<p>I salute you two!</p>
<p>
</p>
<p>The higher paying jobs in banking and consulting are mostly based off commissions/sales/trading, etc. Sales-oriented jobs involve higher risk and thus, higher reward.</p>
<p>This thread is a wealth of information for anyone considering engineering as a possible career path. Thanks for having this debate</p>
<p>
I’d be highly surprised if I-Banks offered significantly higher hourly compensation than ExxonMobil for engineers. For entry level positions it’s all in the amount of hours.</p>
<p>
</p>
<p>I expect no such thing. The organizational decision-making process is not of concern to me. What is of concern to me is the final outcome.</p>
<p>As a case in point, there are large and small engineering firms. There are also large and small consulting firms. None of them would be expected to behave in a unified manner, nor do I expect them to do so. Nevertheless, the inescapable conclusion is that, for some reason, consulting firms (aggregated over small and large consulting firms) seem to pay better and offer more opportunities than do the engineering firms (again, aggregated over all small and large firms). My question is - why? </p>
<p>Sure, engineering firms probably don’t make decisions rationally. But neither would we expect consulting firms to make decisions rationally. Yet at the end of the day, they arrive at different decisions. Rationality doesn’t seem to have anything to do with it. </p>
<p>
</p>
<p>But that doesn’t address the question on the table. These ‘contractors’ to the engineering firm are themselves employees. They are just employees of a consulting firm. Hence, you say that engineering firms have difficulty hiring and firing employees. I agree. But then why is it that those consulting firms can hire and fire employees more easily? Why don’t they have to go through 3 levels of bureaucracy before they hire anybody? Why don’t they have to go through a bureaucratic process of documentation before firing people? How exactly is it that they can have those extra people around such that they can supply the demand of engineering firms for those extra bodies? </p>
<p>In short, the question boils down to why consulting firms seem to be able to defy the laws of economics and have extra people on their payroll when they’re not needed, when engineering firms are not able to do so? See below. </p>
<p>
</p>
<p>Uh, I think it is *I *that has to remind you to be more literal. The question on the table is still unanswered - why don’t consulting firms experience the same staffing issues that engineering firms experience? </p>
<p>To wit: you talk about engineering managers being given allotments as to how many people they can hire. But then that begs the question of why exactly aren’t consulting managers also being forced to abide by allotments as to how many people they can hire? You talk about engineering managers not caring about matching hirees to typical job tasks. But then do consulting managers care about this? </p>
<p>In short, again, it comes down to the basic question - what makes engineering organizations different from consulting organizations? At the end of the day, they are both organizations and hence should be subject to the same forces, right? Yet the outcomes are dramatically different. Why?</p>
<p>
</p>
<p>You’re dancing around the core issue here without actually speaking to it. The question is why does this kind of firm have nothing better to do with its employees such that they can send them to retraining, and in particular, why can’t an engineering firm do that too? </p>
<p>Like we’ve agreed before, consulting firms are firms just like any other firm. They’re out to make as much money as they can. They’re characterized by managers and investors who are only looking to make short-term profits. Yet, despite all this, they’re still able to carry all these employees with nothing better to do than retrain? How’s that? And if they can do that, why can’t engineering companies? </p>
<p>
</p>
<p>And these are not the examples of consulting firms that superstar engineering students are liable to join, at least, not right after undergrad. So they’re irrelevent to this discussion. </p>
<p>
</p>
<p>Exactly - so you agree that training costs short-term money. But then, again, why is it that those consulting companies (or at least, the subset of consulting firms that you call the ‘former’ group) is able to pay that short-term cost? We agreed before that consulting managers are just as greedy and focused on the short-term as engineering managers. Yet, despite that, somehow they are still able to pay for training for a long-term payoff. How is that? </p>
<p>
</p>
<p>Ah, so you agree that the problem is cultural. In other words, by extension, I think you would agree that you could have an engineering firm that offered wide disparities in pay, as long as you built the initial culture around such a philosophy. Hence, there is no inherent reason why engineering firms couldn’t pay one engineer 10x more than another. </p>
<p>And in fact, many engineering firms do exactly this already. For example, some engineers at Google are far richer than are others, and it has nothing to do with acquisitions. Google’s early engineers tend to be far far richer than the later engineers simply because the early engineers got in before the 2004 IPO. Similarly, Microsoft still has many multi-millionaire engineers that benefitted from the huge gains in their stock option valuations of the 80’s and 90’s. But engineers who have joined Microsoft in the last few years are not rich. </p>
