<p>I think what I’m getting out of this discussion - this seems kind of obvious but I’ll say it anyway - is that it greatly depends on the individual job. The humane conditions that BassDad hopes for…I feel that I have those. It is clear, from listening to the variety of viewpoints in this discussion, and a significant minority of my engineer friends, that not everyone in engineering does.</p>
<p>I’m amused that sakky’s Time article quoted someone I vaguely know (Nick Pearce - we’re the same class year and were both involved in student government stuff).</p>
<p>Well, think about the insurance industry. It sure seems to me that quite a few people spend quite a bit of money on insurance, which is basically a form of ‘paid prudence’. For example, when I bought my first car, I had to get car insurance, and I learned to my chagrin that the insurance premiums for just one year would cost me more than I paid * for the car itself*. </p>
<p>Now, to be fair, a big part of the reason was that the car in question was a dumpy old car that I bought from my friend for dirt cheap. And of course the other reason is that my car insurance wasn’t really covering the car itself, but rather was covering my driving liability. </p>
<p>Nevertheless, the point is, I am fairly confident that if I actually added up the total costs of actually driving the car (i.e. all the gas, all the extra motor oil I had to buy because the car was leaking oil, all the times I had to take it to the shop, all of the replacement filters and hoses I had to buy,and the car’s annual depreciation), it would still not be as much as I had to pay annually just for the insurance. In other words, I was spending more money on just insuring my driving than I spent on actually driving. </p>
<p>Hence, it seems to me that this would be a case of highly expensive precautions that probably didn’t warrant a strong cost-benefit calculation. But what can I say? That’s what happens when you’re a young man who wants to drive. Insurance companies really sock it to the young. And frankly, I can’t blame them, as young drivers tend to be the most dangerous. Even if car insurance wasn’t mandatory, I would have prudently bought it anyway as I don’t want to risk financial ruin if I end up in an accident, despite the expense of the premiums. </p>
<p>
</p>
<p>I agree that we are now getting into a different subject.</p>
<p>But I think it reinforces what I was saying before. A lot of students are indeed excited about studying engineering, especially at a school like MIT. Those schools offer an environment that makes learning engineering fun. However, it’s quite another matter to actually work as an engineer. Consonant with the sentiment expressed in that Time Magazine article, a lot of engineering jobs are simply not very interesting. </p>
<p>To be fair, I think it should be pointed out that the above is true of probably all majors. It’s pretty cool to be able to deeply study the causes and effects of the Hundred Years War, or to deconstruct and compare/contrast Shakespeare vs. Marlowe vs. Ben Jonson, or learn about the correlated equilibrium of game theory, or to write an algorithm that will find Carmichael numbers. Learning that stuff is pretty exciting. </p>
<p>But most jobs out there aren’t exciting. They don’t let you expand your mind. They don’t really allow you to learn anything. You often times just end up doing the same thing over and over again without any opportunity to learn and grow. </p>
<p>When I used to work in the oil industry doing offshore exploration and production, I would talk to guys who would be sent out to jobs for weeks at a time on rigs that had no Internet access and sometimes not even TV and certainly no newspapers, where they would be running the same wireline an drillstem jobs over and over again while being completely cut off from the world. One of the guys even described it as a process of ‘getting dumber’, as they would just be stuck out there with no opportunity to learn about what was happening in the world. </p>
<p>But this is not confined to engineering. Most jobs out there for any major are, frankly, pretty boring. I know many former humanities students who are deeply frustrated and bored with their jobs too.</p>
<p>But back to engineering, the question then becomes, why can’t engineering jobs be made better? In particular, why is it that consulting and banking firms can apparently offer better jobs than can engineering firms? If it’s just a matter of money, then why can’t engineering firms pay more? {Especially when you consider the fact that many engineering firms are themselves clients of consulting firms, which means that those eng firms are effectively paying the salaries of those consultants. They’re just doing so indirectly. Hence, it seems to me that if these firms just paid their engineers better, then they wouldn’t have to pay so much for consultants.} If it’s a matter of career advancement opportunities (as that Time article stated), then why can’t engineering firms offer the sorts of career advancement opportunities that the consulting firms can? Nick Pearce said that he felt that if he took an engineering job, he would be locked into a project. But why should he have to feel that way? Why do engineer companies lock people into projects, when consulting firms don’t? The article also talks about the team-based social nature of consulting work. Well, why can’t engineering work be team-based and social?</p>
<p>The auto insurance analogy does not do it for me in this situation. Most of the premium goes to cover liability for possible injury to other people and to their property. You can choose to provide minimal coverage for your own car if that makes financial sense (i.e. your car is not very valuable) and that is precisely what most people do for the kind of car you describe. In that case, the ratio of the cost of the car to the total cost of the complete insurance package is meaningless.</p>
<p>I will give you my thoughts on your last paragraph when I have a bit more time.</p>
<p>OK, back from dealing with some auto insurance issues ironically enough.</p>
<p>Having worked for both engineering and consulting firms, I would not categorically state that the consulting jobs are better than the engineering jobs. The consulting jobs do not provide much in the way of benefits, they frequently require me to be away from my family (those expenses at least are mostly reimbursed) and they require me to present a much more upscale appearance (mostly unreimbursed) to clients than I would typically have to at an engineering job. They pay more in salary, but the added expenses in benefits, wardrobe and drycleaning make the difference pretty small, particularly in an after-tax sense.</p>
<p>Engineering firms are being squeezed to make this quarter’s profit and loss statement look good, just like everyone else is. They are seeing non-salary related costs, particularly health insurance, skyrocket. They are cutting back everywhere they can. On top of that, Wall Street rewards them for cutting headcount and increasing span of control. These are big financial incentives for getting rid of people, particularly experienced ones, whom they replace with fewer entry-level new hires whom they can pay less, or perhaps outsource to people who are paid much less. They run at the edge of capacity and, when squeezing more unpaid overtime out of the newbies no longer works, they hire consultants to help in peak periods. Its all about cycles and not wanting to have a lot of unproductive employees that have to be paid during slow periods. The consulting companies, not being idiots, know they can demand top dollar in that situation. They also know that they have to get as much money while they can as quick as they can because the consultants are going to be the first to be let go when (not if) there is a downturn.</p>
<p>Because the engineering companies are always running near the edge of capacity, there is little time for training or career development, hence the mobility problems. Besides, they get anywhere from fifty to a few hundred resumes for every job opening (OK, that’s a bit of exaggeration), so they can cherry pick from among all the older guys looking for a job if they need some special skill or else hire someone with the skills they need right out of college. Meanwhile, the consulting firms can usually find someone somewhere who is busy enough to hire their employees, even if the fit is not exact, because the engineering firms with hot projects want non-permanent bodies right now. If it all falls apart, the consulting firms do not have a big investment in real estate or capital goods. They can declare bankruptcy and set up shop again next month somewhere else.</p>
<p>Then there are hostile takeovers, where your company can be bought out from under you and sold off piecewise to the highest bidder. The purchaser has no interest in seeing the business continue, just in selling the pieces for maximum profit. A similar scenario is the merger in which the larger partner is not interested in continuing some of the lines of business owned by the smaller partner. Back to the corporate liquidators we go.</p>
<p>Basically it boils down to good old-fashioned greed, augmented by the newer ability to track financial data continuously and almost instantaneously.</p>
<p>I never worked for a financial institution, so cannot tell you firsthand about them. Instead, I will refer you to Willie Sutton. When asked why he robbed banks, he reportedly answered, “Because that’s where the money is.”</p>
