If the LAC option is Amherst, note that Forbes a few years ago placed it first (and Williams third) in an article on “expensive colleges” that are “worth every penny”:
Nonetheless, I concur with others that excessive debt should be avoided.
If the LAC option is Amherst, note that Forbes a few years ago placed it first (and Williams third) in an article on “expensive colleges” that are “worth every penny”:
Nonetheless, I concur with others that excessive debt should be avoided.
Of course it does. But there is a super-strong Texas alum network in DC that will help you every bit as much. And: your first Capitol Hill jobs will pay very very little, and debt payment of $1K/mo will come out first.
(Also will/can your parents co-sign that much in loans?)
And I believe that @PurpleTitan’s point was that whatever money would have been spent on the expensive LAC could be saved to pay for grad school.
It all depends on if OP wants to ultimately end up on Capitol Hill or find his first jobs after college on Capitol Hill. If its the first jobs on C. H. it would make no sense to accumulate $80k+ debt for that.
To address a few points and hopefully bring some clarity:
The school in question is within Forbes top 25 schools in the country.
BingoMy parents are willing to cosign on loans if necessary.
As much as these are nice to have, I wouldn’t consider them goals for my near future. I already live quite frugally (by choice) and wouldn’t have an issue continuing to do so.
You could very well be correct. In my process of decision making though, I am making judgements based on the schools average salary after 2 years of $55k. Following undergrad I’d come back to live at home and find work in the region, which although isn’t guaranteed 100% is quite likely to work out given the area of the country. I’d stay until 75% of the debt at least is paid off, which I hope to do in 4 years. On even a $42k/yr salary, I believe I could do $1750/month and still have a livable income. That said, there are some things I might have forgotten to consider so please correct me if there’s an area you think I’m missing or not addressing.
I’m sorry, I should have clarified that I don’t plan on entering D.C. fresh out of school. See comment above this.
@collegemom3717 this addresses your later comment too.
Furthermore, quality of life is a large consideration in my decision. I am not confident in UT to deliver the same quality as the latter. However, though, I am not sure yet if a decreased quality of life 4 years is worth the debt later on.
$100k or so debt will cause you several years of decreased quality of life and reduced opportunities after graduation.
Are your parents contributing anything to your college expenses? If not, I would not take out a personal loan (co-signed) for 100K for undergrad. It’s a shame but it’s really something that needs to be thought out many, many years prior to college attendance.
If you were looking to get a job on Wall Street or management consulting, I could maybe see the value in taking out big loans for attending a top private feeder college to these industries but a government job does not seem to be a great value. You will get a great education at UT, albeit a totally different experience than say Williams and the like.
Nothing fully confirmed yet but I am estimating ~8k/yr, which if so would bring my yearly loan amount to the lower end I had mentioned earlier of $20k.
You are working out your options well…just be sure to recognize the implicit costs and trade-offs.
For example, to pay for spending 4 years in a big-name school, surrounded by other ambitious high achievers, with a goal to get to Capital HIll, you will then go back to Texas and work for 4 years. Will you want to go back home for 4 years? what if a summer internship leads to a great job that would take you the direction you want to go- but it’s not in Texas / doesn’t pay enough to both survive & make your debt payments? Or, if you do go back to Texas, once your debt is 75% paid off would you move someplace more exciting? or do your MBA at UT-A? Then take your new MBA and your 4 years of experience and move to DC? Could you afford to do that?
No matter what, though, UT will not have the same type of quality of life as the fancy NE school- b/c they are very different environments.
Without being disrespectful, you sound like you want someone to tell you to go to the LAC.
The UT Austin label will carry far more weight within Texas for jobs and networking than any NE LAC. Texas folks are very, very fond of UT. Although I agree that the LAC may be a better overall experience, it will not have a good ROI within Texas.
"another possible scenario is working at a consulting/banking gig and paying off the $80k debt in a few years after college while being sent to a prestigious MBA program by an employer.
Depending on the “elite” college OP is talking about and its track record of sending graduates to $100k+ consulting and banking jobs the LAC route can still work to his/her advantage. "
Another scenario that is far from guaranteed. And these days, really only MBB covers the whole MBA tuition. I can guarantee you that far from everyone who wants to enter MBB from undergrad manages to do so even from the LAC with the best placement record.
Same with IB.
Not to mention that IB hours are insane and those jobs tend to be in high cost areas that make paying off debt difficult.
OP, I don’t think you understand what it’s like to carry a $100K debt starting out in life. Personally, instead of either of these 2 options, I’d recommend working a year and trying to support yourself on your own. There’s a lot of educational value to be gained simply by doing that. You’ll come to realize that there’s a lot of uncertainty (for instance, in getting and keeping a job; or even finding any work–try to find a job right now, for instance) but debt doesn’t go away even if your income does.
Another possible scenario is you go to college and end up changing your major and, consequentially, your career path.
I’ve experienced debt. Debt is bad.
If the parents are willing to co-sign the loan, that’s the whole ballgame. Hard to judge where they are coming from.
A 40K EFC, including room and board + books, is a pretty sweet deal for a NESCAC (which I think is a more inclusive term than Little Three.) And, Parent-plus loans are not that unusual for even the most well-heeled families. If the parents are willing to co-sign a loan for three-quarters of the cost of attendance, they may be indicating that there is a family asset that they are not willing to dissolve just yet. Perhaps, they are thinking it will accrue in value at a faster rate than the debt service on a loan (I mean, it’s Texas. Who knows?)
OTOH, they may just be naive. Either way, I see the OP shopping for North Face outerwear in the near future.
This is the worst of both worlds. Most of the value from a school comes directly after graduation. You are going to pay for the expensive education then go to the cheaper school and compete on their home turf? Living at home for 4 years after living on your own for 4?
@collegemom3717 @roycroftmom @Jon234 @Eeyore123 Fair points from all of you. Thank you for responding, seeing some of the potential scenarios written down has helped me come to the realization of their viability.
Still a lot of reflecting I am having to do, both in terms of my personal short and long term goals. Nonetheless, the perspectives everyone has brought to the table have been helpful in guiding me. Thank you all!
With that said, I am still open to more comments and look forward to discussing with you all.
Unfortunately not the case.
It is a big assumption during current crisis to assume your parents will qualify for Plus loans each year - if they were to be unable to cosign, you’d have to drop out of the NE LAC.
^^ $25/bbl oil may be a bigger issue for Texas than COVID-19.