<p>Nevertheless, I think we have established that there is no *inherent * reason why engineering firms couldn’t pay widely disparate pay packages. They could. The reason why most don’t today is due to arbitrary choices that were set in the past and that have shaped the current culture in a path-dependent way. But those choices were arbitrary. They could have made different choices. More importantly, those who are starting an engineering company today can make different choices. </p>
<p>
</p>
<p>First off, nobody is saying that every consulting firm is superior to every engineering firm. There are indeed plenty of bad consulting firms and plenty of good engineering firms out there. Google, for example, is a shining example of a very good engineering firm, superior to almost every consulting firm out there.</p>
<p>Secondly, nobody is trying to argue that salary is the end-all, be-all. Obviously numerous other factors have to be taken into account. </p>
<p>Nevertheless, at the end of the day, what is undeniable is that many of the best engineering students no longer choose to work as engineers, instead preferring to be consultants. I think that it is important to understand exactly why this is happening and why engineering firms don’t really seem to care. </p>
<p>
</p>
<p>And I believe that my proposals do indeed improve the status quo, and by quite a bit. Like I said, I believe that if engineering firms were to simply put more effort into hiring better engineers (i.e. increasing pay, boosting training, etc.), then they wouldn’t need to pay so much for consulting services. Consulting firms like McKinsey, BCG, Bain, etc. will charge you millions for an engagement. And like I said, many of their employees are * the same people that would have worked for you directly if you had just made them a better offer*. So if that’s the case, then why not just cut out the middleman? Why pay the consulting overhead? Why not just hire these people directly? You either pay more to these people as direct hires, or you pay even more to bring them on as consultants. Financially speaking, I think the choice is obvious. </p>
<p>However, to your second point, no I don’t think I have to increase the status quo of a ‘sufficient majority’. All I have to do is change the minds of only a minority of highly-influential tastemakers. For example, when McKinsey recently decided to boost starting consulting salaries, most of the other consulting firms quickly followed suit. Why is that? McKinsey is just one consulting firm. But it is a highly influential consulting firm. Similarly, when Goldman Sachs recently boosted starting pay packages, so did many of the other investment banks.</p>
<p>
</p>
<p>Indeed so. But apparently a lot of top students want that. So then why won’t engineering firms also offer these sorts of high risk/high-reward jobs to potential hires?</p>
<p>And in fact, many of them effectively do. Startup technology firms probably represent the pinnacle of high risk & high reward. Those engineers who joined Microsoft in 1975 and stayed for the IPO became multimillionaires. Those engineers who joined Google in 1998 and stayed for the IPO became multi-millionaires. I once attended a talk with one of those early Google engineers a few years ago. He hadn’t even turned 30 years old, yet had an estimated net worth of probably over $50 million (and perhaps more now, as Google’s stock price has increased over the last few years). </p>
<p>But obviously many startups go bankrupt and hence their engineers do not become rich. Yet the fact remains that startup companies are extremely attractive to many of the top graduating engineering students, with the chance - however small - of a giant reward being a core component of the attraction. Numerous engineering students from MIT, Stanford, Berkeley, etc. join startups, or found their own, rather than work for established engineering firms.</p>
<p>So it begs the question of why established engineering firms can’t offer a more ‘high-powered’ pay package - that is, a pay package that is more contingent on the success of your project. The more commercially successful your project, the more you would get paid, and I think that’s exactly the way it ought to be. That’s how startups are. The early Google engineers became immensely rich because they worked on a project that turned out to be highly commercially successful. In that way, a highly productive engineer will be paid according to his productivity, and that’s exactly the way it should be. Those early Google employees created billions of dollars in wealth, and it is only fair that those early employees who were creating so much value become rich themselves. {As a case in point, on the day of Google’s 2004 IPO, Google was valued at a market cap of around $20 billion, which means that from the 6 years between Google’s founding in 1998 until the 2004 IPO, Google employees were creating $3.33 billion of economic value a year or a whopping $9 million a day.}</p>
<p>
</p>
<p>I agree that it’s all in the hours. Ibankers work dreadful hours.</p>