<p>Uh, I think I stated precisely this point in my post.</p>
<p>I think it perfectly illustrates my point. Sometimes you have to take extensive measures to mitigate risk. The risk-reduction aspect of driving actually costs *more * than the act of driving itself. Like I said, I pay more to insure myself when I drive than I do in actually driving. And while car insurance is obviously mandatory, I would purchase it even if it was not because I value the risk-reduction. </p>
<p>Similarly, I don’t think it’s entirely surprising to find people who value the ‘career insurance’ aspect of a particular type of college education more than they do the education itself. </p>
<p>
</p>
<p>But I am not talking about just the ‘regular’ consulting firms. Those are generally not the firms that engineering students from schools like MIT, Stanford, etc. will flock to. I completely agree that there are plenty of mediocre consulting firms out there who often times do not provide career paths than engineering firms. But that’s not what I’m talking about. </p>
<p>What I am specifically talking about are the elite consulting firms, and specifically, the top-tier strategy houses like McKinsey, Bain, BCG, and the like. These firms provide extensive benefits, as well as salary, and yes, in many cases, including an expense account and full concierge to handle your dry-cleaning and wardrobe necessities, particularly when you’re on the road. </p>
<p>
</p>
<p>But you missed the basic point, which is * why aren’t these consulting firms facing the same pressures?*. After all, consultancies are firms too. They should also be facing pressure from their own investors, right? So why don’t they also feel constant pressure to eliminate employees? Why is it that they are somehow able to invest heavily in training? Why aren’t they also getting 50-200 (actually almost certainly more) resumes per job opening, such that they can cherry-pick the best people? Why aren’t they also threatened by hostile takeovers and other such M&A activity? </p>
<p>In short, the fundamental question is why would consulting firms, as an organizational structure, be somehow immune to the economic pressures that other firms face? After all, firms are firms. </p>
<p>Now, let me review some of the possible objections that I can foresee coming, and outline why I do not think they apply:</p>
<p>***Consulting firms are privately held and therefore immune to the pressures of the markets. ** </p>
<p>It is true that some consulting firms are private, but it is not true for others. For example, some of the largest consulting firms such as Accenture and Capgemini are publicly traded. Furthermore, just because you’re a private firm doesn’t mean that you’re immune to M&A activity. Some of the largest acquisitions in the world were targeted at privately held companies. As a specific case in point, in 2002, the strategy consulting arm of PWC was acquired by IBM for $3.5 billion - and yes, that acquisition triggered the layoffs of thousands of employees. </p>
<p>And furthermore, I don’t particularly agree with the premise that public firms are more likely to lay people off than are private firms, as a percentage of their total employee base. It seems to me that many private firms (especially those held by private equity) are among the most likely to engage in extensive layoffs. For example, ever since Chrysler was officially taken private 4 months ago, the pace of layoffs has actually increased, with persistent rumors of even more layoffs to come. In fact, one of the greatest fears of the UAW is that either GM or Ford (or both) will also be taken private, because it is believed that the private structure might enable even more layoffs than if those firms remain public. You would think that if a private structure really provided for a larger employment structure, then the UAW would be pushing GM and Ford to sell out to private equity. That is certainly not happening. </p>
<p>What I believe happens is that layoffs at public firms get * constant media exposure*. Because they’re public, they have to disclose everything through press reports and investor relations meetings. So any large-scale layoffs have to be publicly announced. In contrast, a privately held firm can lay off thousands of workers and not have to say anything to anybody, and certainly not have to say anything to the media. Granted, some of them do talk to the media. But they don’t have to. For example, when McKinsey laid off numerous employees a few years ago during the dotcom bust, nobody in the press really noticed. </p>
<p>*The major asset of consulting firms is human capital, and hence, they have to treat their employees right because their assets can walk out of the door at any time.</p>
<p>That’s probably correct, but then that just begs the question of why engineering firms can’t also derive most of their value in the form of human capital. And in fact, I think that does in fact happen, at least in the case of small high-tech engineering startups. Most of them have relatively few physical assets and often times don’t have strong intellectual property assets either. Hence, when a company acquires these firms, what they’re really trying to acquire is the knowhow in the heads of the employees. {After all, if this wasn’t true, then why even bother to acquire the firm at all? Why not just buy an exclusive license to the startup firm’s intellectual property and/or technology instead? That would be a lot cheaper than acquiring the entire firm itself.}</p>
<p>Hence, if it is the case that consulting firms’ value is derived more from human capital, it is still an open question as to why consulting firms are able to structure themselves that way but engineering firms are not. </p>
<p>*** The top management of engineering firms are just greedy managers who care only about their own short-term financial situation **</p>
<p>Well, I don’t know about you, but it sure seems to me that the top managers of consulting firms are also pretty darn greedy and tend to care only about their own short-term financial situation too.</p>
<p>I stated that greed is at the root of the problem. I completely agree that both engineering and consulting managers are pretty darn greedy as you say. </p>
<p>When you are talking about the very high end consulting firms and the small startups, you are talking about a pretty small piece of the entire profession. Your points may be valid to one degree or another in those situations, but I am talking about a different situation entirely. What one small part of a market is able to do is very different from what the entire industry as a whole is able to do. If your questions related only to a few percent of the industry then I would be far more inclined to agree with you. Since your questions seemed open ended and the thread started out by talking about the plight of engineers in general, I assumed that we were talking about different things.</p>
<p>When you get right down to it, someone has to provide the infrastructure. Someone has to own and maintain the buildings that contain the labs, offices, manufacturing floors and warehouses. Someone has to buy the machines and computers and the test equipment. If everyone was mostly in the business of human capital, nothing much would get done because there just wouldn’t be anywhere to do it or anything to do it with. Somewhere along the line, someone has to provide the non-human capital.</p>
<p>I think you missed my basic point that (non-high-end) engineering firms are fundamentally different from (non-high-end) consulting firms in that the engineering firms have to worry far more about the cyclic behavior of the markets that they are in. They do not have enough permanent employees to handle peak periods because they cannot afford to retain them during the slow periods and the hiring/firing process for permanent employees is much more expensive than adding or subtracting some consultants as needed. Engineering firms generally have a larger base of fixed cost to deal with than do the consulting firms. They have far higher startup costs and far more to lose should they go into bankruptcy. They turn to consulting firms precisely when they are hitting peak periods and they are willing to pay a premium for services during those times because they need the help and they have the cash coming in to pay for it.</p>
<p>Consulting companies, particularly those on the high end, can afford to treat their employees well because they are basically opportunists who have the option of taking only the most profitable jobs. No consulting firm I have worked for has ever sold my time for less than 100% profit. For much of the rest of the world, life is a zero sum game and costs associated with treating employees better have to come from treating someone else worse. They need to keep enough work coming in to pay for those higher fixed costs and cannot afford to take only the highest profit margin jobs. They would be quite happy to turn a 15-20% profit, particularly when things start to slow down. If they notice that the supply of labor has gone up relative to demand, they are going to respond by paying less for it. Not everyone can skim the cream off the top of the market like those high end contractors.</p>
