Recommended by a Famous Professor

<p>I am currently the only freshman in an upper-level class with a world renowned professor - and I’m getting an A! The professor is highly respected in his field, chairman of the department, and widely published. I think I have developed a good relationship with him. Granted he is very busy and engaged in so much research and work at the graduate level and beyond, I am the only person in our class of 20 undergraduates who he calls on by name. I guess he now knows me since I have visited during office hours, asked and answered questions thoughtfully in class, and attended guest lectures. He’s not at all aloof (actually he is rather personable), but I just don’t have the sense that he typically learns the names of his undergraduate students (I can understand, as there is little opportunity for him to learn our names unless we attend office hours. He grades papers, but his TA is mostly responsible for putting names to faces and handing the graded work back).</p>

<p>So my question is… does any of this fame add value to a recommendation from him? Is it impressive for a freshman to have caught the attention of a big-time professor within her major? Do the adcoms even recognize field-specific names? Would my application be passed to a specialist in my major who would surely recognize this professor?</p>

<p>Any answers or speculation would be greatly appreciated :slight_smile: </p>

<p>PS: I’m at a top 15 school, applying for transfer to other top 15 schools</p>

<p>I’m sure it can’t hurt. But why would you want to transfer if you’re pretty tight with a top professor in your major?</p>

<p>My current school holds a very impressive rank for the History of Art major (my major), but the departmental focus is on the Western tradition. There are no Asian, African, or Pre-historic offerings and there is no intention to hire professors to include these artistic traditions in the department. Honestly, this is my weakest reason for wishing to transfer, but I still do hope to obtain a broad education within my major and I do not see how this Euro-centric approach will satisfy me. Regardless, I have been impressed by the small class-sizes, the instruction of my professors and TA’s, and the resources available on campus (super-helpful librarians, academic advisors, and learning disability support services). I’m actually pretty content Monday-Friday. </p>

<p>But there is supposed to be so much more to the college experience than scholarship. My main complaints and reasons for transfer are not academic. My school is a well-known factory of pre-med students, and so many people here are wrapped up in doing well to go to medical school. I don’t find that there is a great diversity of interests - and students who are majoring in the humanities (we’re a minority) are scoffed at, as we are supposedly on a track to poverty (I know this is not at all the case, but the pre-meds are convinced of their superiority). As a result of this imbalanced culture of academic interest, the focus on campus is not at all intellectual, but rather, pre-professional. With everyone so driven to make it to the next step (med school), it is hard to find people who are willing to relax and enjoy a weekend (whether it be attending a sporting event, a party, a concert, a museum… anything). I grew up in NYC and I get so antsy on the weekends here because I am bored and can’t convince many of my peers to explore beyond campus. Ok, I’ve rambled on for a lot - I suppose you could click back to my old posts to see more reasons to transfer. </p>

<p>So are there any more opinions on the nature of this recommender? Any suggestions for explaining to him why I seek to transfer without being insulting of his program?</p>

<p>Just know that the likehood of acceptance at a top 15 school is far less for a transfer student than for Freshman. And it is nil if you were already rejected.
But given that, if your world famous professor is willing to contact a collegue[s] at the college[s] you are applying to, and recommend you, it sure won’t hurt!</p>

<p>I would have to disagree with Menloparkmom on the top 15 statement. The numbers in the thread are from 2006 so the exact percentage is somewhat different, but there are a few top 15:</p>

<p>Princeton - 0% - The only top 15 school that outright disallows transfer applications.</p>

<p>Harvard - 8.1%</p>

<p>Yale - 3.9%</p>

<p>CIT - 9.2%</p>

<p>Stanford - 5.1%</p>

<p>MIT - 6.3%</p>

<p>UPenn - 12.4% (Other sources put it at ~9.75)</p>

<p>Duke - 7.9%</p>

<p>Dartmouth - 12.6%</p>

<p>Columbia College - 6.3% - Columbia Fu - 24.1%</p>

<p>Chicago - 25.9%</p>

<p>Cornell - 27.0% - Number inflated by some schools. I believe CAS is between 13 and 14 percent.</p>

