So in my decision process, I’ve narrowed things down to one reach school and one safety school. After visiting both (including overnight stays etc) I like my safety more… it’s a smaller state school. My reach school is a prestigious flagship state school (think the UMich of the South) - and it’s alright, but I don’t feel connected to it.
Should I chase the prestige, or go with my gut? Also cost is not really a factor - I’ll be getting in-state tuition at both schools.
Questions to ask yourself:
How do the academic offerings in your area(s) of interest compare? (It is not necessarily true that the more selective college is better in all areas than the less selective school.)
Are your post-graduation intentions ones where college prestige matters?
Go with your gut.
This study is a little old but it made an impression on me:
https://www.brookings.edu/articles/who-needs-harvard/
Specifically:
“Krueger and Dale studied what happened to students who were accepted at an Ivy or a similar institution, but chose instead to attend a less sexy, “moderately selective” school. It turned out that such students had, on average, the same income twenty years later as graduates of the elite colleges. Krueger and Dale found that for students bright enough to win admission to a top school, later income “varied little, no matter which type of college they attended.” In other words, the student, not the school, was responsible for the success.”
I think you should go with your gut. You’ve done your due dilligence and it’s your life.