<p>The discussion on auto insurance was triggered by a question of cost-to-benefit ratios. Your point seemed to be that there are some circumstances in which people are willing to pay a high cost for insurance, which you illustrated by citing the large amount that they would pay to insure a cheap car. My counter argument is that they are paying to insure far more than a cheap car, and hence the cost-to-benefit ratio of that insurance is far lower than it would be if you only consider the total premium paid for insurance and the cost of replacing the car. In the case you cited, the cheap car is the smallest part of what you are insuring and calculations of cost-to-benefit ratio that do not include the larger part of of the benefits for which you are paying are misleading in such a way as to make the example work toward your side of the argument rather than mine. In fact, you might think of the cost of insuring everything but your own car as a fixed cost and the cost of insuring your car as the variable cost. You are in the position that you have to pay so much in fixed costs that you cannot afford to pay much toward purchasing a car (read paying the salary of your engineers) or toward paying to insure that car (read paying the non-salary related expenses of those same engineers.) So you look for the car that will get you where you need to go at the least cost even though the seats are vinyl instead of leather, the heater doesn’t work too well and you only have an AM radio instead of a CD changer and 12 speakers. You would certainly like to get something better if you could afford it, but you can’t, so you make do. Engineering companies are doing exactly the same when hiring employees.</p>
<p>Like I’ve always said, I still think that the bulk of the engineers (i.e. the bottom 75%) have it pretty good, relative to whatever else they could have been doing. This is especially true as you move down the spectrum. As somebody else on this thread said, the guy who barely graduated from a low-tier college is almost certainly better off working as an engineer than the alternatives. After all, such a guy will almost certainly never get a job offer from McKinsey, Goldman Sachs, or a private equity firm. That guy can probably get a 40-45k salary as an engineer just to start, which like I said is already better than the average American who has experience. </p>
<p>But like I’ve said, the problems with engineering seem to be concentrated at the very top. I focus on the very top because, frankly, the population of readers here on this discussion board is slanted towards the top. Most readers here are students who are far better than average (as the average American student isn’t that good), and hence will be attending colleges that are far better than average. For example, a school like MIT is mentioned far more often here than is the average college, yet the fact is, only a tiny percentage of people could ever dream of attending MIT. </p>
<p>Top people at top colleges is precisely the audience that suffers from the problems of engineering. The engineering industry doesn’t seem to be able to properly accommodate such people, which is why so many of them decide to enter other fields (i.e. consulting, banking, or law, as in the case of ariesathena). My question is: why? </p>
<p>For example, I think it has been noted that the top engineers are far more productive than are the bad engineers. In the case of the software industry, the most productive engineers can actually be several orders of magnitude (i.e. 100x) more productive than are the worst engineers. I think anybody who has worked in any software company will note that the work never seems to be completed evenly and that only a small percentage of the developers seem to be the ones who actually produce the vast majority of a software project’s functionality/features, whereas plenty of other developers produce almost nothing. So why not just fire those low performers and take whatever you were paying them and use it to increase the salaries of your high performers? Similarly, back when I worked in the oil industry, I noted that even the best engineers did not make more than 2 or 2.5 times more than the worst engineers, even though they were clearly far more than 2.5 times more productive. </p>
<p>In short, the plight of the engineers is that, beyond a certain point, there is no room to grow your career. As mentioned by others, your salary tends to max out rather quickly such that, beyond that point, it doesn’t matter how much more you learn and how much more you improve your productivity, as you’re not going to get paid any extra. Whereas in consulting or banking, your pay will continue to advance as you continue to improve your productivity. Hence, the very best people (i.e. the students at MIT) realize this and adjust their career paths accordingly. Again, I agree that this doesn’t affect the majority of engineers, but it does affect many people here on this discussion board. </p>
<p>
</p>
<p>Well, the US (and the developed world in general) has been moving to a more human-capital-centric economy for awhile now and I see no signs of that slowing down. Services will continue to supplant manufacturing. Human capital will continue to supplant physical capital. Sure, somebody will always have to provide physical capital, but those jobs will become increasingly marginalized.</p>
<p>But I don’t think that is necessarily threatening to the state of engineering. After all, engineering is itself a matter of human capital. After all, what is engineering? It’s not about ownership of physical capital or physical goods. It’s actually about how to take physical goods and transform them into more valuable products through the application of human capital. For example, raw metal and raw rubber is practically useless. It takes extensive engineering human capital to take a bunch of metal and rubber and transform that into an automobile. Similarly, it takes vast engineering human capital to know how to convert sand and a bunch of chemicals into a microprocessor. I could give you an entire semiconductor fab plant, with all of the raw materials, but if you don’t know how to use it, then you won’t be able to make any microchips. And in fact, if you have that microchip engineering knowhow, then you don’t really need to own any of the physical plant itself. </p>
<p>That is why the ‘fabless’ semiconductor firms have thrived. They consist of little more than a bunch of research offices, and when they actually need to produce something, they will contract for some cheap manufacturing capacity at a semiconductor foundry. They don’t feel that they actually need to own any of the machinery when they can lease it at will. And, in fact, these fabless firms offer some of the highest paying engineering jobs in the country. What those firms prove is that you don’t actually need to have physical ownership of machinery in order to perform valuable engineering work. </p>
<p>Hence, on a first-pass, there is no reason that engineering can’t thrive in a human-capital intensive world. And, like I said, the bottom 75% of engineers are thriving (at least, relative to most other Americans). But the question on my mind is, why isn’t engineering thriving as much as, say, consulting or banking? </p>
<p>
</p>
<p>No, I understand your point, but I still disagree with the premise. You say that engineering firms are subject to the cycles of the market. Well, consulting firms are also subject to the cycles of the market. After all, consulting firms also have to answer to their investors, whether those investors are public shareholders or managing partners or whoever owns the company. Like I stated in my previous post, there is no reason to believe that privately owned firms are any less prone to layoffs than are publicly owned firms, and if anything, the opposite may be true (as, like I said, Chrysler actually laid off people at a higher rate after it privatized.) For example, you say that engineering firms are not able to hold onto people during their slow periods, but then that begs the question of how are consulting firms somehow able to do it? Why are consulting firms somehow able to endure the cycles of the market, but engineering firms can’t?</p>
<p>You also cite the fixed cost base of engineering firms relative to consulting firms. But that’s a misreading of the rules of corporate finance. High fixed costs should be an anti-cyclical force, not pro-cyclical. After all, high fixed costs imply that your unit cost of labor is relatively low. That means that, in a recession, you don’t save very much by reducing your headcount, because you still have to pay for those fixed costs no matter what. Heck, even if you fired everybody in the company, you would still be incurring a large loss anyway. In other words, your incentives to implement layoffs are actually diminished by a high fixed cost. Contrast that with consulting firms, which, because of the lower fixed costs, should actually be deeply affected by market cycles. Every fired consultant represents a large decrease in costs to the company, hence consulting firms have a large incentive to cut their workforce very very deeply during recessions. </p>
<p>Yet, as we have seen, consulting firms are somehow able to better invest in employee training and provide better career development than engineering firms can even during the bad times. Consulting firms are somehow able to hold onto their employees even during the bad times when engineering firms evidently cannot (or don’t want to), even though you would think that consulting firms would have every incentive to lay off lots of people during bad times. The question then is why? Why are consulting firms able to do what engineering firms are not able to do? </p>