<p>WashU - 24.6%</p>

<p>Northwestern - 22.7%</p>

<p>Brown - 3.0%</p>

<p>So Northwestern, WashU, Chicago, and Dartmouth all take more than 20% of transfer applicants, representing more than a quarter of top 15 schools. Moreover, if one consideres cornell, then 1/3 of the top 15 schools accept over 20% of transfer applicants. Those don’t strike me as bad numbers for elite schools.</p>

<p>Although I think menloparkmom is wise to point out the harsh realities of transfer acceptance rates (ofttimes lower than freshman rates), and although I agree that the many students who toss transfer apps at schools where they weren’t accepted first time around in a mad hunt for climbing the rankings are probably unwise… I don’t think it leads to the conclusion that a given student has “nil” chance for transfer to a school where previously rejected.</p>

<p>How’s that for a run on sentence :D?</p>

<p>So, if you have performed very well in college, have new insights into why a school which rejected you before is a fit for you and you for it… it is certainly possible that a highly selective school which rejected you before will accept you as a transfer. Even if they are single digit acceptance rate transfer schools. It has happened and there are such stories here on cc (don’t ask me for specifics, I haven’t kept a catalog :wink: ).</p>

<p>Don’t count on it, certainly.</p>

<p>As to your question: IMO (and it is only an opinion; no insider information on this one) it matters more what the prof says about you than what his credentials are. A lukewarm rec from a world-renowned individual will be no help imo. It sounds like your rec would not be lukewarm and it cannot hurt that he is world renowned.</p>

<p>Will the ad com recognize his name? Probably not if he is not a household name. Will your app be reviewed by a faculty member in your major? This is not typical, but I have had experience where the transfer app staff coordinate with department-specific staff on certain matters. How often and what triggers it, I can’t say.</p>

<p>As someone above says, if this person pro-actively advocates for you (calls a colleague at your target school) and that colleague goes to bat for you with admissions… certainly can’t hurt. Could well help quite a bit.</p>

<p>Is it impressive for a freshman to have caught the attention of a big time professor? Well, close relationships between profs and students are what LACs are all about. Many of them feature freshman seminars, with very good student: prof ratios for just this reason. It all depends on how well he feels he knows you/your work and what he says about you in a recommendation.</p>

<p>Not much else we can say; no one knows any individual person’s odds of admission or how much any particular factor might enhance/diminish those odds.</p>

<p>Gprime,
Last year [2007 ] Stanford accepted only 20 of 1400 transfer applicants= less than 2%. Harvard’s acceptance rate was also much lower in 2007 than the year before, and this theme was repeated at college after college. Do some research on last years CC threads or by checking with the Common Data sets to get the figures for 2007 transfer acceptance rates. At every college I looked at the acceptance rate % for transfer students was far less than for Freshman. The probable reason was the unexpected [?] higher yield of students who said “yes” to offers of acceptance at many of the top colleges around the country. Whether this was due to the baby boomlet, the intense level of competition, a poor mathematical guess by admission number crunchers of what their yield would be, or all of the above, who knows? Regardless, it may be a pattern that could repeat itself as the population of students applying to college peaks in the next 2 years. Additionally, when colleges overenroll 1 year, that usually reduces the # of applicants- freshman or transfer- that they usually can accept the next year. So the 2006 figures are a little too optomistic to use as examples of what it may be like for this years’ transfer applicants.</p>

