Romance in supplemental essay?

<p>Hi guys,</p>

<p>I know you can put in something weird in your supplemental essay, but could you guys tell me whether this is too much?</p>

<p>In that essay, I want to show one fairy tale I wrote for a girl when I was in love with her. She was a rabbit and I was a donkey and we were searching for the evil eagle who stole her glasses off. Weird, I know, but is it…too weird?</p>

<p>On the other hand, is it interesting?</p>

<p>I don’t see how it would help your application in even the slightest bit.</p>

<p>When admissions officer Jennifer is reading your application, she is going to have a pile of hundreds of others waiting on her desk for her to read before she can go home and eat dinner. If you submit something purely for the sake of it being an “interesting read” but not otherwise related to your candidacy for Harvard University, effectively doubling the time it takes her to read your application, it will infuriate her.</p>

<p>I also object to the idea that a Nick Jr.-esque love story between high school students counts as “interesting” unless you have such writing talent that you could conceivably write these stories for a career. Even then I wouldn’t buy them.</p>

<p>Sorry, no. It sounds like you’d be putting that there just for the sake of putting something there. I think you’d be better off without it.</p>

<p>Hmmm. Alright. Thanks.</p>

<p>I’d offer a slightly different view: if it’s a great piece of writing that an admissions officer would find really impressive, and if writing fiction is an important interest for you, then it could be a distinctive addition to your application. But it’s high-risk (that donkey-rabbit bit could seem silly). I wouldn’t submit it without positioning it in terms of what it says about you, and not unless someone who really knows good writing has confirmed the quality of your work. </p>

<p>Remember that most applicants are going to be rejected in any event. If you’re too cautious in applying, you can easily get lost in the pack of talented applicants. So you want something to make you stand out – but not as an example of bad judgment.</p>

<p>It seems like you’re grasping at straws to be “different.” Different is not always a positive thing.</p>

<p>only use this if it can display your abilities in someway. I think a good supplemental essay would not be focusing on boasting any achievements but subtly presenting what you have to offer as a student.</p>

<p>Most of my application is about my passion for a few things in life. I want to show ‘the other side’ of my life in my supplemental essay. There are a few things I want to put in there, and one of the things I want to say is that I am a hopelessly romantic person. Yes, I am. Hence, that story. </p>

<p>And now that you mention writing quality/friction, I am writing a novel as well. I’ve been writing it for one and a half years now and my English teacher is writing a reco for me and I think she has included the novel part in the reco (I regularly sent her the chapters for reviewing.) Do you guys think that I should replace this story with maybe a small section of the novel?</p>