<p>
</p>
<p>Ha! I think it should be noted that even high-end consulting actually isn’t that profitable of a business, relative to high-end engineering.</p>
<p>It may be surprising to some that consulting firms actually don’t generate particularly high margins. But it’s true. The truth is, consulting as an industry doesn’t scale. Bringing in more work inevitably means hiring more consultants. Hence, there are relatively few economies of scale. </p>
<p>Contrast that with the top engineering firms. They are among the most profitable firms on the planet. ExxonMobil generated about $40 billion of profit in the last year. That’s the most profit of any US public company in history. That’s more profit than any investment bank has ever generated in any year, even during the hottest of the boom years. That’s almost certainly more profit than the entire US consulting industry generated. </p>
<p>Or take Microsoft. Microsoft generates something like a ridiculous 90%+ gross margins on its standard software products like Windows and Office. That’s because it obviously costs practically nothing to print another copy of Windows or Office. Even if you include all of the taxes it pays, all its money-losing businesses (i.e. MSN, Xbox), and all of the billions it pours into R&D (with very little to show for it), Microsoft still generates an absurdly high 27% overall profit margin. Even after paying out that huge $32 billion special dividend and a number of share buybacks that have consumed billions more, Microsoft is still sitting on $18 billion in cash, and zero debt. Microsoft is hands down one of the most prolific cash-generating machines in world history. They’re minting money over in Redmond. </p>
<p>Yet again, the truth is, even profoundly profitable engineering companies like ExxonMobil and (especially) Microsoft don’t pay their employees as well as the banks and consulting firms do. Why not? There’s no doubt that they have the money to do it. Microsoft, especially, has more cash than they know what to do with, to the point that Microsoft has been willing to spend giant chunks of cash on investments that have not been profitable, and many of which have been downright silly. {i.e. Microsoft just recently invested $240 million for just a tiny 1.6% slice of Facebook, implying a $15 billion valuation for a startup that has a negligible revenue stream.) Microsoft has reportedly lost nearly $10 billion total on its Xbox division ever since its launch (including $4 billion in 2005, and another $2 billion this year). In fact, Xbox may not become profitable until 2010 (if it ever does), and in fact, may never be able to generate enough profits to pay back its initial costs at a reasonable rate of return. </p>
<p>Yet why is it that Microsoft can apparently spend billions of dollars willy-nilly on massive money-losing investments like Xbox, but can’t afford to boost employee salaries or provide better employee career development? For example, I was talking to a few former Microsoft engineers who are getting their MBA’s at Harvard Business School. None of them are planning to go back to Microsoft, even though they all could (as they took leaves-of-absences, so they do have jobs waiting for them). Instead, they’re taking jobs in banking and consulting because those jobs pay far better and provide better career development. But why? It’s not like Microsoft doesn’t have the money (as, despite the billions lost on Xbox and MSN, Microsoft still generated more income this year than even Goldman Sachs did). But Microsoft, for whatever reason, just doesn’t want to pay it. There’s something ironic about the fact that people feel they have to leave one of the most successful and profitable companies in world history to work somewhere else in order for those people to make more money. </p>
<p>Nor do I mean to single out Microsoft. Microsoft is actually probably one of the fairest and most meritocratic companies in the world, offering more opportunities than most other engineering firms in the world. Yet even so, even Microsoft has difficulty in providing opportunities that are comparable to those in consulting and banking. Why? </p>
<p>
</p>
<p>See above. Like I said, engineering is not innately less profitable than is consulting. In fact, many engineering firms (like Microsoft) are actually far more profitable. Yes, Microsoft spent many billions in order to develop Windows and Office. But those investments have generated truly massive profits and giant cash flows. </p>
<p>Hence, while I might agree that those engineering companies that generate low profits might not be in a position to compete for employees with consulting firms, why is it that even the * most profitable* engineering firms are also not able to compete with those consulting firms? The most profitable engineering firms are clearly more profitable than the most profitable consulting firms.</p>
<p>I think that you are talking about far less than 25% of the engineering population, then, and most likely far less that 5%. The industry doesn’t spend more money than it has to on much of anything, including top flight engineers, when it can do what it needs to do with pretty good engineers who are willing to work at half the salary, or in some cases even less than that. Even the best ones coming right out of school generally need to get some on the job experience before they are ready to make the kind of contributions that you mention. Remember that we both said that greed is a common denominator, well everyone wants someone else to pay for those first few years in which the recent grads are still learning their trade. I rather doubt that the people running the financial companies are any less greedy than those running the engineering companies, so either they are more forward thinking or else the grads are more able to contribute to those industries right out of the box.</p>
<p>You seem to be equating advancement with salary over and over. What you say about hitting a ceiling is true in terms of salary, but there are other forms of advancement. I will say it once again: If salary is your main objective, you can certainly do better than engineering. If the engineering industry is getting what it perceives that it needs under the current structure, why should it change its ways to accommodate a handful of top students from a few top schools? If they don’t get the top five or ten from MIT, numbers eleven through twenty will do just fine as far as they are concerned. Getting back to the car analogy, they don’t need the top of the line Bugatti when they can get a small fleet of BMW’s and Mercedes for the same money.</p>
<p>The fabless semiconductor folks are in a very vulnerable position if the people with the production facilities ever decide to make life difficult for them. They can also be cut out entirely should the companies who buy their products start doing the designs themselves. While they do not have some of the fixed costs of a Motorola or TI, they have to pay more in variable production costs than they would if they owned their own production equipment. Effectively, they still have a higher cost structure than a true consulting firm that is only selling knowledge. While service industries have been growing, there is going to be a hard limit on their growth set by the need for infrastructure and the need for customers with money to buy their services. When it hits that limit and the growth slows, stops and possibly even reverses, the salaries will be reeled in just as happened in the late nineties with the early Internet bubble.</p>
<p>Please explain to me why Microsoft or ExxonMobil should feel the need to spend more on their engineers if they are already generating huge profits and have been doing so for years. If they already have some of the best business plans of anyone on the planet, why tinker with them?</p>
<p>Consulting firms are usually in a better position to weather the low parts of industry-specific cycles because they can position themselves across several different industries much more efficiently than an engineering company can. They can shift personnel around, do a few weeks of retraining and poof! they have an instant expert (or so they claim) for whatever industry happens to be hot at the moment. As long as they have someone on staff to field the truly hard problems, the retrained folks can handle 90% of whatever comes up and yell for help the other 10% of the time. Worst case, they go out of business, stiff their creditors and employees, then appear somewhere else a month later with a whole new set of employees in whatever industry is currently desperate for bodies. Engineering firms that crash and burn are not nearly so agile.</p>
<p>I believe it is probably a combination of both, and a few other attributes besides. But that doesn’t really answer the question, it just moves the goalposts. Why can’t engineering companies be more forward-thinking? Why can’t they structure themselves in a manner to increase the productivity of new hires?</p>
<p>That second question is, I think, the more interesting one, for it implies that engineering companies are actually losing money on its new hires until such time as those new hires aren’t paying their way until they have develop sufficient experience. But why would engineering companies put up with this? We both agree that engineering companies are greedy. So why even bother hiring these new hires at all, if you’re going to lose money on them? Why not simply hire only experienced veterans - i.e. those who actually have enough experience to pull their own weight? </p>
