It’s against Ivy League rules to admit RD students before Ivy day, so they use a likely letter. There aren’t many likely letters given out in RD.
NESCAC schools are prohibited from using likely letters. These schools can admit some students before the date each school plans to release decisions, but AFAIK, only Amherst does that and they admitted a wave of RD applicants this past week.
Some other schools use likely letters too…not sure why they just wouldn’t admit early, for example Stanford or William and Mary (2 other schools that use LLs in RD, although W&M’s is called the cypher postcard.)
It is useful to know that this is an Ivy League rule! Maybe these other schools do it because Ivies do it, and they want to be seen as being in the Ivy-plus category?
Could be, I’m not really sure the reasoning as to why Stanford for example would do LLs in RD (and I’m not even sure they currently do…it’s impossible to stay on top of what each school is doing in any given year!) Maybe just the psychological boost to the applicant of an early admit and/or just tradition like in W&M’s case?
Yes, league rules, and the schools/league administration monitor this. This is the only place I know of where the agreement is on the web (I think this is the current agreement):
NACAC governs the behaviors of colleges and counselors (HS and independent) with ethical practice guidelines. Prior to the DOJ lawsuit of 2019 (based on anti-competitive Sherman Act law), NACAC’s ‘guidelines’ had more teeth. NACAC walked back some ‘guidelines’ that the government said were anti-competitive, so now schools can basically do whatever they want with regard to application dates, notification dates, enrollment deadlines and deposit amounts, etc.
ED is especially tricky because we all know that those agreements aren’t legally binding. DOJ opened an investigation in 2018 re: schools sharing names of students they accepted ED. DOJ said doing that is collusion/anti-competitive. I hope all schools have stopped that, but obviously I don’t know that for sure.
Looking into all the details for possibly attending UBC (visas, etc), D26 checks the cost of health care there… and immediately suggests that we all move to Canada.
The flip side is that we know a couple of medical professionals who moved to the US from Canada (and they claim to know a lot more) because the healthcare system there also effectively limits their salary. But yes, I think just about anywhere in the world is cheaper than here…
I can believe that. I looked at the bill for my recent surgery and it cost about the same as our house did (and we live in the bay area so it’s not a cheap house). Fortunately we have insurance with an out of pocket limit. But it makes sense that the surgeons in Canada might not be getting paid like this. It is a truly weird system we have here.
I will remind the group, D26 received a “Apply and you’re in with a $ 100k four year merit scholarship” letter from Seton Hall - when she had expressed zero interest in the school.
It is definitely different than the number of programs marketing their schools to you by sending postcards, letters, packets with glossy brochures and swag boxes - just to try to induce you to apply (UChicago) so they can boost applicant numbers and “improve” selectivity or those trying to make your kid feel specially courted to induce applications. Which are obviously different from what you may or may not receive -after- they have been admitted to programs.
This is a different thing, though. My D26 received one of these, too, from Xavier – attaching it below. She’d never heard of Xavier and had not applied. And they sent it FedEx. Very strange, lol.
The likely letters, though, come from Harvard and mostly other schools in that tier, after the student has applied, saying essentially, “We received you application, and we really like you as a candidate, so we are very likely to admit you. Hang tight until decision day!”
Not the same thing at all.
(Image removed by moderator as name/address were still visible)
Right? It must work on a handful of students, otherwise they wouldn’t do it – but yes, wild.
My D26’s school likes to tally up the total amount of scholarship money the senior class has been awarded and use it in their marketing materials. We debated for some time whether we should tell the college advising office about the Xavier letter or not, lol.
I don’t know why it surprises me (because it shouldn’t ) that they actually have an official agreement.
I still wonder how they police this- I feel like it is still just a handshake agreement. If Harvard decides to go rouge and admit people early- would they no longer be an Ivy!? Could they kick Harvard out of the group? Public opinion I feel would outweigh this agreement and Harvard will always be an Ivy- regardless of an agreement (all hypothetical of course).
Likely letters are a bit odd to me also- under the agreement- I can now see why they do this. But it just seems like they could come up with amendments on their agreements, and all schools can offer x- number of students early?!
D26 has finished another scholarship application. 2 done and 2 to go (assuming she doesn’t find any that she likes- I doubt she is looking though )
This one was part of a professional organization that Hubby is part of. One interesting aspect is that they can ‘win’ an interest free loan for college- and they follow similar pay schemes that school loans follow (not having to start the pay back until graduation and such)
It is a small amount- but kind of intrigues us. Could be more valuable than some smaller scholarships that they also offer. Will look into it more if she gets to that point. Does not say based on financial need- but it would not surprise me if they consider that heavily.
On another note- D26 had one of her pieces of art accepted into a Juried art show. She is pretty excited about that. She won’t share with us what it is yet- says we have to go see it in person! Eagerly looking forward to that.