<p>This is somewhat off-topic, but
“My current school holds a very impressive rank for the History of Art major (my major), but the departmental focus is on the Western tradition. There are no Asian, African, or Pre-historic offerings and there is no intention to hire professors to include these artistic traditions in the department.”
Although knowing the different characteristics of non-Western Art is important, would you not be better served by first learning Western Art, which tends to be more “deductively based” and has less of a focus on “continuity” compared to Asian art? As mode for analysis it seems like the Western standard would provide a stronger basis for further work. Does this make sense, or are you planning on ending your scholarly pursuits after four years (which might make diversity a larger issue)? (Or am I factually incorrect on assuming Western art to be more “deductively vs intuition” based)?
It also seems like you would enjoy a LAC more than so than just a regular top 15 school. What might be keeping you from applying to those schools as well?</p>

<p>if I may ask, what school are you planning to transfer from MissFiskGuide ?</p>

<p>Wow! Thank you all for your responses! </p>

<p>Milton, I’m not 100% sure, but in a perfect world I would love to enter a two year MA/PhD program in the UK (specifically Oxford, Cambridge, or St. Andrews) and then go to law school back in the US. Of course, this would require my parents’ willingness to fund my endless schooling or a stellar undergraduate performance on my part to obtain a Marshall Scholarship, or something of that ilk. I agree that an education in the Western tradition is likely most useful, but I feel that I should have a well-rounded background in all traditions. Also, the graduate programs in the UK do not include non-Western art either. Finally, I have been considering Amherst. I’m not interested in any of the other LAC’s mostly because of their location.</p>

<p>Fullmoonwisdom, I do not like to disclose this in a public forum because I have revealed a lot of specific information. You can message me if you want.</p>

<p>I understand. It also doesn’t hurt to know some other fields you may want to explore down the road.
What about LAC college locations do you not like (out of curiosity)?</p>

<p>For graduate programmes in non-Western art I suggest you have a look at the School of Oriental and African Studies (SOAS) which is part of the University of London. They have a Department of Art and Archaeology which has undergraduate and graduate courses. Obviously their whole focus is on non-Western art.</p>

<p>Milton, LAC’s are generally very small and rural. I’m seeking more activity and student involvement, and I just don’t see how moving to a small environment would facilitate this. Amherst is appealing because of it’s membership to the Five Colleges Consortium - I’m under the impression that there is a lot going on up there. Barnard is the only other LAC that would be suitable to me, but my parents and I agree that it would not be in my best interest to go back to Manhattan for college (my hometown). I was accepted to Columbia and Barnard last year, and I decided that I need new experiences in new places! </p>

<p>Oldspc, I am very aware of SOAS, as I have family who have attended. It is a little premature for me to begin to seriously think about graduate programs, but thank you! I suppose the only reason why I mentioned my intention to continue schooling was to illustrate my inclination to seek a well-rounded education in the History of Art discipline. I have family in the UK and I know a fair bit about the universities I listed above. I almost attended one of them for undergraduate, and I sometimes wonder if I made a mistake passing up on that opportunity (I visited and fell in love, but medical issues arose and my parents baulked at the idea of being so far away). I guess I can come back to you in a few years for further advice on studying in the UK!</p>

<p>

If you’re at the school I think you are, there’s some pretty good Egyptian and Near Eastern courses available.</p>

<p>I wouldn’t agree, but we may not be thinking of the same place : ) </p>

<p>In any case, as I said above, the academic program is not the main focus of my desire to transfer.</p>

<p>I know this is a really late reply, but I don’t think that Princeton doesn’t NOT allow transfer students. I personally know someone who transfered there for their sophomore year. :-/</p>

<p>From Princeton’s website:</p>

<p>If you have already started a college or university degree program elsewhere, you are not eligible to apply for admission to Princeton. We accept students who will begin their freshman year in the fall. Princeton does not offer spring semester entry or a transfer admission option.</p>

<p>… The person you know of may be a super-special circumstance, or maybe they’ve since changed the policy.</p>

<p>I wasn’t planning to apply there anyhow, so it’s irrelevant. Thanks though!</p>

<p>I know Dartmouth last year was about 5%. Transferring is much easier to the schools right outside the top 10 - places like Rice, Northwestern, WashU, JHU, and Georgetown.</p>

<p>how did that person transfer? sports?</p>