<p>Furthermore, that line of logic brings me back to a question I asked before. Like I said, at many (probably most) engineering companies, some engineers are far more productive than are others and hence do most of the actual work. It’s not much of a secret. Certainly all the engineers knew who was really doing most of the work. It’s hard for me to imagine that the managers couldn’t figure this out if they really wanted to know. What often times happens is that the most productive engineers inevitably get frustrated and quit the company to do something else (i.e. get their MBA’s and switch careers). To stop that from happening, why don’t these engineering companies just fire all of their less productive engineers and then take the savings and give a chunk of it to those highly productive engineers (and keep the rest of it for the company)? In other words, instead of having 100 engineers all making basically the same salary, but only 10 of them actually doing the real work, why not just fire the 90 unproductive ones and vastly increase the salaries of the remaining 10? </p>
<p>Lest you think this is politically impossible, I would say that this is precisely what happens in the sales departments of most companies, including engineering companies. The top salesman at most companies makes vastly more than the bottom salesman, usually by an order of magnitude or more. I read somewhere that the top salesmen at the software company Oracle would make literally millions a year (and the worst performers would quickly get fired). Why can’t engineering be like that? </p>
<p>Now, I know what you’re going to say: that engineering relies more on cooperation and teamwork than sales does. That is true, but not THAT much. Again, most working engineers understand full well that certain engineers are far more productive than are others. Hence, there is the opportunity to pay people according to their actual productivity. </p>
<p>
</p>
<p>Salary is not my only concern, it is just the most visible one. The other is, of course, the opportunity for advancement. Many engineers perceive that the best way to advance, even within their own company is not through the ranks of engineering, but rather through consulting or banking. For example, the CEO of Sun is not an engineer, but rather is a former McKinsey consultant. The 2 co-Presidents of Oracle were not engineers, they’re former investment bankers. The most recent CEO of Dell (before Michael Dell took the helm back) was a former partner at Bain. The CEO of GE did a stint at BCG. </p>
<p>The salient point is that engineering companies, at least in the US, are only rarely actually run by former engineers. Microsoft, Cisco, Intel, IBM, GM, Boeing, HP, GE, etc. etc. - none of these companies are actually run by people who actually worked as engineers. Instead, they’re usually headed by former financiers and salesmen (and consultants). These aren’t banks we’re talking about here, for which we would expect that the leadership would consist mostly of former bankers. These are engineering companies. Yet even in those companies, engineers don’t make it to the top. The engineers see that and rationally deduce that if they want to have the best chance at making it to the top, they shouldn’t do so through engineering. Sad but true. People are ambitious and they’re rightfully going to want to choose the path that maximizes their chances at getting them where they want to be. </p>
<p>That’s a big part of the problem: that, for whatever reason, working as an engineer is not perceived to be able to expose you to the career development opportunities that you need to advance. Whether it’s salary or promotion or whatever it is that you want, the point is, engineering doesn’t seem to be a fast track to get what you want. A lot of people want that fast track. Nor can I blame them for wanting it. </p>
<p>
</p>
<p>** But they’re not getting what they need! ** Let me illustrate. </p>
<p>A know a guy who graduated from MIT and got a job from an engineering company. He turned it down in order to take a much higher paying job at a consulting firm. One of his first consulting gigs was * for that very engineering company that he had originally turned down!*. In fact, he basically ended up “working” for that engineering company for nearly a whole year. For example, he had his own cubicle at that company. He had an access pass. He worked closely with many of the engineers at that company, many of whom became his friends. Basically, he was doing many of the things that an actual employee would be doing at that firm. The major difference was that obviously he was formally employed by that consulting firm, and he was drawing the (much higher) paycheck from them. {And yes, every week or so, he had to go to the offices of the consulting firm to ‘check in’.} </p>
<p>But think about what that means. If that engineering company was doing just fine with, as you say, the #11-20 MIT grads, then why did they hire the consulting firm in the first place?. Or more specifically, why didn’t they just give him a better job offer in the first place? After all, the company basically ended up “hiring” this guy anyway. They just did so indirectly and for * far far more money*, because they had to pay millions of dollars to the consulting firm, which then in turn paid that guy’s salary. If you’re going to end up “hiring” this guy anyway, why not just do so directly and cut out the middleman? </p>
<p>What I am really suggesting is that if engineering companies were to pay more for better engineers, then they probably wouldn’t need to pay so much for consulting. Whatever you save on engineering salaries, you end up losing that and much more on consulting fees. That’s the very definition of penny-wise, pound-foolish. </p>
<p>Hence, I completely disagree with the premise that these engineering firms don’t “want” the top of the line Bugatti’s. Not only do they want them, they are clearly willing to pay through the nose to get them (via McKinsey or BCG or Bain as the middleman). Why do that? If you really want them, then why not just get them directly? </p>
<p>
</p>
<p>But the fact remains that the trend within the US is to go fabless. Few of the US fabless firms are contemplating buying production facilities, but the US integrated chip manufacturers are under constant pressure to outsource their fabs. For example, LSI Logic just recently eliminated all of its fabs. You mention Motorola and TI. Well, first off, Motorola doesn’t make chips anymore, having spun off that division as Freescale 3 years ago. Freescale and TI are both outsourcing more of their fab production. It seems to be a one-way transition. </p>
<p>Certainly, it may be true that these fabless firms may run into trouble later. But let’s face it, it hasn’t exactly been a walk in the park for the integrated manufacturers either. For example, in its latest fiscal year, AMD lost more money in just 1 year than the total combined profit it had made * in the entire 39-year history of the firm* Many of the old US integrated manufacturers of the old glory days of Silicon Valley are either bankrupt or were acquired for a song. </p>
<p>
</p>
<p>Why tinker indeed. Good question. But that is PRECISELY what they are doing right now. </p>
<p>For example, ExxonMobil is a major consulting client, for which they spend millions. Why? Doesn’t that mean that ExxonMobil is tinkering with its business model? {If not, then what exactly are all these consultants getting paid to do?} If ExxonMobil is willing to pay so much for consultants, then why isn’t it willing to pay more for better employees? </p>
<p>Or take Microsoft and its business model. Like I said, Microsoft has lost easily over $10 billion on its Xbox division ever since its launch in 2001. Why? Isn’t that a case of Microsoft tinkering with its business model? After all, Microsoft had never sold games before. And in fact, Xbox may never be profitable. </p>
<p>Similarly, Microsoft has spent tens of billions on Internet and telecom investments with relatively little to show for it. I would also say that that’s also a case of tinkering with the Microsoft business model. Microsoft invested $5 billion in AT&T during the peak of the dotcom boom, and that investment has lost a lot of money. Microsoft recently bought the Internet advertising company aQuantive for $6 billion. These, I would say, are quite radical changes in Microsoft’s business model. After all, Microsoft had never been a major player within the Internet and telecom space before. And Microsoft continues to invest billions into MSN and Live, with relatively little to show for it, as the Internet division still continues to lose money. </p>
<p>But the point is, Microsoft seems to be quite willing to radically change its business model, and is willing to spend (and lose) billions to do so. Yet you’re telling me that Microsoft somehow can’t afford to pay more for better engineers? Really? </p>
<p>I would venture to say that perhaps if Microsoft were to hire better engineers, then maybe they wouldn’t be have to lose so much money on changing their business model. For example, Google and Yahoo are both highly profitable Internet companies. Why can’t Microsoft’s Internet division turn a profit? Both Sony and Nintendo have generated huge profits from their game consoles. Why can’t Microsoft generate profits from the Xbox?</p>
