Question

<p>This is a question for everyone. I am interested in what all of you have to say. Honestly, it doesn’t particularly deal with Harvard, but since I come to this particular blog often and value what all of you say, I would appreciate your input.</p>

<p>Scenario: Someone has been offered a full scholarship to a VERY good university and that same person was a finalist for another scholarship at another VERY good university.</p>

<p>They PREFER the 2nd university to the 1st.</p>

<p>My question is this: When they go to interview with the 2nd university, should they tell them they have been offered a full scholarship to the 1st one, but would prefer to go to the 2nd one?</p>

<p>Thanks for your replies. I wish everyone well on this forum as we all wait anxiously for answers from Harvard and from other colleges. Best wishes to all . . .</p>

<p>Oh, that’s tricky. If it is true, I probably would.It’s much easier to sound convincing when you are honest. If it isn’t true, I wouldn’t bring it up, but often at interviews, you will be asked where else you are applying. Then you can say that you got a full scholarship to ___ but prefer____ .</p>

<p>I promise it’s true . . . It’s my daughter – she definitely prefers school # 2 . I am just not sure if she tells school #2 that she has been offered a scholarship at school #1, will they offer the scholarship at school #2 to someone else – thinking that she already has an offer and doesn’t need it – make sense?</p>

<p>Or, would they be impressed that she has an offer and try to get her to come to school #2.</p>

<p>Dilemmas . . . thanks for your input . . .</p>

<p>This reminds me of the situation of appealing financial aid offers. For instance, if a student received a more liberal grant from University A but prefers University B, B will usually match the offer of A if the student expresses a definite interest to attend and if it deems that providing the additional funds may enhance the matriculation rate. </p>

<p>

</p>

<p>I do not necessarily believe that it is worth mentioning unless the interviewer explicitly inquires where her other applications were submitted. If the question does surface, a sincere response is fine, but it would not hurt to reassure that University 2 is preferred. As for the full scholarship, I would probably omit that detail, which is not an act of dishonesty – just something that does not need to be brought to University Two’s understanding. I believe that it is best to keep one university’s business separate from another. Also, if an admissions committee is consciously aware that a student may be difficult to eventually enroll for whatever reason, that will most likely be considered. For instance, Tufts University is notorious for rejecting very high-achieving students for the simple fact the Tufts admission officers realize that it is all too common for these students to use their school as a safety net.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Thanks. :)</p>

<p>mifune, Thanks! In this particular case, both schools are very reputable colleges; however, if anything in this case, # 1 was more of a safety net – # 2 was a reach that turned out to be a surprise when they notified daughter that she was a finalist for a full scholarship.</p>

<p>She wanted to mention it – hoping that #2 would be more likely to match the offer of #1, but I, like you, lean more towards her not mentioning it for a variety of reasons.</p>

<p>She just so DESPERATELY wants to go to # 2, but we cannot afford it without the scholarship. </p>

<p>Anyway, thanks for everyone who has commented. Any other comments/suggestions from anyone :slight_smile: Thanks!</p>

<p>One more thing . . . my daughter has also applied to Harvard – that is why I read this particular blog so much . . . but truthfully she probably has little to no chance of being accepted . . . </p>

<p>. . . but I suppose you never know :)</p>

<p>My instinct is to try and gain the acceptance before discussing money. Might the fact that your daughter have this scholarship from school #1 put school #2 off if they are not willing to match? I would get the acceptance and then talk to the FA department afterwards and get them to match. My two cents.</p>

<p>Yes, smoda61 provides excellent advice. I would first focus on the acceptance itself before considering the economics involved. If she does obtain an offer of admission from University Two, you will have a full month to send/fax in any financial aid/scholarship documentation from University One along with a letter of intent to negotiate for a more charitable grant.</p>

<p>Okay – this is the deal. She received a likely letter and is a finalist for a full scholarship at College # 2.</p>

<p>College #1 has already offered the full scholarship.</p>

<p>So basically she has already been accepted at both – just waiting for the scholarship weekend at College #2 .</p>

<p>Thanks . . .
“Bugs”</p>