REA Anxiety + RD Paralysis

Hello. I’m (17F) from India, and I applied early to Princeton during their REA cycle. For the past 4 years, I’ve worked really hard to build an objectively strong profile for myself. I’m enrolled with Crimson’s CAO (access opportunities) consulting program where my advisor thinks my profile is solid and I have a good chance of getting into Princeton.

Princeton has been my dream school since seventh grade when I attended a college fair as a delegate to ISEF and returned two times since in high school to their ISEF booth as a finalist. I also attended two other good summer programs (which I think might doxx me if I mention them here) and I intend to major in math. It’s been two weeks since I hit submit and I keep trying to chance myself and overthinking about the outcome of my decision. Every day that leads up to December 11 makes me nervous and panicked. I worry about external factors out of my control that might lead to me getting deferred or even rejected (since I’m an international who needs a significant amount of aid). When I tried to send my SAT score to Princeton on the 1st of November, my international card payment was reversed by Collegeboard and I was not notified via email. Later, when I was emailed about a missing item on my Princeton portal, I nearly had a panic attack and it was frightening. I’m trying to distract myself with my RD essays but I keep thinking about my REA decision. I’m not sure what to do at the moment and any advice would be appreciated.

So I don’t know if this will help, but Princeton is in fact just a school. A good one, but not the only good one. And so if you can’t go to Princeton for undergrad, you can instead go to another good school. And of course if you want to do graduate work in Math, that is another opportunity to look at a variety of schools.

As to undergrad options, we could discuss US options for your RD applications if you like–if so, it would be best to do a full Chance Me/Match Me thread in the suggested format.

6 Likes

Does your portal show the test score was ultimately received in time for REA?

The application and decision making process is out of your control. I know it can be difficult to not think about it, but whatever coping mechanisms you can use to process things that are out of your control will help you right now, and for the rest of your life.

Meanwhile, focus on what you do control…the rest of your college apps, for one. Make sure to apply to at least one college that’s highly likely for admission and affordable. Have you put in an app for at least one school like that yet? If not, focus on that. I would encourage you to get the RD apps completed, don’t wait until holiday break.

Good luck.

3 Likes

Have you resent the scores? Princeton will typically allow a short grace period for scores to be received after the deadline.

I’m not sure what you mean by “good chance”. The international acceptance rate for Princeton is somewhere in the 1.5-3% range. Please plan accordingly with the rest of your school list.

5 Likes

Deferred isn’t rejected and as you note, it’s out of your control.

Princeton is not the only need blind college, meets need college - there’s 10 or 11 - and then many more that meet need but are need aware.

Depending upon your budget, there are others you should have applied to as well.

I hope you get in but last year they accepted 2.3% - and surely some are athletes - so you need a well balanced plan so you can adapt if needed.

Princeton is great but it has issues like other schools. So make sure you apply to a well rounded list, which will in part depend on your budget. If you can afford $30K a year for example, which still means you need significant financial aid, your list might look different than if you can afford $5K.

You’ve worked hard and I’m sure your work ethic will be recognized in life, whether at Princeton or elsewhere.

For now, breathe, exercise/walk and listen to music or do something that takes your mind off things, eat well and sleep. You’ll know soon enough - and then can either celebrate or move to the next part of the plan.

Best of luck to you.

2 Likes

Does your portal show the test score was ultimately received in time for REA?

no :frowning: :frowning: :frowning: so immediately after this happened, right, I called Collegeboard and had them bill me over the phone and it was only then that I was notified that my scores had been sent. Right after that I called Princeton admissions and I told them about the incident, and also emailed the admissions office with the downloaded report of my score from Nov 25 (1520 760/760) and they confirmed the receipt of my score stating “the document has been received and will be added to the student’s file.” I have been checking my portal every morning right after I wake up for 4 days now and it hasn’t arrived yet but I’m hoping it will because this is just insane

I agree with the rest of your advice TBH i was thinking of UMD and I might submit soon because the essays are small and my recs are in already. Thanks!

  1. Can you afford UMD? It’s well over $60K - and I wouldn’t assume aid

  2. UMD admits most early action - at least for domestic

What is your budget?

Did you apply to the other meets need, need blind for international schools like Harvard, Dartmouth, Brown, Yale, MIT, Wash & Lee, Amherst, Bowdoin and there’s some more.

Or others that meet need like F&M, Claremont McKenna, Colgate and more that are need aware but meet full need.

1 Like

Yeah, I resent the score and I’m hoping it will make it in time for REA. Also, the reason why I said “good chance” is because my ECs and awards are objectively good. I really didn’t want to bring this up because it’s not very helpful right now, but I’ve spent several hours researching and comparing my activities to lists from college websites For context, both programs I went to are on the MIT recommended list:mitadmissions.org/apply/prepare/summer/ and my recs to Princeton are from the directors of these programs. Like I mentioned earlier, I’ve also been to ISEF twice (twice as a finalist, once as a student delegate in '22). I’m confident in the choices on my school list, but the problem lies in my confidence in acceptance, which is what I’m struggling with. Thanks!