<p>But the bottom line is not that I am trying to position myself as a brilliant corporate strategist that really knows Microsoft’s problems (for I do not). What I am really saying is that many engineering companies could afford to pay more for better engineers. They just don’t want to. What I find remarkable is that they don’t want to pay for this, but they seem to have no problem in paying for many other things. Like consulting services. Like (in the case of Microsoft) ancillary investments.</p>
<p>But even this does not get to the true heart of the matter. It just raises several other points.</p>
<h1>1 - You say that consulting firms can , during the down times, simply retrain its employees to become ‘experts’ in whatever field happens to be hot. But it takes two to tango. Some company has to be willing to buy consulting services from these newly trained experts. Why are these companies willing to do so, as opposed to just hiring employees directly? Is it just a matter of superior marketing by the consulting firms?</h1>
<p>That leads directly to the next point…</p>
<h1>2 - You say that consulting firms can claim to have an instant expert on staff which they can sell to clients, which seems to speak strongly to superior marketing skills. But that just begs the question of why engineering firms can’t also obtain these same superior marketing skills in order to sell its products to which customer segment seems to be hot at the time? After all, if marketers are really so skillful as to be able to convince companies to buy consulting services from people who aren’t really experts at all, then marketers should also be able to convince regular people to buy products they don’t really need and aren’t that good.</h1>
<p>Hey why not? After all, marketers were able to convince people to buy the Pet Rock. Even today, bottled water is a triumph of US marketing: getting Americans to pay exorbitant amounts of money to buy something that is free (although I do agree that bottled water is actually valuable in those countries that don’t have clean water systems). </p>
<p>But the point is, if consulting firms are so skillful at marketing that they can pass off “experts” who aren’t really experts at all, then why can’t engineering firms learn how to do this? Why can’t engineering companies market themselves better? </p>
<h1>3 - The endgame logic of your argument is that engineering firms should merge and diversify so that they can ride out economic cycles (i.e. when one division is doing poorly, other divisions pick up the slack). That way, engineers who work in one division can retrain for another.</h1>
<p>But then that begs the question of why don’t firms do that then? Specifically, why doesn’t some entrepreneur come along and roll up a bunch of engineering firms together? In fact, this had been tried many times before in history. GM used to own Frigidaire (and hence sold refrigerators and air conditioners). GM also used to own a large IT consulting business (EDS, which is Ross Perot’s old company). Gulf & Western started life as a company that sold car bumpers to eventually also owning zinc mines, sugar plantations, and the movie/TV studio that would eventually become known as Paramount Pictures. We may know Nokia for cellphones today, but it wasn’t that long ago when Nokia still owned a bunch of lumber mills, rubber plantations, and tire factories (which were its original businesses). </p>
<p>The point is, if diversification was really so valuable, then we should be seeing a strong push for engineering companies to diversify and merge. I don’t see that. If there has been any push, it is for firms to spin off divisions and focus on core competencies. For example, as I mentioned above, Motorola doesn’t even sell semiconductors anymore, having spun off that division. If diversification is so beneficial, then why would Motorola spin off Freescale? Why did Nokia spin off its lumber and rubber divisions? {After all, during the tech bust of the early 2000’s, people may have been buying fewer cellphones, but people were still buying plenty of wood and rubber.} Those companies who do try to diversify will often times do so badly, losing billions in the process. Like Microsoft. Again, if diversification is really so beneficial, then Microsoft should have been making money through Xbox and MSN, not losing money.</p>
<p>Engineering companies do not have to lose money on new hires. They can find useful things for them to do as they learn on the job. They just cannot afford to pay them as much as you seem to want them to do as the new hires come up to speed. On the other hand, even they realize that if nobody is willing to hire new engineers right out of college that there soon will not be any experienced ones at all.</p>
<p>Work situations are complex in the way that numbers can be complex, meaning that there is both a real and an imaginary component to the work. If you only retain the people who are good at getting the real component of the work done, the imaginary component gets left undone and the managers cannot cope. In many situations, 20% of the people will do 80% of the work. That does not mean that you can leave the other 20% of the work undone or else get rid of 80% off the bottom and hire another 5% good people to do the rest of it. The fact is that it is really hard to measure productivity on the job. The two extremes are pretty easy and you certainly want to reward the best and get rid of the worst, but the vast majority of people in the middle are a much harder call. If you get rid of too many, all the little things that you never realized were important (the imaginary component as far as managers are concerned) stop getting done. You find that the super productive ones are only doing what is being measured (i.e. the real component) and not a bit more. You also find that everyone who wasn’t let go has really low morale, even the top producers, because they are now forced to lower their power factor by doing a part of the necessary imaginary work.</p>
<p>Also there is the question of where do you draw the line. Why not fire 95 and keep the five best? While I have argued that engineering is not a safe field already, if you are going to set the casualty rate that high, hardly anyone would be willing to spend four years and $100 -200K to get an engineering degree.</p>
<p>Companies hire consultants because it is easy to do so. You are giving managers too much credit if you think they can actually run things at or even near peak efficiency at all times. They make predictions and, when the predictions turn out to be wrong, they have a lot more flexibility to increase or decrease the number of consultants on short notice. There are always going to be individual glitches such as with your friend, where very likely they would have hired him as an employee but something weird happened (lost paperwork, he said exactly the wrong thing at the interview, a company-wide hiring freeze was implemented after the interview but before the offer - I have lost jobs to all of these). The decision to hire him as a contractor was likely made under different conditions and possibly by entirely different people. </p>
<p>ExxonMobil has been a major purchaser of consulting talent for quite some time. Their use of consultants does not represent tinkering with the model but staying the course. They pay for consultants rather than employees precisely because that decision has always served them well.</p>
<p>Microsoft has been known to make some boneheaded moves over the years. They can afford it due to their cash cow main lines of business. Anyone without such resources and without control in the hands of so few individuals would have probably cut their losses on Xbox long ago. In terms of acquisitions, they have long been willing to take chances looking for the big score. They are pursuing a model that has served them in the past, not changing directions simply because they occasionally rush out and buy something that caught Bill’s fancy. He only needs the occasional winner to come out ahead. Again I ask, why should Microsoft or any other highly profitable company suddenly decide to start paying their engineers more when they have survived and prospered for decades without having done so? </p>
<p>I am not saying that Microsoft cannot afford to pay their engineers more in the short term, just that they are not going to do so unless they have to and they know what will happen if they do. When the engineers get more, the managers and support staff also want more. Consultants will still be needed and they are not going be happy if their co-workers get raises and they do not. When you start favoring one group over another, it usually has to be done slowly and with clearly-announced intent or else everyone else feels undervalued.</p>
<p>It is not so much a matter of marketing skills as one of convenience when it comes to consulting firms. Engineering managers have been known to make mistakes on occasion and either hiring or firing consultants is one of the tried and true mechanisms that they use to try to correct those mistakes in real time. When those managers need to ramp up quickly in response to an unexpectedly hot project, they cannot afford to be quite as picky about the previous qualifications of their contractors as they would under other circumstances. Also, they know that 90% of what they need done could be accomplished by suitably trained chimpanzees and that the other 10% can be accomplished by the one or two real experts available either on staff or through the consulting firms.</p>
