Philosophy BA, Transfer

I’m a high school senior headed to college in the Fall, but I did the whole college process pretty badly. My mom, who’s raising me alone, never went to college in America, so she wasn’t familiar with the process at all. I was a mess junior year, so I didn’t put much effort into learning about it either. In the end, I just applied to Rutgers Camden, knowing that it’s a cheap school to go to if you’re in-state, not considering any scholarships or grants. My grades and SAT score were far more than enough to get in, and I’ll only have to pay about 6k (not including any misc. expenses) for the first year. I wanna major in philosophy and probably go on to law school unless I feel confident enough to pursue philosophy further and try to become a professor.

It seems to me that Rutgers Camden offers a small selection of philosophy classes in each semester and doesn’t offer a lot of philosophy courses in general, so I don’t think I want to continue studying there after my first year. I’m assuming I can easily transfer to Rutgers New Brunswick afterward, and not lose any credits, especially since I’m focusing more on general education requirements my first year. But what I’m considering is applying as a transfer student to a different school outside the Rutgers system.

Here are my questions: Will my mistake of spending a year at Rutgers Camden without applying anywhere else hurt me in the long run, or will it be fine as long as I take classes I can get credit for in other places? Can I get credit at other places for the courses I take at Rutgers Camden? Would it be smarter to just completely drop Rutgers Camden, work for a year, study some philosophy independently (which I have been doing for many years) during that time, and then apply to some colleges for Fall 2019? How good is Rutgers-New Brunswick for philosophy compared to some of the schools I see on a lot of the top philosophy college lists, like Vanderbilt or Georgetown or Duke or Boston? Am I over-valuing those lists, and does it particularly matter if I went to one of those schools instead of Rutgers New Brunswick? With a GPA of 3.12 and an SAT of 1360, are there some reasonably safe schools I could try to apply to that would be better for me than Rutgers New Brunswick?

What is your EFC? Do you qualify for significant financial aid, or would you need merit aid to afford a private university?

If your GPA were higher, I would definitely advise a gap year, because you would be a strong candidate for the tier of schools that would meet full financial need (like the schools you mention - Vandy et al), or for next-tier schools that offer significant merit aid to high-stat students… and your FA/merit aid opportunities would be better as a freshman applicant than as a transfer.

But your stats are more at the level that would get you into the next-tier schools without merit aid, and would be unlikely to get you into super-elite schools at all (unless you have significant “hooks” that you haven’t mentioned). It may still make sense to take a gap year, but only if you have a clear objective as far as where you’d like to get into that will be a significant improvement on Rutgers Camden, and how you’re going to be well-positioned to get in and to be able to afford to attend. (I’m not at all saying that isn’t possible - I just don’t have enough information to know.)

One possibility you might want to consider is St. John’s College (two campuses - one in Annapolis MD and the other in Santa Fe NM), which is on the NACAC list of colleges that still have space available for Fall 2018. St. John’s is unique in that all undergrads go through the same Great Books curriculum. https://www.sjc.edu/academic-programs/undergraduate This covers many of the great primary sources in philosophy; you sound like someone who would love this approach. St. John’s students do extremely well at getting into top grad schools and law schools. Because the St. John’s curriculum is so unusual, they are far more focused on “fit” than on stats - they know that the kind of students who will thrive there are not necessarily the ones with perfect high school GPA’s, but rather those with a type of intellectual curiosity that wasn’t satisfied by the high school classroom.

You are smart to consider your options. There is nothing at all wrong with Rutgers (though I know nothing about their offerings in your particular area(s) of interest), and it may indeed be your best plan to knock a year or two there out of the park and then transfer to a school with a strong philosophy department (whether within your state system or beyond). (Did you apply to TCNJ, btw?) But it’s good to step back and make sure this is your best option before you matriculate and forfeit your freshman applicant status, if there are other better-fit options that you didn’t know to apply to this time around.

Rutgers (New Brunswick) does have a top end reputation for philosophy, so if it is affordable, it can be a good choice to major in philosophy.

Rutgers main campus – New Brunswick – is one of the top Philosophy departments in the U.S. The source relied on most within the discipline is the “Philosophical Gourmet” run by Brian Leiter. The strongest Phil departments are not necessarily at the “top” overall schools so, schools like Rutgers, Univ Pittsburgh and UC Riverside are top Phil departments. For what it’s worth, while they are excellent schools overall, Duke, Boston, Vandy and Wash U are not top Phil programs. Keep in mind, Philosophy tends to be a small major, and departments often don’t offer tons of classes any given semester.

Research the transfer requirements from Camden to New Brunswick so that you know what you have to do to transfer but it sounds like starting out at Camden campus to keep costs down makes sense as long as you can easily transfer to New Brunswick.

How much can your family reasonably afford? Right now you’re using the low cost option which is fine since you can transfer to Rutgers NB. Don’t even consider large loans for undergrad if you want to be a lawyer. You’ll have plenty of opportunity for that in law school.

That’s interesting that Rutgers NB is a top philosophy school! In that case, starting at Camden seems like a very reasonable path. http://sasundergrad.rutgers.edu/advising/current-students/school-to-school-transfer#what-are-the-sas-admission-criteria-from-rutgers-camden-or-newark