Plan II and top 10% - never the twain shall meet?

<p>I’m reading about Plan II admissions, and it seems that being in the top n% doesn’t really matter - certainly not nearly as much as it does in other impacted majors/colleges (Communications, Engineering, Business, etc). </p>

<p>So improving from, say, the top 10% to the top 5% may help you get into the College of Communications (that 75% reserved for top 10%ers), but it probably won’t make much of a difference with your Plan II app because your essays and Plan II-ness are so heavily weighted. Do I have that right?</p>

<p>yeah but the vast majority of Plan II-ers are very highly ranked anyway. Whether the adcomms use it specifically or not, it still demonstrates intelligence.</p>

<p>Judging simply by the facts over the years not many people are accepted who aren’t at least in the top 5%. I know they say the essays and “plan II’ness” count for a lot, and they do, but it seems they still highly value SAT scores and class rank. I think in 2003 the average class rank was like top 3% and the avg SAT was around 1450. It does change slightly over the years but not much.</p>

<p>The reason I was asking is that D’s school’s new class rankings come out next week. Any increase in rank is nice for Plan II app, but downright necessary for College of Communications app. For CofC, it appears that rank is pretty much the only thing that matters for their 75% reserved slots - her good SAT (1570), Subject tests and AP scores won’t matter at all until the 75% is filled and the adcomm starts looking at the remaining 25%. (Rank is like 7% or something.)</p>

<p>Essentially, though pure numbers only count for 20% of the Plan II app, kids who are successful in the rest of the application areas tend to do well in school and on standardized tests as well. Typically students who are good writers and well-rounded outside the classroom tend to have high ranks and 1400+ SAT scores.</p>