<p>The whole diversification/core competencies thing has a cycle of its own. It works better in some industries than in others. AT&T was rolling along quite well at over a million employees in wildly diverse lines of business until conditions changed that caused it to split up. Now look where they are after having spun off countless parts. For many years, it was advantageous for the regional Telcos established in 1984 to merge into larger companies. It was starting to look like the pieces of the big bang were putting themselves back together. More recently, Verizon is starting to split off parts of its territory that it has not been able to run profitably. These things come and go in cycles, along with management fads. True diversification comes from being able to adapt to change and to grow or shrink quickly as the times demand. That is precisely what the use of consulting companies offers to a large part of the industry.</p>
<p>Yes, all of the engineers in my family have found an area that makes them happy. They all make a very nice living with normal work hours. Son is currently a happy engineering student with cool jobs both during school and during the summer. I’m sure there are many others who are happy as well. </p>
<p>No job is perfect in all respects. You must acknowledge that threads like this tend to attract people who are dissatisfied or who simply want to play devil’s advocate. The grass is always greener…</p>
<p>I was speaking of the post-degree casualty rate there, merper68. It is not easy to compare these two because most engineers start their careers with a Bachelors degree or perhaps a Masters. For doctors, I think the equivalent number would be the percentage who wash out after starting med school. I would be interested in hearing what that number is.</p>
<p>Actually, for all I have said, I am happy that I studied Engineering. As lkf725 points out, there is the grass is greener phenomenon and there are drawbacks to just about any job, plus Engineers are trained to analyze things and try to figure out how to make them better. If we can’t complain about something, it is time to turn to a different problem.</p>
<p>I was not saying that they should pay all new hires more. I am saying that they should pay the highly productive new hires much more. </p>
<p>I harken back to my old days as an engineer, and I remember one guy who was newly hired who was, frankly, far far more productive than most of the experienced engineers, yet was getting paid less. In fact, the disparity of productivity was so large that one day, some of the experienced engineers pulled him aside and advised him to work less because he was making the others in the office look bad. While they were half-joking when they said it, they were also half-serious. </p>
<p>Hence, the point is, I don’t see why engineering companies don’t ratchet their pay according to productivity. They usually already do so for salesmen. In my same old company, I have seen unusually talented new salesmen come in and blow away the figures of many of the experienced salesguys. The difference of course is that those new salesguys got paid extremely well for doing so. </p>
<p>
</p>
<p>But that’s not their problem. We both agree that engineering companies are greedy. So, sure, if nobody ever hires new guys, then in the future, there will be nobody entering engineering. But so what? If you’re really that greedy of a manager, then what matters is that you make money right now, so that you can make your bonuses right now, and whatever happens in the future is not your concern, right? That’s what you would expect highly greedy companies to do. </p>
<p>So then maybe companies are not that greedy and are actually more far-sighted than we thought. But if that’s the case, then maybe companies should also pay more to their best engineers to convince them not to leave, or to convince more of the best people to study engineering in the first place (or if they do study engineering, then to actually take engineering jobs). </p>
<p>
</p>
<p>Certainly there are measurement problems. I never said otherwise. </p>
<p>But at the end of the day, the fact remains that some engineers are far more productive than are others, whether that productivity is measured through real or imaginary components. And some engineers, as you would agree, do practically nothing at all. Yet engineering companies don’t seem to be interested in reducing the pay of those guys, or getting rid of them entirely. That’s odd. They do so without hesitation to their poor salesmen. Those guys get fired all the time. Odd that that doesn’t happen with engineers. </p>
<p>Personally, I strongly suspect that this is why many of the best engineers won’t work for large companies, but instead strongly prefer startups. It’s not just because startups can offer an open and free-flowing environment with flexible opportunities for advancement. It also has to do with the fact that startups offer large stock options that not only accord you the opportunity to become filthy rich, but, more importantly, make that opportunity operationally controllable. In other words, working very hard to produce an excellent engineering product in a startup company will probably vastly increase the value of that company and hence will vastly boost the worth of your options. For example, if you produce a product that is worth $5 million in a company that is itself worth only $5 million, then you’ve just doubled the value of the company (and hence doubled the value of your options). In contrast, even if you’re the greatest engineer in the world, if you work at a huge company, whatever you do as an individual won’t really move the needle. A successful $5 million project will do almost nothing to the stock price of ExxonMobil, which has a market cap of nearly $600 billion. </p>
<p>
</p>
<p>Well first off, I don’t think we need to worry about where we draw the line. After all, my proposals do not have to be perfect. They just have to be better than the status quo, and the status quo ain’t that good. Hence, clearly there is flexibility to draw the line that is better than what is happening right now. </p>
<p>Secondly, as merper68 said, plenty of people spend plenty of money on an undergrad education with the express purpose of becoming doctors, and then don’t make it to med school (either because they can’t get into med school or because they don’t even apply because they know they won’t get in). Perhaps more poignantly, the vast majority of people who want to become investment bankers and especially the alternative investment firms (i.e. private equity, hedge funds, venture capital, wealth management, etc.) won’t get offers. But that doesn’t stop people from spending vast sums of money trying. For example, even at Harvard Business School, most people who want to work in private equity won’t get an offer. But of course, that pay of $450k+ equity *just to start<a href=“for%20the%20top%20PE%20firms”>/i</a>, and the realistic chance to make 7 figures in just a few years will continue to draw people like flies. </p>
<p>
</p>
<p>Uh, in the case of my friend, none of those things happened. Remember, they made him an offer. But my friend turned it down. Why? Several reasons, but one big one was simply that the consulting firm was offering far more money than that engineering firm. As my friend told me, it wasn’t even close. </p>
<p>What is ironic is that my friend, while working as an embedded consultant at that engineering firm, eventually met that manager who had tried to hire him before and asked him why he didn’t take the job if he was going to end up working here (as a consultant) anyway. My friend said candidly because the consulting firm was paying him much more (and also offered better career development). All that manager could do was wince and nod his head. </p>
<p>However, at the end of the day, the moral of the story is that as long as consultants are getting better treatment than are the engineers, then people will rationally prefer to be consultants. See below. </p>
<p>
</p>
<p>And all you are doing here is just reinforcing the notion that the best engineers should then choose to work as consultants. After all, if companies like ExxonMobil are not willing to pay their engineers better than their consultants, then people should rationally choose to be consultants. After all, why make less money when you can make more? </p>
<p>
</p>
<p>Yeah, so pay them ALL more. Why not? Even if you doubled the salary of everybody at Microsoft, I am quite certain that the expense would still not be even close to the money that has been lost on Xbox alone. </p>
<p>But more to the point, what I am saying is that I don’t see why Microsoft can’t change its business model with respect to pay if it’s willing to change its business model with respect to acquisitions. 10 years ago, Microsoft didn’t give a whit about games (except for Flight Simulator). Now they care deeply, to the point that they’ve been willing to lose billions. That’s a pretty big change in business model. Nobody is forcing Microsoft to become a game company. So one could ask why Microsoft is trying to become a game company now? Why not just stick with what worked for them, that is, minting cash from Windows and Office? To this day, Xbox is still a financial failure for Microsoft, yet that hasn’t stopped Microsoft from pouring even more money into it. </p>
