Not everyone goes to college- high school should be the place it’s taught.
That’s great. I think it should be mandatory in all high schools, not elective. It is the one thing that everyone, regardless of field (or frankly if they even ever work at all) needs to know. Everyone has to manage their money and pay taxes. That is not actually true for many of the other courses that are mandatory.
Totally agree that some personal finance instruction should be part of a high school curriculum – because true, the majority of families on this forum probably instruct our kids on this stuff, but lots of kids don’t have that.
I am skeptical of College Board heading this up in an AP class, though.
My girls both took a standard semester of Econ because it’s required to graduate in Georgia, and neither had room in their schedules for AP Econ. And both had some basic personal finance instruction as part of that course – they both did a project where they were assigned a job/salary in a specific city, and then they had to research every aspect of life and create a budget. It wasn’t high level, but it was eye opening because very few kids understand rent and taxes and insurance and all that in high school.
I’m of the “both and” school on this. Have it in high school and college. Like English, or writing, or foreign language, or math and science are generally required in both (except for the few open curriculum colleges).
I could not agree with you more. I think this education or knowledge is sorely lacking to many even though a lot of the concepts appear very simple and easily accessible, as CFP and others highlighted.
There is some thing to be said about systematically teaching the concepts to young minds (who have other passions and priorities to attend to, like looking good, entertainment with friends, social media, video games,..) with lots of real life examples/scenarios that hopefully helps many avoid the debt trap and become financially responsible sooner.
I think it should be standard in both
Well, savings from having 3-4 vs 30-40 lattes a month could help you pay for that plumbing charge from your meager savings and not keep that as credit card debt.
I think small, insignificant spend can add up. If you start caring a bit about small, avoidable expenditures, you likely will be more thoughtful about more material stuff.
That is a good question. My daughter’s high school has a required financial planning class -but it’s regular level (not honors or AP).
A lot of state schools are now requiring a Personal Finance class - so it might actually be something they CAN get credit for at those locations. More selective privates? Probably not.
Again -state schools often DO give credit for this and for some majors it fulfills a math requirement. My students need a PreCalc or Algebra and Trig for the majors in my department, so when they come in with this class (usually through dual enrollment rather than AP) they DO get credit for it.
I think one of the most critical things in personal finance to communicate is how compound interest works, seeing as almost everyone has to take a loan for something at some stage of their lives. Many people just don’t get how compounding works. Exercises in amortization tables and seeing how the repayments work in terms of interest vs principal being repaid at each stage, as well as the total repayment amount, can be quite an eye opener and help people understand that overall affordability means lower monthly repayments over a longer term can really hurt your finances at the end of that longer term. And maybe fewer lattes for higher loan repayments is worth it.
The visual that stuck for my kid on the power of compounding, was me showing her my Roth IRA balance from the account I opened in my early thirties, but was ineligible to continue contributing to after only a couple years (I knew nothing about backdoor Roths at the time). I was able to say, I only put x into this account 20 years ago, and look at the growth. Yes, it is not a pure compound interest example, but it drove home the point. We also explained how loans can have the opposite effect, and gave her the example of my credit card debt early in life before I knew better and was just making payments on it. We also got her a personal finance book for kids late middle school or early high school (can’t remember). And I was pleased to go into her room once and see it on her desk and dog earred one year before she started a summer gig.
Absolutely. I remember talking to an early boss (bank economist) when I took out my first mortgage. His advice: pay it down as soon as you can, because that switch in compounding working against you (debt) to working for you (investing - his advice: keep putting away what you were paying on the mortgage) is massive. I’ve lived that advice ever since.
That was the case for us – but D and SIL bought at a great time and have a 3% mortgage so they can invest at a higher return.
In at Denison with $! WL at Northeastern - it’s been surprising so far! A bunch of schools come out on Saturday!
The concept of personal finance is great. But what do they really teach?
Do they teach you how to read a tax return? Do they teach you to sell long term capital gain assets if youre in the 12% tax bracket and pay no capital gains taxes and increase your basis? Do they explain the potential capital gains exposure on actively managed non-qualified mutual funds where your account value can go down but still get hit with a 1099-div? Do they show you where you get your tax credit on your 1040 if you switch jobs and overpay your FICA social security taxes? Do they explain different trusts and when people should use revocable trusts vs irrevocable trusts?
Do they show you how to run your own retirement monte carlo scenarios?
The OBBBA provides all sorts of new tax laws that everyone should be aware of -deductible car loan interest (if you qualifiy), above the line charitable deductions, senior deductions, Trump savinsg accounts, SALT deduction increases and phaseouts.
There are real world solutions and there are theoretical/academic. And in the past, it seemed they only focused on the academic part.
Congrats on Denison!!! That is an amazing COA!!
Looking for some perspective and viewpoints. We are debating about whether or not to wait past May 1 if a school waitlists you. One side - if waitlisted, drop the school, commit to another school and move on. Other side - Commit to a school by May 1, keep on waiting until June or whenever.
One side - Is it worth dragging on the waiting? No one knows how these waitlists work - you could be 1 or 1000. On other hand - if this is the school you really really want, why not continue waiting.
Your child needs to commit to another school that they have been accepted by May 1st and they can stay on the WL to see if they come off if they like that school better. It’s fine to tell school one that you aren’t coming if you get off the wait list later in the summer.
There’s a discussion in the thread linked below about this very topic! I’ve linked to a comment I agreed with there stating that it can be very emotionally satisfying to turn down the school that waitlists you. Of course, a lot of folks will have a different conclusion, but I think it’s a pretty emotional decision since you generally don’t have a lot of time to consider it, and folks generally don’t want to consider it until they have an acceptance in hand.
For me personally, I’m very comfortable with the idea of a last minute pivot. I’ve uprooted my life a bunch since college, so I’ve never really worried about it. But my D26… I’m not so sure. I suspect that once she commits to a school, she’s going to want to COMMIT. So, we’ll end up having that discussion if/when she gets a waitlist.
Here’s the thread: Excellent article on what a waitlist is and is not - #18 by jym626