<p>But what can I say? For whatever reason, many of the best engineering students seem to want that. They don’t seem to mind working 90+ hours a week. </p>
<p>I would again point to the startups. Engineers at tech startups also work ridiculous hours. Most of those startups won’t make it big, which means that those engineers will not be paid well at all. Yet many engineers don’t seem to mind this and are willing to take that chance. For example, I know quite a few MIT engineering students who turned down jobs with large engineering companies in order to join startups.</p>
<p>So it begs the question of why these large companies can’t offer jobs that pay very highly (or at least offer the potential for very high pay) in return for massive hours worked. </p>
<p>Heck, I remember when I was younger and had no responsibilities, I might have wanted to work 90 hours a week if I got paid more to do it. But I couldn’t. My employer had no mechanism to deal with somebody who just wanted to stay in the office and worked more. Sure, they would have liked it and they would have given me more projects to do. But my pay would not have increased. Hence, why should I work more hours? I don’t receive any financial benefit from doing so.</p>
<p>You say yourself that consulting firms pay better than engineering firms. That tells you right there why they find it easier to hire people. They pay more because they have to pay more in order to be able to supply what the industry needs on short notice. They pay more because the people who work for them know that they have even less career stability and (in most cases) less in the way of fringe benefits than they would when working at an engineering firm. Look at the recent demise of Ensemble Chimes Global. They were one of the larger contracting firms around and they filed for Chapter 7 bankruptcy leaving their own employees and the contractors that they supply to several industries unpaid for anywhere from a week to more than a month. Unlike an engineering firm that would take years to rebuild, the executives from ECG could be running the same kind of operation in a different state or country a month from now.</p>
<p>The employer/employee relationship between “permanent” employees of an engineering firm and their employer is very different from the relationship between contractors and the contracting firm that supplies their paycheck. Engineering firms mostly hire their engineers at an annual salary and in most cases expect more than a 40 hour week without paid overtime. Consulting firms generally have two classes of workers - a salaried staff that is usually pretty small, and the consultants who are paid by the hour or day to work for other firms. At least in the US, the salaried workers and the hourly/daily paid consultants operate under a completely different set of laws and expectations. The answer to your questions mostly lie in those differences. While I have agreed that both consulting firms and engineering firms are out to make money, I have never agreed with you that they are alike in other important ways. </p>
<p>Some consulting firms will pay their consultant employees for short periods of beach time between gigs as a means to retain and retrain them, but only for those people who they are certain will be in demand. If your billable time drops much below the 90% range, most consulting firms will drop you pretty quickly. With the current glut of unemployed engineers on the market and thousands more being turned out by schools every year, neither the engineering firms nor the consulting firms have a lot of incentive to hold on to employees that they do not immediately need. Engineering firms used to train from within a lot more than they do now in the boom years when there was a shortage rather than a glut. Now, they can be pretty sure that they can get someone either on the open market or through a consulting firm with almost exactly the experience that they need. As an engineer, you pretty much have to retrain on your own dime these days and hope that you pick areas that will be in demand.</p>
<p>Concerning being more literal, you do not need to remind me. I was reminding myself, not asking you to be either more or less literal.</p>
<p>While new employees may not be bound by choices that seemed arbitrary in the past, existing companies are bound by the choices that they made and the set of laws and expectations that have accumulated since those choices were made. If new hires limit themselves to companies that have a particular corporate culture and pay structure, they may find that it takes a good bit longer to find a job. If they are willing to make that tradeoff, that is fine, but they should not expect that the industry is going to change overnight just for them.</p>
<p>Engineering companies will always be willing to pay for a certain number of consultants because they value the convenience and flexibility that they bring. That number changes with market condition and the relative availability or scarcity of the particular talent needed. Hiring a specialist on a long-term basis may not interest an engineering company so long as they can rent his or her services when they really need them. In such a case, paying a consulting firm a somewhat higher hourly rate for a few weeks or months could be far cheaper than hiring the same person, particularly when the added costs of hiring/firing, training and employee benefits are factored in. </p>
