S21 - ACT improved so now reworking PolSci/IR/Govt list of schools

IMO, ED is a great option only if the school is a clear first choice and financial aid is not a big consideration. Since you are full pay, FA considerations falls out, but if you ED not because your son loves the school, but because of some admissions advantage at a less reachy school, he may always wonder what if. Based on what you have written about your son’s accomplishments and the fact he is a URM, I think he will end up with multiple choices at very good schools.

G’Town of course is an excellent school. If that is his first choice, I would not be afraid of applying EA. If they do in fact only admit the cream of the crop EA, they would obviously seriously revisit many EA deferrals in the RD round. I don’t think his chances are reduced applying EA vs RD. Also, I don’t think DC has to be an overriding condition. D went to a NESCAC and 2 of her roommates had DC summer internships and a term within DC. If your son got into one of the Ivies, DC internships will not be a problem.

Apply ED to a clear first choice school. Need for financial aid should not inhibit applying ED as ED is not binding if aid offered is insufficient.

However, if one needs very substantial financial aid, then best not to apply ED to any school which does not meet full need.

ED is too powerful to be ignored in today’s ultra-competitive admissions environment. Just do research & use the ED option wisely.

I agree with posters who have suggested that applying EA to Georgetown might not be worth giving up the ability to apply ED or SCEA/REA elsewhere.

Also for Georgetown your S should take 3 SAT subject tests, which are ‘strongly recommeneded’ by GT. AP tests can be submitted in lieu of, or in combination with, the subject tests.

As for American, demonstrated interest is ‘very important’ on the CDS, and they fill around 45% of the class in ED. Make sure your S signs up for their email distribution list, meets with the AO on a school visit/at a college fair, visits campus, etc.

GWU ‘considers’ demonstrate interest, and fills around 35% class in ED.

Note also that both American and GWU are skewed female: Class of 2022 stats: American 65% female, GWU 64%. Interestingly, males do not have a relatively higher acceptance rate at either.

Additionally, look at UVA, William and Mary, U Maryland, Tufts (really most of the NESCACs will work), and Colgate. About 175 schools partner with American for the Washington Semester program, so look to that for more possibilities.

I was also thinking about CMC for your son, but it’s a very tough admit as are the other schools being discussed. My S19 applied to 16 schools, was admitted to 3 top 20 universities and wait listed at a number of other top schools. The only two where he received flat out rejections were Yale and CMC.

“Although I guess he could apply GT EA and if he didn’t get in, then he could still apply ED2 to GW.”

I would still RD to GW even if you were deferred by GT (they don’t reject in EA). You don’t want to lock yourself in like that. GT EA rate is lower as others have noted, for last year it was 12% with RD being 15%, to make the overall acceptance 14%. Also SFS has slightly higher acceptance rate than Georgetown College (if you want to major in poly sci or govt). Good luck!

@SJ2727

Is your daughter starting NYU in the fall or already there? Would love to hear her experience if she is already there. Is her major IR or polysci?

@apple23
I only know of Hamilton by name but not familiar with it really. But what feedback I have heard has been top-notch. NYC and DC internships would be huge plus.
And apparently the teaching is extremely high quality? and small class sizes?

I didn’t know that GT will defer to RD if not accepted EA. That is very helpful. All of your feedback is extremely helpful. So maybe we won’t be so eager to find an ED since you are right, he doesn’t have an absolute first place school. He wants to learn lots, have inspiring conversations with peers and faculty, have opportunities for direct exposure to DC activity (be it WH, state dept., foreign affairs).

He did talk with a dream-like quality (when we were visiting the 3 DC schools last Fall) that he thinks attending events at the DC Kennedy Center would be a huge plus, as well as “being able to sit by the Lincoln Center with a book at night” or elsewhere on the National Mall would be something he could see himself doing. Jogging around the capitol was another scene he described as a perk.

Note: He will be spending a week living on GW’s Mt. Vernon campus in July and I think that will also help him better gauge what he wants, etc.

We won’t be applying for FA. Will be full pay. Merit would be nice but not something that has to be.

This is helpful. And a bit reassuring.

He’s taken one. WH 790. Two more in June 2020 (Am. History and Eng Lit).

We toured American in the fall, and we are on their mailing list (although I don’t think we’ve seen anything much from them to be honest.)
Unfortunately, they don’t seem to visit our Florida school area. But if they do, we will take note for sure.

Toured in the fall, and S21 will be living on Mt. Vernon campus for a week as part of a GW summer program. It may be hard to get him back on the return plane home when it finishes?!

Interesting. I really do wonder why that is.

Thank you for including that specific program name. Good to know.

This is VERY helpful. Many, many thanks for these stats. (Hubby also appreciates these specific percentages when I share with him the f/b I’m learning from CC.)

Congrats on your S’s new ACT! Re, his interests and desire for internships and travel, and love of the DC area, GT would seem perfect. It has fabulous professors and connections, and the SFS has great employment outcomes. So, if your S got into a “higher ranked” program, would that be better? Would he want to ED somewhere else, as posters are recommending?

A good friend’s D just went through the process, applied everywhere RD (bc family wanted to weigh finances though they were full pay). In the end, she turned down Duke and is happily and very involved at GT. They have a separate newspaper for SFS, which she is writing for, she already has a paid job on campus where she gets to hear all the distinguished speakers at fancy events, etc. And, she’s just a 1st year. Her family is very cost-conscious, and they said the only reason they are paying that amount is, after lots of research, they concluded she’d definitely be employable at graduation!

And, fwiw, he is Hispanic for college purposes, regardless of how he was raised. He is an URM and that rightfully should be taken into account in his admissions, though he’s fabulous regardless. But, every kid deserves to see people who look like them in high level positions. Only when all of us are equally represented will the sexism, racism, bigotry and hate in our country be overcome.

