<p>Even if that were true, does that make it okay to insult them like that? (Hint: No it doesn’t.)</p>
<p>
</p>
<p>Interesting question. I think it depends on how malicious the intent is. If the person’s ■■■■■■■■ just to get a few laughs out of everyone (including the ■■■■■-ee), that’s obviously not bullying. But if the ■■■■■■■■ genuinely hurts someone and is repeatedly hurtful, that’s not okay.</p>
<p>
</p>
<p>Note my distinction between insults based off personality/capability and insults based off things like sexual orientation.</p>
<p>
</p>
<p>No one gets to decide who’s “cut out” for life or not. Driving someone to suicide is never justified; you can’t say that a person “overreacted” and expect to be absolved of guilt. I personally would never commit suicide (although I can see myself considering it), but it’s ** never the victim’s fault **.</p>
<p>What is that distinction? They are both things that are a huge part of who a person is. </p>
<p>
Suicide is always the victims fault. By definition it is the act of causing one’s own death. Other people cannot be blamed for that person’s actions. If a boy kills his parents because they constantly belittled him is it the parents’ fault? No, the boy was the one that committed the crime and it was his decision.</p>
<p>Again, the difference lies in the social hierarchy that one creates, whereas the other is more a comment on that person’s actions. The word ■■■ is meant to suppress the gay community, much like the word ■■■■■■ is meant to suppress the black community. I don’t think any insults are cool, but there’s a huge difference in degree between recreational insults and the big-timers: those dealing with race, sexual orientation, etc.</p>
<p>
</p>
<p>Yes, the person carried out the action on himself, but something caused that person to commit suicide, whether it was bullying, neglect, depression, or whatever. You don’t make a choice like that for fun…</p>
<p>
</p>
<p>This is a completely different situation though. This involves someone taking out their anger on other people. In this case, the boy was taking away his parents’ freedoms to their lives. In the other, the boy was making decisions about his own existence. The parents are the victims here, not the boy. (Obviously the boy’s a victim in that he just lost his parents, but that’s beyond the point).</p>
<p>Any insult is meant to suppress people. that is the purpose of an insult. When people talk about this it always reminds me of Glee. I don’t know if you’ve seen it but last season there was a big deal about gay bullying and stuff and the show got all serious and talked about how bullying someone for their sexual orientation was completely wrong and the bully that pushed Kurt into a locker deserved to be kicked out of school and stuff. This was the same show that treated kids throwing Artie (the kid in a wheelchair) down the stairs as a joke. Bullying is bullying whether you make fun of them because of their sexual orientation or their hair color.</p>
<p>
It is still your choice. No one is making you kill yourself. The vast majority of people are made fun of sometimes. It isn’t their fault if someone decides the can’t handle it and wants out. Should they bully people? No but they are in no way responsible for others’ choices.</p>
<p>I don’t think we’re going to get anywhere since we have differing notions of responsibility and different “categories” of insults. We agree that bullying is wrong, which I think is the important message of this discussion (one of them, at least).</p>
<p>we are all responsible for the choices of the people we interact with, if by responsible you mean that parts of the reasons for people’s actions can be traced back to us. </p>
<p>If I have a friend and I go to see him he is partly responsible for that choice - if he wasn’t my friend i wouldn’t have seem him.</p>
<p>sure, suicide is a choice in that the parts of you that want you to do it overwhelm the parts of you that don’t. But the only thing that labeling it a “choice” does is change what suicide is * in your own mind *. It makes you liable to conflate it with other choices you are familiar with. But the choices you are familiar with are likely very different than the choice of suicide. Obviously choosing what kind of bread you want is not like choosing suicide </p>
<p>I always thought this quote did a good job of conveying what kind of choice it might be:</p>
<p>This is just a ludicrously narrow view of causation and responsibility. Decisions are never made in isolation, and treating them as though they are is just willful blindness.</p>
<p>
</p>
<p>The vast majority of people touch something sometimes.</p>
<p>Makes you wonder how it is that a car can kill someone.</p>
<p>I wrote that in response to an other post saying that “suicide is never the victim’s fault” While there are many things that contribute to the person’s decision, the final decision is, without question, in the hands of one person. There are many ways of dealing with things and if they choose suicide the blame falls squarely on that person’s shoulders. </p>
<p>If a man is laid off for some reason and he is left without a job and he can’t seem to find another one but he has a family to provide for and everything seems hopeless so he kills himself is that the fault of the company for firing him? </p>
<p>If that man’s wife later commits suicide because she can’t stand the grief and the idea of living her life without him is it the man’s fault? Is it the companies fault? Is it the fault of the consumers for not buying enough of the product forcing the company to cut the number of workers? </p>
<p>In the end there are an infinite number of variables that when combined made the person who is committing suicide think that it is the right thing to do but in the end the decision is a personal one.</p>
<p>Yes, in that case the company clearly bears some responsibility for the situation. Of course, whether they deserve blame is another question. There are a large number of valid reasons for laying someone off.</p>
<p>This thread suddenly got less serious since I last viewed it!</p>
<p>If the original Lion King was loosely based off of Hamlet, and the Lion King II was based off of Romeo and Juliet, was the Lion King 1/2 based off of Rosencrantz and Guildenstern are Dead?</p>
<p>^^ Why do Americans love the simpsons ?? I watched it several times and in every time I thought it is more stupid than the time before . I think - and everyone from where I live shares the same opinion - that it is the silliest show ever .</p>