It seems that you value the short term much more than the medium or long term – i.e. you have a high discount rate when comparing the present value of something in the short term (college) versus the present value of something in the medium or long term (after college).
“A 40K EFC, including room and board + books, is a pretty sweet deal for a NESCAC (which I think is a more inclusive term than Little Three.)”
Depends on alternatives and resources. To me, UT-Austin tuition-free when the family doesn’t really have the resources for something a lot more (like the LAC) seems sweeter.
“And, Parent-plus loans are not that unusual for even the most well-heeled families.”
Doesn’t make the decision to take them any smarter. Plenty of people may have overleveraged to buy a house they really couldn’t afford before the '08-'09 crisis. Didn’t mean that was actually a smart decision.
@Eeyore123 haha yeah it’s been crazy… what goes down will always come back up at some point eventually.
Fair assumption. I guess I should outline in more detail reasons I believe it’s worth the investment at option 1. Please don’t hesitate to tear holes in these (as that’s what I’m here for).
- Option one puts me in an academic environment I believe I am more likely to thrive in. The small class sizes and proximity to professors is something I’ve realized that engages me far more than the contrary. UT’s considerable size is something that has pushed me away, and I was unfortunately rejected from the honors college. I do see somewhat how size can be a pro, but haven’t been fully sold on that yet.
- Strength in my desired programs as well as more fulfilling and meaningful work. In the areas I hope to study, option 1 thrives and offers many attractive grants, fellowships, and real-world study programs that are lacking from option 2.
- Students at option 1 report some of the highest quality of student life in the nation. While this might be a weaker point than the others, I think it is telling. This intertwines with the school’s emphasis on collaboration as opposed to competition.
It is quite possible you will thrive more in the 4 years of college at the LAC than at UT. It is the subsequent 40 years I would worry about
Now do the comparison for the next ten years after graduation comparing:
- Graduating with $100k debt.
- Graduating with $0 debt.
Consider how that will affect your choice of:
a. Where you can live.
b. What jobs you could take.
c. What quality of life you could have.
d. What progress you could make toward long term financial goals.
@socaldad2002 believe it or not UT is a very large feeder for IB. Especially regionals. It’s a player.
“Students at option 1 report some of the highest quality of student life in the nation.”
Drivers of Mercedes report some of the highest quality of driving in the nation. I don’t borrow money to drive one, though- I drive a paid-for Toyota. It’s a choice that allows me other choices.
I truly get how hard it would be to say no the LAC. Go look up the marshmallow test- that’s what this comes down to.
@PurpleTitan wrote:
Depends on alternatives and resources. To me, UT-Austin tuition-free when the family doesn’t really have the resources for something a lot more (like the LAC) seems sweeter.
Ah, but UT-Austin undergrad isn’t free. The UT MBA may be tuition-free. But, by my estimation, the OP is going to still be on the hook for $20,000 in loans after he graduates UT-Austin undergrad. Yes, there is a big difference between that and $80k in debt. OP is wrestling with how to pay back that extra $60k which NESCAC college X seems to think the parents can afford.
“And, Parent-plus loans are not that unusual for even the most well-heeled families.”
Doesn’t make the decision to take them any smarter. Plenty of people may have overleveraged to buy a house they really couldn’t afford before the '08-'09 crisis. Didn’t mean that was actually a smart decision.
Agreed. But, you can’t repossess a diploma. All of which makes me question what the parents must be thinking. The OP seems to have an unusual amount of sway with them.
The OP wrote:
Please don’t hesitate to tear holes in these (as that’s what I’m here for).
Well, the biggest hole is this one:
option 1 thrives and offers many attractive grants, fellowships, and real-world study programs that are lacking from option 2.
People claw their way into fellowships and internships for one purpose, to hopefully land a job after making connections at the institute or company in question. All of that leverage goes out the window if you have to save money by staying at home in Texas for four years.
I’m not denying that NESCAC college X probably has a fantastic career development program, and could be of great help post-grad, but, TBH, the longer you are in the workforce, the less future employers will care where you graduated from.
@circuitrider, how are you estimating? The OP said “With additional parent help and personal savings, I could graduate with little to no debt.” With regards to UT-Austin.
To the OP: Have you looked at opportunities at UT-Austin? Study-abroad, for instance?
Not sure if the marshmallow test is valid any longer:
https://www.theatlantic.com/family/archive/2018/06/marshmallow-test/561779/
But in any case, as others have noted, OP you seem to really, really want to go to the unnamed LAC and really really don’t want to go to UT. Since I don’t know which LAC is involved, will only mention, again, that UT has a great reputation, and has been pointed out, has clout in unexpected areas(IB, see above).
But if you are absolutely convinced that the LAC in question is the school for you, then that’s that. My question-and I’ll admit I’m confused after reading all the posts-as how you will fund it, who signs what loans, and who will be the loan originator. When that much debt is involved, keep in mind you are making a decision not just for today, but for 10 years from now.
@circuitrider, how are you estimating? The OP said “With additional parent help and personal savings, I could graduate with little to no debt.” With regards to UT-Austin.
The OP is giving us a lot of information in piecemeal fashion, but over the space of several posts, he or she has said the cost of attending Texas undergrad is $20,000 exclusive of tuition (you are correct - he did say Texas tuition was $0.) Elsewhere, they have said the potential parental contribution is ~$8,000. That still leaves a gap of 12k a year the OP is going to have to finance on their own just to attend his home state flagship university.
So, a lot depends on how much the OP can earn in the summer and/or in work-study jobs to mitigate their total loan debt which could be as low as $16k or as high as $30k after four years at their flagship state u. Will Texas subsidize all those glam summer internships that are very prestigious but pay no money? Something else to consider.
You came here for advice. You are getting it. Will you take it? Doesn’t sound like it.
It is INSANE to rack up $100K debt.
In additional to all the good advice here…
It is not just you racking up monstrous debt - it is your parents. Do not put them in that position. Because if you don’t graduate, or you don’t have a job, or you die, guess what? They will have to pay that debt. Even if you pay, being co-signers on that kind of debt affects their ability to obtain credit, good interest rates, etc. Do not be selfish.
And if you have a job paying $42K a year, which translates to ~ $33K take home, which would be $2,750 a month. You are going to spend ~ 50% of your income on a loan?? What about rent, clothes (for work), food, health insurance, retirement, car, savings…
On a side note, I don’t know anything about UT-Austin, but I find it unusual that you got accepted to an, “ivy-level top-ranked” LAC, but not honors at UT-Austin.
@RookieCollegeMom, honors at a school like UT-Austin (like at other top publics such as UVa and UNC) isn’t so easy to get in to. Definitely not a slam-dunk.