Good luck to your extremely interesting and unique son!

Please remember Early apps are only an advantage in admit rates for kids who DO fully match what a college wants in an applicant. They don’t magically lower standards just to get more admitted earlier.

So you still have learn a lot about the colleges and how you fit what THEY want and look for. Parts of this thread make it sound like it’s all about what the applicant wants and just finding what you want most.

Again, you haven’t mentioned a usual array of the sort of *activities /i that top tier colleges look for.

@havenoidea: Hispanics do not look alike. Also, the concept of how URM is defined is up to each school to decide.

S18 had a similar set of interests (though with somewhat higher stats: 4.0UW, 1540 SAT, 10 APs, top 1%) and went through this two years ago. He had always seen himself in DC and loved the summer program he did at GWU after sophomore year of HS.

He applied to UVA, W&M, GWU and American. Not Georgetown because we didn’t want to pay $80K per year. Admitted to those four (with Echols at UVA, Monroe at W&M, $25K merit at GWU and $20K merit at American) and a few other places like Macalester. When making his decision he ranked them in that order, despite UVA and W&M being outside DC and not offering merit money, because he felt they were better schools (also GWU didn’t impress during his admitted student visit).

But in the end he decided to stay instate at UCLA and save his 529 money for later. He’s loving it there and is planning a summer internship in DC this year. He could spend a semester in DC but decided against it because he is involved in lots of organizations on campus and it’s hard to have leadership roles if you are out for part of the year. He doesn’t feel at all limited by not being in DC, he’s developed relationships with a number of politicians who are teaching courses, and will have the opportunity to go to the East Coast for grad school with a lot more money in the bank.

Maybe he doesn’t have breadth. True. Bc yes, JRTOC is by far a huge chunk of his life other than academics. (Drill team, academic team, and PT take hours of his time before and after school each day, plus drill meets, academic brain brawls, and other demands for JROTC like fundraising as it’s a public school with NO money for funding besides what little the Navy provides for uniforms and basics.)

He also squeezes math tutoring (receiving not providing), and NHS activities (book drives, school maintenance events on weekends repainting murals on campus, painting parking lines, touching up other school areas that maintenance doesn’t always have time/money to do). He also tutors some of his JROTC peers before school. He had a p/t fast food job last summer/fall (before hubby and I pulled the plug b/c of time constraints). He initiated applying for the job b/c he “feel like I need to be true teenager and know what it means to work”. He got his first paychecks and yes, was surprised at how little he got paid but he appreciated having interactions beyond that of HS peers and JROTC crowd. He cleaned bathrooms, wiped tables, emptied garbage and took orders from college students, etc. and realized people change their minds a lot, etc. He liked having co-workers who were almost all college students. (Restaurant is across street from our local college.)

He works one-on-one with his Spanish teacher after school bc while he is Hispanic born, he is not a native speaker and 80% of his classmates are. So he has A’s but wants to improve his fluency.

He spent some time one volunteering at Humane Society. But not in depth.
He has said that he would really like to take an art class his senior year but feels he shouldn’t b/c of needing to keep his schedule comprised of all challenging classes.

He also said he would like a college where he could do a little theatre (back to his Middle school days) bc he misses being on stage and performing.

So…yes, he doesn’t do those things now but he has a huge creative side that if he could find an outlet for in college, he’d also try to make it happen. He has an interest in photography but nothing to date.

So I guess I neglected to present the side you may (?) be hinting at that isn’t developed: a curiosity of things besides govt/politics/history.

He is really a cool kid. He is quite bright but he is always up to try new things. (He wanted to pursue a year in Japan via Rotary but we weren’t ready to have him leave us for a year while still in high school.)

Lastly, to finish “painting the picture” a bit:
He attended a private school from preschool through 7th grade but he insisted on leaving it to attend public school. He was “tired of a bubble” and of “white, wealthy kids with beach homes”. He shadowed at the local public middle and enrolled the following nine weeks. He was thrilled. He ate food at the cafeteria every day, walked home from school, delighted in a double-block English class with MUCH writing and was thrilled with the diversity. He’s never looked back with any regret and now is looking for more adventures in college.

@123Mom123 what do you mean by your “CA phobia” comment? What’s the concern?

Posters wondered why I wasn’t open to considering schools, for example, in CA. I explained that the coastal highway driving (scenic but easily deadly from my flat Florida point of view and admitted fear of heights) makes me prefer S to stay East.

Son would be happy anywhere for school. (I just like flat, boring, safe places. I am a scaredy cat.) :wink:

Right now, I don’t think it would mean much besides ego boost. Bc he’s not visited the other schools suggested so can’t really miss what you don’t know, I suppose. And…when reading what your wrote here:

…that makes me smile. B/c i love that she is writing for the SFS newspaper (didn’t know they had a separate one), and the paid job on campus with the great perk of hearing distinguished speakers, etc…and as a first year!!!

I like hearing specific accounts of others’ kids and how they approached the process. I get overwhelmed with all the info, but I still need/want the info. Just have to then organize it for continued reflection and decision-making.

So does he live in the dorms? Will he have other internships besides DC one? How is the career counseling center support at UCLA?

And, your story is a good reminder that DS has been happy at every school we’ve visited. (Granted it’s been Davidson, Duke, WF, Rice, GW, AU, GT - although he felt it was pretty formal and not friendly but has since said that maybe we just got a self-absorbed tour guide on a bad day and to recognize the school may be quite different…and every school will have some minor issue but the bigger picture is more important.)

We visit W&M in a few weeks. Will be interested to see what he thinks.