REA Anxiety + RD Paralysis

I just read that international student enrollment in US colleges is down 15% (changes to visa policies, other factors). This is having a financial effect on many schools. And I wonder if you have explored the effect of AI on mathematics as a major and field. Some schools (like Brown, in an article I just read) now have a provost for AI.

Often scores and grades are seen as “benchmarks” for very selective schools, meaning you need to meet the benchmark and after that, admission is about other things. Top schools are assembling an interesting class so it is not always about the individual applicant so much as how you can contribute to a mix of talents, interests and backgrounds. So don’t take rejection too personally- and not saying that will be the outcome for you!

I just read that international student enrollment in US colleges is down 15% (changes to visa policies, other factors).

Yes, I’ve heard of this, and I’m slightly worried about my own visa but I should be okay since I’ve had a B1/B2 and visited the States five times, which probably helps my case in applying for an F1 visa. Seems like there’s lots of things to worry about right now, haha, so that’s a fish that I’ll fry when I catch it and I’ll focus on the bigger ones for now.

And I wonder if you have explored the effect of AI on mathematics as a major and field.

In the case of math and AI, I’ve been reading about it and watching a lot of interviews in which mathematicians like Terence Tao, Grant Sanders, and Richard Borcherds talk about future prospects for current students looking to enter math, and after weighing many polarizing views and reconsidering my own reasons to pursue math, I’ve decided to still go ahead and do math.

Personally, I have not used much AI directly in my own research except maybe for formatting, literature review and clearing conceptual gaps, and I had to submit a Generative AI Use statement for the math research I did this summer. That being said, it is foolish to denounce the mathematical abilities of the newest LLMs, and everybody I know in the math community is having a difficult time with coming to terms with what it will be like for us going forward.

As a backup, I’m thinking of quant finance, but at the moment, like many other students my age and slightly older than me, I’m unsure, because like many people have remarked, the romantic/heroic age of math is over. It was a little upsetting at first, but for the sake of optimism, it is also a little exciting to think of the fact that the future of how humans approach mathematics alongside AI is malleable in my hands, as well as the hands of all students who are looking to enter the field despite discouragement. Only time will tell, and for this reason I’ve decided to approach my career like the mathematician Hong Wang (whom I deeply admire): do math for five years and see if it works out, and decide what to do with my career otherwise.

Often scores and grades are seen as “benchmarks” for very selective schools, meaning you need to meet the benchmark and after that, admission is about other things.

My dad has been saying lately that my SAT is like admissions ticking off a checkbox, which probably means it’s not always a dealbreaker except in extreme cases. Albeit over the last week especially with the SAT score-sending mishap I have heard “[my name], it’s alright, the SAT is like ticking a checkbox” multiple times a day, so I do not know whether these affirmations are meant to allay my own anxiety or his. Boy, I sure hope that checkbox is ticked!!

For my personal statement, I wrote about a deeply personal philosophy I was raised with, a chess-related metaphor that illustrates my upbringing as well as my close relationship with my dad, about how the process is equally as important as the outcome (to describe it broadly). I tried not to talk about academics at all in my essays because I wanted to demonstrate the kind of person I am in social settings, relationships and at home with family, and my thought processes and mannerisms. I used light humour (which I’ve heard from people who read my supplements was fairly effective and far less awful than my dad’s puns) which hopefully added a factor of levity to my file.

Surprisingly, the college applications process has inevitably led to a lot of reflection that I’ve done about my life so far, everything I’ve done and why I did it, and what I can do going forward. I have been reflecting on and journaling about things that I wouldn’t even use in my essays just for the sake of looking at things from my past, kind of like window-shopping down memory lane, which is always pleasant. This way, I’ve also learned to find joy in seemingly very mundane things in my day-to-day life now, because who knows if I’ll ever get to experience them again after I leave? This introspection has also helped me understand the kind of adult I hope to become very soon, and how I’m going to navigate the new responsibilities and duties I will be given (and how I’m going to relish my brand-new freedom!!). Most importantly, I know now that I’m a lucky, lucky girl to have my wonderful family having my back, as well as my amazing mentors and teachers along the way who were generous and thoughtful enough to take a high schooler seriously and support her selflessly. I’m very, very grateful for that, irrespective of wherever I end up.

So don’t take rejection too personally

I’m still a bit antsy, though. When I wake up, do I immediately check my email and portal for updates first thing in the morning? Yes. (Do I need to chill out? Probably!) Do I regret anything I’ve done or said as part of applying to these colleges? Absolutely not, because I know I’ve done my best. For me, I think that is enough :heart:

2 Likes

I don’t think getting an F1 visa will be a major issue, provided you can adequately document your finances (from your family, along with any financial aid or scholarships from the university).

The “visa policy” concerns are primarily around employment visas after graduation, or the OPT option that allows international students to pursue internships or accept post-graduation employment for 1-3 years. Those rules have changed, and it’s become much harder to find an employer willing to sponsor you for a work visa (and permanent residency). So you should go in with the expectation that you will likely need to return home after finishing college.

1 Like

There have been some pretty surprising visa denials for students of late, but totally agree that most are still getting them and that worry on this front is premature.

1 Like

Personally I can’t imagine math ever being a bad major. The thought processes, thinking skills that develop are transferable to so many areas.

2 Likes