<p>I rent certain tools like wallpaper steamers, carpet cleaners and mechanical lifts when I need them. Over a lifetime, it may indeed have been cheaper for me to own them (well, not the mechanical lift) if I were to neglect the costs of storage, maintenance and the interest that could have been accruing on the money spent to purchase it. Similarly, when engineering firms consider all of the costs involved, there are situations in which it makes a whole lot of sense to rent help rather than buy it. That is exactly where the consulting firms come in.</p>
<p>If your proposals are that good and that easy to implement, I wish you much success in following through with them. There are many ways in which I would like to see the industry change, but I somehow doubt that such changes will occur in my lifetime.</p>
<p>
</p>
<p>But from a rational standpoint, it doesn’t make sense for people to then prefer to work for consulting firms the way that they seem to do so. After all, if consulting really was so unstable, if they really offered fewer benefits than does engineering - in short, if they really did not actually offer a better deal - then why would so many people want to work for them? Is the implication that people are not choosing rationally? </p>
<p>
</p>
<p>I completely disagree with your characterization, although perhaps now I can see why we have always come to odds. </p>
<p>Hence, to clarify, I am not, and I never have been talking about all of those ‘body-shop’ contracting/consulting firms out there. I have always been specifically talking about consulting firms such as McKinsey, BCG, Bain, Booz Allen Hamilton, Accenture, CapGemini, and so forth. Believe me, *almost all * of the consultants at these firms are fully salaried and fulltime employees. They are not guns-for-hire. </p>
<p>Like I said before, engineering students from MIT, Stanford, etc. are not turning down engineering jobs to join one of these guns-for-hire contracting body shops. They are turning down engineering jobs to join McKinsey or those other consulting firms. And that is why I have been discussing this topic. </p>
<p>
</p>
<p>Yet the question still stands. Even if McKinsey and other similar consultancies will only retain people for short periods of lull time, the question remains as to why they are able to do that and engineering firms can’t. Again, it’s not like engineering firms are significantly greedier than McKinsey is. McKinsey is a tremendously greedy firm. </p>
<p>
</p>
<p>And similarly, those people who join consultancies are bound by the rules of the past. McKinsey is over 80 years old: older than most extant engineering firms. BCG is 40 years old. It would seem to me that their work environments would currently encompass decisions that were made a long time ago too. </p>
<p>Nevertheless, I think you may be onto something - that the difference may be indeed due to path-dependent culture. But then that’s just a reason for why people will continue to choose consulting over engineering. </p>
<p>
</p>
<p>But as I’ve said before, the cost of that full-time employee doesn’t ‘disappear’. It just gets shifted to the consulting firm. So then that begs the question of why the consulting firm is better able to carry the cost of hiring that full-time employee. But at the end of the day, somebody has to assume the costs of employment. </p>
<p>Furthermore, to extend this argument, then why do engineering firms ever bother to hire anybody full-time? Why not just bring in everybody as a contractor/consultant? This gets down to what economists have called the scope of the firm: why do firms even exist at all, why does employment even exist at all, why doesn’t everybody just work as an independent contractor? After all, if you really can just rent an engineer as a gun-for-hire from one of these consulting firms, why not always do that? I think you would agree with me that there must be some optimal point at which it is better to hire permanent full-time employees, and the question on the table is where that point is. </p>
<p>
</p>
<p>I am not saying that my ideas are easy to implement, or that they are necessarily even that good (although I believe they are). </p>
<p>What I am saying is that change does indeed happen. Consider Silicon Valley engineering companies, which are structured in a completely different way from traditional engineering companies, with SV firms being far less hierarchical and more willing to use incentive-based pay through stock options. Coincidentally (although, perhaps, not so coincidentally), Silicon Valley has dominated its competition. For example, Silicon Valley computer companies absolutely annihilated the Massachusetts computer industry that used to be dominant just a few decades ago. SV networking and communications firms such as Cisco are crushing the East Coast networking and telco vendors such as Lucent.</p>
<p>Ultimately, I fear that that is the way that firms change. It’s a population ecology standpoint (see Hannan & Freeman). Firms don’t change, I agree. So what happens is that suboptimal firms get selected against and go bankrupt. Those engineering firms that choose not to participate in the war on talent and who don’t value their employees are, I fear, also going to be selected out, in favor of those other firms that do value their talent.</p>
