Keep in mind also that the ED/EA pools at many of these schools include recruited athletes, legacies, and others for whom the admit rate is close to 100%. So the EA admit rate overstates the advantage for typical applicants. No, it is not impossible for unhooked kids to be admitted RD at these schools. But the odds aren’t great for anyone.
For a student with well defined interests I’d pay less attention to the overall ‘ranking’ of the school, more to the department. Georgetown has a very strong government dept and school of foreign service. It is going to come up in any discussion of top 5-10 schools for a student interested in politics and foreign service. MIT is a higher ranked school on most lists, but wouldn’t be part of that discussion.
Whether to apply to multiple Ivies really depends on the list size. To me, based on your brief description and especially the mention of foreign service, Princeton would belong on any size list as an extreme reach. If you want a few more extreme reaches you could look at Harvard, then perhaps a few others. In fact, it’s probably common for kids applying to one of them to apply to a few. But don’t assume that just because they’re Ivies that they’ll be better fits for your son’s particular interests than Georgetown, Tufts, Rice, etc.
For summer work, he could consider volunteering at a local party office if a particular candidate isn’t appealing. Not absolutely necessary so I wouldn’t do it unless it sounds fun.
If you’ve determined that one Ivy may represent a good fit, then, because of the overlap across Ivies in academic strengths, usually one or two more would be good to add to a potential application list.
Only — and then not necessarily — under the condition that you are confident you have accessed reliable rankings for undergraduate programs for the study of politics, political theory and public policy.
I’m glad you brought up the distinction between undergrad and grad rankings. I typically only find grad rankings when I google for top programs but don’t know how or if that translates to undergraduate teaching, etc., too. So your comment makes me think that yes, I need to evaluate undergrad rankings but how/where?
Sorry for all the questions.
Small class sizes, taught by professors, not TA’s and lots of interaction is big priority in our search. And very helpful career counseling services and internships is another big need.
I would put G’Town in the top group for Poly Sci and IR at the undergraduate level. There are some Ivy’s I would indifferent with and the others I would prefer G’Town over them. However, even that difference is really almost immaterial. G’Town and the other DC schools have the clear advantage in internships. You can do them while you are taking classes. There is an abundance of internships in DC. However, many of them are unpaid. Not always having to take a semester off or compete with the masses for summer internship is helpful. Plus you have a built in place to live. What you want to apply early to is really personal preference. The one caveat I would have to that is if it impacts any other schools that he would like to apply EA. The SCEA schools will not let you apply EA to any other private EA schools. G’Town allows that to happen. So if he has a match school that he would like to EA that could drive his decision.
Just a “warning” of sorts that EA at Georgetown is harder than RD, unlike most other early programs. Their marketing says admit rates are around the same for both, but the info session we attended said they only take the cream from the EA crop - those people that they are sure they would admit regardless what the RD pool will look like. Remember these schools get many more applicants in their stats range than they can admit. Such a school is hard to call a “match” if match implies a high chance of admission.
Not sure if I misinterpreted one of the posts above but sounded like someone was recommending some top state flagships under the “matches and safeties” banner. Matches maybe, for OOS such a school is never a safety.
@SJ2727 Really? Ugh. That’s discouraging. But thank you for the heads up. That would make S21 consider EDing at GW then bc if he really thinks he likely wants DC (granted he’s still a junior) then that could be risky. Although I guess he could apply GT EA and if he didn’t get in, then he could still apply ED2 to GW.
I was thinking he’d have better odds doing EA at GT then trying to go for big gamble at H or Y or P, for example. But maybe not then.
FWIW Many colleges & universities offer a Wash DC semester option.
GWU–George Washington University–has the Elliot School of International Affairs–lots of DC internships, many study abroad options, a University Honors Program, and merit scholarships which average about $20,000 per year (although I suspect that your son may be competitive for a higher award).
@happy1 and @SJ2727 Im not familiar with Fordham but good for undergrad poly sci? I don’t doubt you but am curious how this is known? (I’m trying to figure out how to learn more about good poly sci undergrads.)
Again may ultimately be moot point if S for sure wants DC but I want to be informed regardless.
@Eeyore123 I look forward to hearing more where your son ends up. He finds out April 1st, right? I feel like I will be learning more about this process from you in the weeks ahead as I learn more what questions to ask, etc.
Fordham University offers a global business major. I believe that admission comes with a scholarship & Lincoln Center housing, but not certain.
Unfortunately, one of the best schools for your son’s interests is located west of Texas in California–Claremont McKenna College. Specialty is International Relations, Government, Economics, History, & Politics. Part of the Claremont Schools Consortium.
@Publisher When I was watching some senate hearings a few months back I googled the person’s background and saw that they had attended Claremont McKenna. I could deal with my CA-phobia if it was a great fit for S. So, yes, I will go read more about them. But…is it another school that if you don’t apply ED you have no shot in getting admission??
If he wants DC then the choices then Gtown, GW, American being the three obvious choices.
Fordham is an overall strong/serious school that should be a safety for your S. The Rose Hill campus (the more traditional campus) looks like it offers Poly Science and an Interdisciplinary Major in International Political Economy.
Although the Eliot school is more competitive than GW overall, likely significantly so, I think your son’s stats will make him a strong ED(2) option. However, I would also urge you to consider that while DC is a fabulous city, it should not be the sole overriding reason for choosing a college. There are many options other than Florida or DC for someone like your son. New York as an example also has many options and as someone mentioned above, a semester or year in DC, or summer internships, are possible with many colleges.
As an aside - my daughter had very similar interests on applying to your son. She scrapped Georgetown off her list after we visited, feeling it was too much of a reach, and ended up at NYU (ED) but had liked all of GW, American and Fordham (which does have polysci and IR) a lot when visiting. She also had BU on her list.
Also, please remove yourself from the mindset that it is “ED or nothing” at schools. Many confer an advantage ED, but they certainly admit out of RD. Your son should only commit ED if he is absolutely certain it’s his number one choice.
For an emphasis on these aspects, research purely undergraduate-focused schools such as Amherst, Bowdoin, Bates, Hamilton, Claremont McKenna, Vassar and Kenyon.
Look into colleges with terms in D.C., which may offer associated internships.