If he narrowed it down to two based on relevant criteria about the schools, that is pretty good and this seems totally reasonable. Once he knows he could be happy and thrive at either, the nit picky differences between schools are likely objectively less significant than his girlfriend. If the relationship doesn’t work out, he still has a great school either way. If he goes to the one further away, it decreases the chance of the relationship working out. Seems a totally rational choice at his stage that also coincides with what the emotions want.
I sent you a DM
Hey all - don’t think I’ve posted in this thread before but my wife and I had a good conversation with my S26 about how we’ve turned the corner in this process—going from positioning himself to be offered admissions to now being recruited by these schools to enroll. It’s an interesting flip in the timeline. His older brother’s advice was to cast a wide net, and S26 certainly did that. Now aside from a couple of deferrals to RD, he has a Top 3 of Tulane, Wisconsin, and Penn State where he’s already been accepted…all of which he loves for various reasons. These visits over the next two months will be very interesting indeed. Tulane’s merit scholarship puts them all within a few thousand dollars of one another annually.
Anyone else noticing that shift from recruiting the schools to being the recruited?
Also, I welcome any opinions on those schools S26 has on his short list. He’s a Poli Sci major. Tulane doesn’t let him declare for a year, but he’s really interested in their Political Economy program.
We’re originally from the Gulf Coast, so that would be a homecoming of sorts. But he also loves big campus energy and sports, and those Big 10 schools have that in spades.
Welcome to this forum!
Nice choices there. Have you visited any of them yet? I imagine they are pretty different in location and possibly vibe. We are also down to top 3 and doing visits in late March/early April - have only visited one of them before. We were planning on visiting most (my kid didn’t apply to a lot of colleges) before applying but ran out of time during a busy junior year and summer.
Welcome, welcome! Your S26 has some great choices there!
Yes! We all felt that shift last weekend when S26 got a decision from one of his reach schools! For now he’s been accepted to 8/11 schools. S26 is getting emails, beanies, and blankets from schools he’s been accepted to so far. He’s a bit overwhelmed by all the options and could not even narrow his list down from his top 5 - he’s still waiting to hear back from the last 3 and I’m not sure if that’s going to get any easier if he gets in to the last 3!
We set up accepted student day visits for his top 5 for now so hopefully some clarity will result from that!
Talking about visit days, I’m curious how many schools allow seniors visiting campuses to be excused absences.
I think that our school allows for 2
Welcome! Sounds like you have three great options.
I have a 2025 Tulane grad (but not a Poli Sci/Political Economy major). I am happy to answer questions unrelated to major.
Our school allows 3 – but I am not above calling her in sick. All of our options are a flight away, so that makes it extra tricky
We’ve both visited Penn State, and he visited Tulane with his mom. Yes, very different vibe for each. We’re headed back to Tulane in March for their Top Scholars Weekend, and we’re going to Madison for the first time for the UW admitted students day.
The cold weather is certainly no joke even coming from Utah, and we’ll miss the most intense time for that by visiting Madison in late March. More comfortable for the visit, but probably not the best representation of the winter, eh?
Our school allows 2
Hm, you think they’d find it suspicious if C26 called in sick two Fridays in a row
Ours are also all a flight away.
I’m checking with ours but I think they go down as unexcused absences.
D26’s school does not give any excused absences for college visits- I really think they should though!!
Any time that we have gone and needed to miss a day- I just call her in for an out-of-town appointment. I leave it vague and they have never asked clarifying question and just mark her as an ‘excused’ absent. ![]()
I’m not sure S26’s school really cares.
As parents, we feel it’s a better use of time anyway.
Are your students actually penalized in some way for having a certain number of absences, whether excused or unexcused? I mean, my kids have had very few absences in their school careers, but in senior year, if we have a take a few days off for illness or college visits, I don’t think the truant officer is going to be chasing after us. But maybe there are actual tangible negative consequences in your (pl.) school districts.
Huge urban school for us, so I take it as they have bigger fish to fry than an IB kid missing some extra days.
We have a rule of how many total days they can be absent. As long as you stay under it, just make some excuse like an appointment or illness. We even have a mental health day absence.
Glad this wasn’t the rule when I was in HS. I skipped first period about 20 times in my senior year because I just couldnt wake up at 7:30 am.
Old fav joke about this: Did you know that 40% of all sick days are taken on Mondays and Fridays?! ![]()
And I guess I need to figure out how many days D26 gets. She’s already used 2 sick days this school year, but she was actually sick! I think we’re expecting to mostly use her spring break in April.
It’s very annoying to have to use your sick days for an actual illness.
We’re doing 2 in spring break, but the one starts Saturday morning so we have to fly on the Friday before break starts. .. 4 something hours flight + 2 hours drive + the extra time needed around flying.