I sure hope your recs followed their instructions - directors of these programs would be unlikely to be considered unless they meet this description below. That could cause instant rejection.

Also, many applying to Princeton have objectively good ECs, etc. but you don’t know what they are looking for - they don’t want 100 clones - they may want people who are musical or theatric or have an interest/experience in poetry and yes, top competitions - but many things, not one thing. They also likely want people from a variety of countries - not just India and China.

I personally wouldn’t be so confident but I wish you luck. I also wouldn’t use an MIT website as a barometer for what Princeton wants. But it’s great if you apply to MIT - and if you have large need - perhaps you should.

“Two (2) Teacher Recommendations. Please ask two of your teachers who have taught you in higher level courses (e.g., AP, IB Higher/Standard Level, A-Levels, etc.) in different academic areas of study to complete and send the teacher recommendation forms, available on the Common Application website. The subjects should be in core academic areas, such as English, language, humanities, social sciences, natural sciences or math.”

1 Like

Okay, you’ve lowkey got a point; I don’t think UMD is a good choice. I haven’t applied to literally any other school because Princeton is SCEA. I will be submitting my Bowdoin app soon, though. Wash&Lee or maybe Skidmore is also a good option I think. I definitely cannot afford UMD because my parents are separated, my mother does not pay child support and my father is unaware of my complete list. I might have to talk things through with him first. My budget is very low as I discovered from submitting my PFAA but since Princeton is need-blind it might not matter too much.

Define very low.

Please make sure to follow instructions for each school. I hope you submitted teacher LORs to Princeton. That is what they ask for.

If you want to attend school in the US, I’d suggest you expand your list.

1 Like

It sounds like you are a strong candidate, but we don’t know much about you in terms of your GPA, rigor, and test scores. With that said, the competition is fierce for admission to Princeton, just to take one example, there are 1,800 ISEF finalists per year (I am not saying that’s not a great achievement, because it is!)

Stay hopeful that you’ll be admitted, but you have to prepare psychologically and practically that you won’t be admitted..so work hard on your other applications. Again, do not wait until you hear from Princeton to complete your other apps. If you want college list ideas, please share all your stats.

Stay on top of the Princeton portal, specifically look to see if it says whether you are in REA or RD…it should say that somewhere on the top of the home page. That is the pivotal info you want, not whether they have received/downloaded your test score from CB.

Please expand your list to include at least one highly likely school for admission that is also affordable. That’s not Bowdoin, Skidmore, or W&L. Do you have a school like that in India? Elsewhere?

Your chances are relatively low as an international, statistically. Your financial need will have no effect at Princeton.

It is honestly dangerous to have a “dream school.” Exposure to Princeton in 7th grade is a typical scenario for this. I wish you had had similar exposure to a wide spectrum of other schools that would be financially possible.

It is easy enough to google schools that are need blind and meet full need. There have been some additions in recent years, including Bowdoin.

Good luck regardless of the Princeton outcome!

2 Likes

oops sorry yeah my teacher LORs are from my math and english teacher, and I’m confident they wrote good recs. I’m also confident I won’t get into MIT because I do not have comp math/Olympiads among my stats. I will apply but I’m not really going to spend time ruminating over my odds of admission because I’m aware they’re very low.

I personally wouldn’t be so confident

I’m sorry if that came off the wrong way. I was very unsure of my application earlier this year and it took a lot of persuasion from people around me to develop confidence about it, and even then I’m still nitpicking at stuff that I think is misrepresented. I tried to tap into the liberal arts angle by talking about my love for language and writing and things but I’m afraid it’s going to be banal. But it is what it is I guess.

I wish the same thing. There were a lot of other great colleges at that fair and honestly I blame the Princeton booth for giving out stickers and posters without having to listen to an AO read out from the brochure LOL. My posting this might have been a little premature because I haven’t put too much thought into the rest of my list and I will have to focus on that first, I guess.

3 Likes

SCEA does not prevent you from applying Early Action to public schools. Unfortunately, it’s too late for EA now, but try to find an affordable option for RD. I hope you also have a fallback option in your home country!

1 Like

There’s always grad school!

1 Like

The entire UC system was ruled out for me because they didn’t offer aid and I didn’t have enough time to apply to other schools because I had midterms in October as well. The way college acceptances work in this country is unfortunately through an objective score on an entrance exam like many other Asian/Southeast Asian countries so the fallback choice for me will have to be a school that I can get a satisfactory score for, and that is a bridge I have decided to cross when I encounter it in March 2027 :slight_smile:

I hope the scores will be received in time for REA to allay your concerns, but realistically I’m not sure it matters much. The reality of an REA application to schools like Princeton is that if you are an unhooked, “average excellent” candidate, your chances of an admission are extremely low. Not impossible, but highly unlikely. Why? Because unless you have some sort of unique component that Princeton decides it really needs, you will be deferred or rejected. I’m not saying this to be mean or hurtful in any way, but rather to help set your expectations. I wish you luck with your college journey.

2 Likes

And no public school will provide you aid. But some schools (both public and private), might offer you sufficient merit aid. What’s your budget?