<p>Would going to umich over gatech or vice versa offer any more opportunities job-wise, or are both very comparable?</p>
<p>Depends on what kind of job you want. If it’s engineering, then it’s probably the same. Heck, Georgia Tech might even have a slight edge.</p>
<p>However, if you’re considering working in consulting or investment banking afterwards, then I would say that Michigan is the better way to go.</p>
<p>Some of the consulting firms you mention do treat their workers more like employees than what you refer to as the ‘body-shop’ kind of firm, but they still structure their business toward meeting the needs of firms that, for whatever reason, want to outsource some part of their operation. This is reflected in all of their dealings with their own employees, from the language in their contracts to the expectations of everyone involved. While there are a few such firms that have remained in business over the long term, they do not represent a particularly large portion of the market. If you are looking at small subsections of a market, you can find examples to support almost any theory you care to advance. You are obviously talking about a few top schools and a few particular companies while I am trying to answer your questions based on my own experiences, which have included everything from being an employee of industry leaders to an hourly hired gun at a body shop that nobody would work for if given much of a choice.</p>
<p>Engineering companies find it economical to have a mixture of employees and consultants. Some potential employees prefer to maximize their salary at the expense of other benefits which they either feel that they do not need or can obtain elsewhere for less than the salary differential. Others place a higher value on a long-term commitment. Still others, in a glutted market, find that there are more opportunities in their area of expertise coming through one source or the other. Consulting companies see an opportunity and fill it. The operation of the free market does the rest.</p>
<p>I agree that there is a point, one side of which it makes more sense to hire a worker as an employee and the other side of which it makes more sense to hire them as a contractor. Just like that mechanical lift I rent on rare occasion - it would never pay for me to buy one given the amount I use it. Conversely, it would not make a lot of sense for me to rent a vacuum cleaner which is needed frequently, sometimes when the local tool rental store is closed. The problem with workers is that the analysis is never quite that straightforward. Furthermore, the decisions are made not by individuals, but by several levels of management each of which may have a slightly different agenda and most of which will be looking to shift the cost of the decision into someone else’s portion of the budget. Decisions made in that manner do not always appear to be logical or even reasonable to an individual. Add to that the fact that the point that we agree exists shifts around over time, sometimes fairly rapidly. It is not hard to see why companies cannot optimize their operations under such circumstances, rather that they do as well as they do. </p>
<p>In the long term your theories of corporate evolution may be correct but, in the long term, we are all dead. In the short term, it has proven necessary to the survival of many corporations to devalue their talent, to reduce costs at every possible opportunity whether that means outsourcing to India, eliminating the training budget, drastically slashing R&D or taking appropriate measures to streamline internal processes. Given the choice between doing that now and going out of business in a matter of months, most of them decide to cut costs now even though some of the measures they are forced to take in the short-term do not bode well for survival ten to twenty years out. That is why I believe that there is no security in any single company, be it engineering or consulting. You have to look out for yourself, continually acquire relevant new skills and be ready to move one way or the other when it makes sense.</p>
<p>A first year engineering student myself, and also considering consulting/banking so early in my life, I just want to tell you why I chose engineering in the first place and why I want to switch.</p>
<p>I chose engineering because it is something I had interest in during my school years and as such filled up most of my high school courses with science and math. I think I had a strong interest in the business fields, as seen in my choice of extra-C’s etc., and could just as easily have pursued a business career from the start but I chose not to. Why? Maybe because I felt it was the “safer” route. I knew enough about what I was getting myself into from the courses I had taken and had also taken too few business courses to convince myself that it was something I was ready to commit a college major to. I did not do so because I felt it was the safer route financially. In fact, all the people I knew who had financial and job security in mind specifically stayed away from engineering (rightly or not) and even looked down on it as a profession. But that’s all a story for another discussion. </p>