<p>Hence, if nobody is forcing Microsoft to become a game company, yet they’re trying to do it anyway, then why do you necessarily need anybody to force Microsoft to pay more for better engineers? Why can’t they just decide to do it anyway? Again, doing so would be far far less expensive than their Xbox investment. </p>
<p>You also talk about how paying certain people more might roil the rest of the employees who will also want more. But consider this. Microsoft already “pays” certain people more (far far more). Again, let’s talk about the Microsoft Xbox/game division. As part of that strategy, Microsoft has acquired numerous game startup companies, hence making those startups’ employees rich. For example, when Microsoft acquired Bungie Studios (the makers of Halo), employees at Bungie became filthy rich through their stock options. The same could be said for the acquisitions of game studios like Rare Ltd., Lionhead, Digital Anvil, VWEG, etc. Most of those employees became Microsoft employees upon acquisition. And they were rich Microsoft employees from their former options.</p>
<p>So here’s a case where clearly Microsoft is “paying” certain people far more than it pays others. In fact, I remember one former Microsoft manager, who used to work in the games division, talking about how he actually managed some of the engineers who came from the various game acquisitions and thinking to himself: “It’s rather surreal that I am these guys’ boss, yet they have a personal net worth that might be 100x of mine.” In other words, certain Microsoft current employees (i.e. the ones who came from acquisition) have been “paid” far far more than other Microsoft employees (i.e. the inhouse Microsoft employees). Yet if that caused tension, Microsoft didn’t seem to care.</p>
<p>Furthermore, many of the acquisitions don’t work out, yet those acquired people get rich anyway. For example, the Digital Anvil acquisition ultimately failed (and Microsoft shut it down last year). Yet Chris Roberts and the other DA people got rich anyway. They got rich the day the acquisition went down, and if the technology later flounders, they don’t care. They’ve already made their money. </p>
<p>
</p>
<p>Ah, now I think we’re getting to brass tacks, because now we are talking about some actual *differences *between engineering firms and consulting firms.</p>
<p>But we need to explore this further. You say that engineering firms can flexibly hire and fire consultants. But that begs the question of why they can’t also flexibly hire and fire engineers? </p>
<p>Secondly, you talk about how 90% of the consultants work is really the work of trained chimpanzees. I don’t agree with the characterization, but let’s suppose it’s true. So then why are engineering firms willing to *pay so much * for the work of these chimps? After all, if the work is not hard to do, then they shouldn’t have to pay so much for people to do it, right? Seems to me that they can just take one of their existing engineers, put him through the same short training period that the consultants undergo, and then that guy would be able to do the work of the consultant. So why pay through the nose to bring in that consultant? </p>
<p>In other words, if it really is so easy for consulting firms to retrain their people, then it should also be easy for engineering companies to retrain their people. Are engineering companies really so pressed for profits that they can’t afford even a few weeks of training (i.e. see Microsoft)? Or consider the converse: are consulting firms really so flush with profits that they can afford to constantly retrain their people?</p>
<p>Very true, just wish there was more posts like this. I find it really hard to believe that having an engineering job means you have no room for advancement</p>
<p>It has taken me awhile, but I am starting to realize that you are expecting companies, particularly large ones, to act in a unified, self-consistent, rational manner. In reality, a lot of decisions get made by committees of self-interested parties, each of whom is attempting to optimize the outcome of the decision over a different set of criteria. There is a lot of ego and a lot of butt-covering that goes into these decisions and the result does not always come out rationally in terms of dollars or sense.</p>
<p>For example, a budget will be set at the start of the project for so many employees and so many consultants in order to provide some flexibility. The pot for consultants is controlled locally by the project manager, while the one for employees comes through HR. Employees are therefore more difficult for a project manager to hire. They are also more difficult to fire, because you either have to go through the process of documenting a firing for cause to protect against a lawsuit, or you have to be willing to pay severance costs that can be quite large for an experienced employee (and you still have to worry about discrimination lawsuits.) You have to get permission from three levels of management above you, all of whom are going to be asking awkward questions about why the person was ever hired to begin with. There will be security concerns while all of this is going on and morale will suffer in general. Companies take all of this into consideration when hiring employees and tend to be careful when not desperate. To hire a contractor, you fill out a couple of forms and make a phone call and they show up in a day or two. To fire one, you simply inform them that their contract will not be renewed and they go away until you call them again. That convenience is worth a lot to the person who is actually making the decision, even though it may wind up costing the company as a whole a bit more to purchase what are essentially the same services.</p>
<p>If you did not spot the chimp remark as being pointed exaggeration, I will have to remember to be more literal with you. This is yet another case of building micro empires within a company and butt-covering. In order to make the financial planning easier, at least the companies that I have worked for tend to think in terms of headcount and whether the person is a new hire, a mid-level market hire or a highly-experienced market hire. Managers are given their allotments of each at the start of a fiscal cycle and they go looking for the best talent they can find within the framework set by the company. They do not care about matching the capabilities of the engineer to the average demands of the job, they want someone who can handle the unexpected tough problems that come up when you least expect them. The way the job market has been for the last several years, those people do not cost a whole lot more than the ones who are more suited to the mundane job requirements.</p>
<p>There are two kinds of consulting firms - those that will carry and retrain their employees between paid engagements and those that will not. The former has nothing better to do with its employees than retraining during beach time, so that is what gets done. The latter simply goes out and finds somebody that already has enough of the needed skills to be able to get by after they have identified an iron-clad opportunity to sell their services. Engineering firms do train people, but tend to do so less willingly because the costs of doing so are highly visible in the short term. The long term cost of training employees may well be less that the long term cost of not training them from within, but the long term does not always get considered.</p>
<p>In terms of the effect of paying some people more than others within a company, the problem is inertia. If it is already an accepted part of the corporate culture that certain jobs pay more than others, that will be accepted by the employees. It is when you try to change the status quo that everyone puts out their hand and starts asking, “Where’s mine?” Acquisitions occasionally present the kinds of problems that you raise. Startups represent a very high-risk situation in which everyone involved is looking to strike it rich but accept that they may wind up with very little to show for a lot of hard work. If you were to take away that potential for the big reward, there would be a lot fewer startups, even though they already represent a pretty small part of the overall industry. It is only the successful ones that grow into larger, established firms and the ones that fail spectacularly that you ever hear about. The ones that quietly disintegrate do not make for good news copy.</p>
<p>I have already explained some of the financial and non-financial reasons that I prefer (some) engineering jobs to (some) consulting jobs. If they were to make the decision solely based on salary, then the best talent would all go to the consulting firms. Since that is not entirely the case, at least some of the best are basing their actions on other criteria. Once again, I will not speculate on their decisions as a group because this is a highly individual matter.</p>
<p>Your proposals do not have to be perfect, but they do have to do more than slightly increase the overall status quo. You also have to increase the status quo of a sufficient majority of the current crop of decision makers (whose status quo is usually a whole lot better than the average) to get them to overcome inertia.</p>