Reed College Vs. Harvey Mudd College

What are some pros and cons of each? Is one better than the other in terms of the math department? Which would be better as a math Ph.D. feeder college? My interests lie in pure math. I have taken one AP class (Japanese) and am taking AP Calculus BC (which is looking like I will finish early). I am in 10th grade and will take the ACT in the spring. I’m studying really hard-- particularly on the writing section --and am aiming for a score above 33. I am going to take college math courses (hopefully including things like differential equations and linear algebra) next year. While enrolled at my community college, I hope to be of service in the mathematics research department. Would I have any chance of getting into either of these colleges?

Both produce a lot of students who go on for math PhDs:
bhttp://www.thecollegesolution.com/the-colleges-where-phds-get-their-start/

Mudd is harder to get into, and is going to be more academically challenging. Not saying Reed isn’t also challenging, but Mudd is notoriously so. Mudd’s ACT range is 32-35, and Reed’s is 29-33. But Mudd is also surprisingly cooperative. Reed has a heavier party atmosphere. Reed has a bit more of a PNW vibe (a little crunchier, a little more flannel). Mudd is located in Southern California, and has the benefit of the other Claremont Consortium schools to give more class options (especially non-STEM courses), and a bigger social pool, etc.

Why would you take the ACT this year? Colleges don’t give credit for taking it earlier. And Mudd may make you report all scores. I’d take the extra time over the summer to study and make your first attempt in the fall. Also be aware of Mudd’s subject test requirements.

Take the time to read Mudd’s mission statement. Certainly you’d want some STEM ECs, but they also like students with other interests and strong non-STEM grades & scores. Note that you may need a recommendation from a non-STEM teacher for Mudd, too, so be sure to think about that during your junior year.

If you can visit both schools, you should. And you can certainly apply to both — you are going to meet a list of matches and safeties to go along with any reaches.

You can find out more about both schools by Googling their Common Data Set. Also, work with your parents to run the net price calculators on each school website to see if it is affordable before becoming too enamored.