<p>Now in University I have come to realize that like you people pointed out, college and/or high school might not be the best indicator of what actual work in the field is like. Actual engineering work is not guaranteed to be as interesting and glamorous as I thought it might be. I found as much interest in the economics course I was taking and noticed that there were many engineering courses I did not particularly like. The pay and general rewards to an engineering profession might be good to start but the salary “caps” and limited career advancements are very real. Engineering firms just don’t value productivity and experience as much as banking and consulting firms do. You are more valuable to a consulting firm the older and more experienced you are. Age to an engineering firm means you probably know less than the young engineer because of the pace of technology advancements and will probably demand more money for what might be seen as less productive work. So knowing I might not get my dream engineering job, I am looking to possibly go straight into consulting or banking without ever holding a real engineering job (i.e. not including internships). I figure I can still work on that interesting engineering project through a consulting firm with added benefits.</p>
<p>Now some reasons I think consulting firms pay more are, 1) the way engineering and consulting firms value age and experience are very different and 2) Consulting firms simply have nothing better to do with the profits they make than split it amongst their employees. An engineering firm could invest in some new project or try and expand in some way whereas the consulting firm’s product is basically the employees. </p>
<p>I also feel that consulting firms are very important and engineering firms are right 95% of the time to hire them when they could just as well pay employees to do the jobs. I only wish I could take an excerpt from the Vault Career Guide to consulting which has very valid points why they are used when their employees seem more than capable although it must be said that most of the reasons where political.</p>
<p>As long as you guys are talking about consulting, I have a question (might be slightly unrelated, so I apologize):</p>
<p>How difficult would it be for a science major (preferably biology or some concentration of it) to go into consulting after a bachelor’s degree? Masters? Thanks a bunch.</p>
<p>roroautomatic, those are my thoughts exactly. </p>
<p>For most business related professions, many of the skills you gain are transferable to many job roles, and makes you very flexible. In the business world, your expertise in a particular industry will be valuable, and it can only be gained through experience. Thus, as you get older, you become more valuable. </p>
<p>In engineering professions, you are trained to do something very specific, unless you work hard and work extra to get out of that role, you will only have a job as long as that role still exists, and it is also not very easily transferrable to other industries. And over time, your value plateaus, and you are stuck. (I’ve even had to explain in interviews, before I graduated college, why I didn’t want to do engineering)</p>
<p>How is engineering any harder to change roles from than biology or physics? How is organic chemistry any more applicable to business than thermodynamics? It’s not. It is just that BS engineers are usually giving up more (in terms of job opportunities) than those BS science students to do so.</p>
<p>Keefer is right on the money with “unless you work hard and work extra to get out of that role, you will only have a job as long as that role still exists.” Given the impact that technology has on most professions these days, it is dangerous to assume that the statement only applies to engineering.</p>
<p>Should roroautomatic ever open a consulting firm, I might just want to work there. If consulting firms had nothing better to do with their profits than split them among their employees, there would be little incentive to be an owner or a shareholder of those firms. I would also have a much larger bank account.</p>
<p>It is true that in an exceptionally profitable year the employees have probably worked more hours than usual and might get some overtime or bonus pay as a result, but the bulk of the profits are not returned to the employees unless the firm is substantially employee-owned. Some of the profits may be used to expand or improve operations or to reduce debt, some will certainly go toward dividends and increased equity for the owners and shareholders, some will probably be paid in taxes, but the employees are not going to get all that much of it in most cases.</p>
<p>As far as I know, engineering as a profession does not impose any continuing education requirements on its members. Thus, it is up to the individual as to whether he stays on top of his profession and of course not everyone does. This contrasts to healthcare professions where members have to complete some number of CE hours in order to renew their licenses. Maybe engineering specialties should demand that practitioners keep up in this fashion.</p>
<p>lfk725, in many states, P.E.'s do need continuing education credits in order to get their license renewed.</p>
<p>Oh, well that’s good then. I guess having the PE is one way to increase the prestige of an engineering job.</p>