<p>Vanilea–If your mom is so concerned about SATs, I’m assuming her primary objective is success in your college admissions. Try to make her realize that while SATs are very important, success at ISEF means much, much more, being significantly rarer and a sign of passion as well as talent. Direct her here, perhaps, for an occasionally-correct view on the admissions process :)</p>
<p>How do you get an idea for an ISEF project? I think I have a good idea, but it doesn’t involve advanced chemistry stuff or anything, and isn’t like “Inhibition of HIV Production in Genetically Generated HIV Model Through HIV TAT TAR RNA Binding Domain” or something complex like that. It’s kind of simple, but its results would be really helpful to language-learners everywhere. What do you guys think?</p>
<p>i say be yourself</p>
<p>your interests are your best guide</p>
<p>a good example is former SSPer Aaron Goldin who lived by the ocean in California and simply used the idea that the waves in the ocean carry energy and this energy can be focused by using a gyroscope which resists change in motion. the resistance can be converted into alternative energy and he won 1st in Siemens Westinghouse. </p>
<p>we’ve all played with gyroscopes… and when i read about his work, i smacked myself in the head for not actually implementing this idea when i further studied gyroscopic motion in AP Physics C! of course i dont live by the ocean and goldin did much more precise and documented trials with a prototype but it was really simple an idea!</p>
<p>:-P</p>
<p>But how do people think of stuff like “Inhibition of HIV Production in Genetically Generated HIV Model Through HIV TAT TAR RNA Binding Domain”? Do the professors they work with give them that idea? It really sounds like the stuff professional NIH researchers work on, not teenagers.</p>
<p>its not teenagers</p>
<p>its either:</p>
<p>1) professors
2) parents in the profession
3) grad students in labs</p>
<p>“But how do people think of stuff like “Inhibition of HIV Production in Genetically Generated HIV Model Through HIV TAT TAR RNA Binding Domain”? Do the professors they work with give them that idea? It really sounds like the stuff professional NIH researchers work on, not teenagers.”</p>
<p>I use to think like that, but then I realized coming up with fancy names is not difficult. You have to realize that most research isn’t big. Its adding a very very small piece of knowledge to the field. Even the siemens winners, they aren’t publishing world breakthroughs. </p>
<p>The complexity of the name does not impress real scientists. At the fairs I’ve gone to, “A Study on the Design and Implementation of an Artificially Intelligent Control System” has won over projects that have names twice as complicated as the one you labeled. Indeed for our iGEM proposal we changed “Biological Circuits” to “Modular Redesign of Signal Transduction Pathways via Biological Circuits by means of Trinary Logic Gates.” If you want a fancy name, read lots of journals. But a fancy name doesn’t impress people in the know, good science does.</p>
<p>For proof, take a look at these papers:</p>
<p>“On the electrodynamics of moving bodies”</p>
<p>“Does the inertia of a body depend on its energy content?”</p>
<p>“On a heuristic viewpoint concerning the production and transformation of light.”</p>
<p>Look familiar? Yeah, these are Einstein’s key papers published in 1905. The first is the theory of special relativity. The second describes the relationship between rest mass and energy(E=mc^2). The third is the photoelectric effect.</p>
<p>Thanks for responding, guys.</p>
<p>So, basically, if I were to get a professor/grad student as a mentor and learn some good science/research skills, I’d be set for Siemens or ISEF? Stuff like “Inhibition of HIV Production in Genetically Generated HIV Model Through HIV TAT TAR RNA Binding Domain” doesn’t sound like stuff you even learn in AP Biology.</p>
<p>No it doesn’t. What you want is really good projects. Often times profs/grad students will give you much easier/simple projects. And of course its not stuff you learn in AP Bio. lol, that’s the point of research. You’re going to the boundary of what we know and pushing further.</p>
<p>more often than not, professors will give you an excellent intro and its up to you to ask them for more</p>
<p>My question is, is the best way to reach that boundary to get a prof as a mentor (which I’m hoping to do)? My goal is to do biochemistry/biomedical research within the next year, but there are not many good books at the library.</p>
<p>@vanilea - omgosh! My mom is the same way. She wants me to focus on SAT/ACT scores instead of research. At first, she thought RSI was some sort of joke but then I explained to her that its competitive, you work with the smartest kids in america/the world, etc.<br>
Congrats on ISEF btw, I didn’t qualify (3rd place and they only take top 2 - so close)</p>
<p>yes the traditional method is knocking on doors. emailing works. sometimes if you are specific enough, a prof can recommend or direct you to another prof in their dept or at some other university</p>
<p>highskoolstudent, wow, our parents are so alike in a not so good way. My mom doesn’t believe me that RSI is basically my door into MIT and other great colleges. When we were talking about what colleges I should apply for, and I said I wanted to do Stanford, she was like, No, there will be too many California Asians with perfect test scores applying, and I wouldn’t get in. Thanks mom for believeing in me… : (
She also thinks that if one ivy rejects me, all will, and that is not the truth because they look for so many different things and the admissions process is 50/50 skill/ luck.</p>
<p>I second Poigant’s post. Sophomore year, I emailed more than 70 professors and only recieved one reply, but the one chance to work in a lab got me to ISEF.
BTW, its not the complexity of the project that makes it a winning one, but how well you do it. Freshman year, I bet a student with stem cell research with my project on oral pH…a really simple experiment done in my home…probably because he didn’t know what he was talking about, and I did. Make sure you know your project, because if you don’t, no matter how good, the judges will automatically think you were just someone’s lab rat.</p>
<p>vanilea,</p>
<p>dont be hatin’ asians. actually, go ahead. we use your hate as fuel. we digest it and thrive on it! MUNCH–YUM! WE USE YOUR HATE AS FUEL.</p>
<p>70 profs? wow.</p>
<p>Poigant, actually, I am Asian…so I can’t hate them because then I would be hating myself, and I totally think I am the coolest person in the world!!! (hahaha, just kidding…my ego’s not that big)
It’s just sometimes frustrating for people to automatically expect you to be smart because you’re asian. I am sort of the typical asian in a sense though, good at math and science, but my spanish, and I’m in IB spanish by the way, sucks a**…</p>
<p>you can’t be asian, vanilea, because you can’t seem to spell poignant after two attempts</p>
<p>Spelling is a problem with all these RSI types lol…CEE couldn’t even spell “Research” right on the application this year.</p>
<p>Well you don’t want to go gangbanging and email every prof in a dept. Target those who are doing work similar to what you want to do. Usually profs like to see that you have you own ideas, etc. Also connections help! :P</p>
<p>i’ll sorry, i really do suck at spelling. Spell check has raped me of my speling scills</p>