results come out later in March. So our waiting will last another 1.5 months. Right now her top admit is the Clarks Honors College at the Univ of Oregon. Unfortunately she doesn’t want to go there because it is not near a big city so we will have to visit it if it comes to that. But hopefully she will get into one of the UCs. She is mostly “done with school” but she has 4 APs to take plus she is the competitive civics team (We the people) so she can’t really give in completely to senioritis!
She hasn’t yet visited RIT or WPI, right?
I know these schools overlap a lot in applicants – we heard from a couple of students when we visited that they basically flipped a coin when deciding – so I was curious what, on paper, made her want to cross off RIT but keep WPI on her list.
(We’ve visited both, and it was the opposite for my kid – she loved RIT but was unmoved by WPI. I didn’t share her opinion, mind you. She still has both on her list at my urging.)
Lots of students from our HS attend U of O, and I hear that the Honors college there is very nice! Eugene might feel enough like a city to your D and she might end up liking it more than some of the UCs (not all of them are in big cities either).
Right. She likes WPI’s curriculum flexibility, study abroad built into the curriculum, and the location looks better to her. From what she sees on their web site she thinks they have a stronger program and better facilities for her major (biomedical engineering) and she likes the proximity to the UMass med school for potential research opportunities. WPI would also be cheaper as they gave her more merit. (It turns out my D is a “love the schools that love you” kid. She seems to like it when schools give her the max merit they have, because she feels more wanted…)
That makes sense!
Mine really liked the study abroad built in, too. And the fact that if you really mess up and fail a class, it doesn’t count against your GPA (or something like that, the first couple times at least).
She was less sure about the 7-week quarters, where you only take 3 classes at a time in a fast-paced curriculum. She didn’t outright hate it after hearing how it works (and supposedly it’s good for kids with ADHD), but she’d rather have a regular semester system.
After merit, both RIT and WPI will come in at about the same amount for us, so the cost isn’t a factor in comparing the two. She really likes RIT’s New Media Design program, but it’s fairly rigid and not focused on game design (their game design program is a different major and programming-based, which is not what she wants). I personally have reservations about studying game design in college because it’s such a cutthroat industry, but she does seem to love it (level design and digital storytelling, which is used more and more across industries) – so if she really wants to focus on that, WPI has the much better option in their Interactive Media & Game Development major.
Dorms at both schools are pretty bad, lol. At least RIT’s are all air-conditioned, but most of WPI’s are not. (I know, I know, it doesn’t matter as much up north, but we’re southerners, and this is absolutely foreign.) RIT has a fun pep band for hockey, but no marching band. WPI does have a marching band, albeit small. And they have band camp and all that, so she’d be able to go early and meet people and settle in – which is what I think this kid needs.
Oy, we weren’t planning to visit WPI again, but now maybe I should encourage it. Ha!
Although my D doesn’t want to major in game design, she also thinks this major looks like a lot of fun! She loves the idea that she could take care of all of her gen ed requirements (after applying APs) by taking a bunch of courses in the IMGD major (animation! sound design! etc), and if she does pep band, that would fulfill the PE requirement. ![]()
Sounds like your kid has done way more research than mine has.
I didn’t even know about the PE requirement!
Congrats on all these amazing and exciting acceptances for your kids! I am going to live vicariously through the accepted student day visits.
D26, a super outgoing, social kid who loves travel, just inexplicably was never into visiting campuses–during any phase of the process. So I love all the reports and decision processes here.
Because I’m a blatant lurker here and you know my older boy is a WPI kid - OM the PE requirement, you do need four classes, but participating in the first term orientation program counts, there’s a meditation class that counts, walking, yoga etc. It’s not all traditional sports. And yes, if you do marching band or a club sport that counts.
Hit reply as I don’t know how to start a new post! DD deciding between UT Austin, UF, Georgia Tech, Tulane, Miami. Public health/psychology with the intent of PA school. She’s intimidated by G Tech. Oos for all. Any experiences to share?
Those are all fabulous choices! Just saying I think she can be sucessful at all of them. Maybe look at pre-health advising at each and see what they offer? I know for PA it is CRUCIAL that they have healthcare experience (many, many hours –between 500 and 2500). Are there locations where 1) that is easier to come by 2) the univeristy/college supports students looking for those opportunities 3) offers credit for that kind of internship? I don’t have experiences with those schools but I do have experience advising pre-PA students so I took it from that perspective. Our school has an 6-12 credit internship experience so many pre-PA students use that as an opportunity to do internships with PAs. It can give them up to 480 hours of experience and it counts toward their degree. When you are trying to fit in enough hours -its nice if you can get some of them through our degree.
I think our college visit plans MAY end up being relatively last minute. We know we are going to visit St Olaf (currently in the #1 spot) -but I’m not sure about anything else. We have to wait for February and March decisions.
This is great advice! Thank you!