Save Me From a Mental Breakdown (Chance Me at Columbia and NYU Stern)

Basically, my two top choices are Columbia and NYU Stern. I’m considering either applying to Columbia ED I, and then Stern ED II if I don’t get it, or just applying to Stern ED II. At Columbia, I would want to do an econ/poli-sci major (possibly applying as just political science), and at Stern, I would focus on finance. If you have any input about which school to ED I to, that would be really helpful as well! I commute to a private boarding school in New Jersey. I understand both these schools are among the most competitive in the country, but I’d like to shoot my best shot.

Income: ~200k+, but my parents are in the process of divorcing, so that could change. I still won’t apply for financial aid.

GPA: 3.76 unweighed, my school doesn’t rank. I had a B+ in Calc BC, which could be concerning.

ACT: 36 (one sitting - 36 in all but science, which was a 34)

Race: Asian

Gender: Female

AP Courses: Music Theory (5), Calc BC (5), US History (4), Lang (4), Chinese (5), Biology (5)

Senior Year Courses: Linear Algebra, AP Euro, Honors Physics, Chinese 5, English

Activities (listed in order of importance):

  1. Princeton Laboratory Learning Program: worked with Princeton faculty and students this summer, used Machine Learning to determine which metabolites are associated with ASD, and which mutations are associated with cancer. I'll have a paper published, I'm listed as the second author
  2. Varsity Tennis Captain
  3. Yale Young Global Scholars: 2 week camp at Yale, learned about sustainability, energy, and environment from Yale professors of different disciplines, ended program with Capstone project
  4. Asian Studies Program: History program at school, with travel requirement to Asia, elective requirements, and a thesis at the end of senior year.
  5. Gold Key: faculty nominated and student elected, basically a 'helper' around the school, take attendance at all-school events, etc
  6. Orchestra: I have played bassoon in the full orchestra for 4 years, as well as audition-only chamber orchestra
  7. Orientation Leader: help the new students get accustomed to the new school, application-only
  8. Horse Therapy: worked at a horse therapy program for this summer, bonded with and helped disabled patients
  9. Chinese Club Leader: mentor Chinese international students, teach school about Chinese culture
  10. Rustic Pathways: traveled to Fiji and Australia with travel company, worked with locals. Built schools, connected houses to running water. I know this is one of many privileged things to have on my list. My experience was a little different, as I truly cared about the culture, and stayed up every night with the locals to learn about their history, but I know colleges won't see past the basic description.

Honors:
National Merit Scholarship Commended Student
Headmaster’s List (Honor Roll)
Excellence in Chinese Award (given to one Chinese student a year)
AP Scholar with Distinction

Recommendations:
both should be really good, the school pretty much guarantees great recs. On top of that, they were my Calc and APUSH teachers who really liked me.

NYU Stern has a slightly better acceptance rate. 10% vs. Columbia’s 7%. Perhaps go with the odds. Sorry about your family situation.

I think you have a great shot at Columbia! Your stats are really great and well-balanced

The thing is, Stern’s ED acceptance rate is 18% and Columbia’s is approaching 20%, so statistics-wise, would it actually make more sense to apply Stern over Columbia?

Olivia: you have great stats, and the breadth of your ECs are excellent.

You have a great shot at both places. Pick whichever you like better and apply ED.

I would go with Columbia for ED. You have a good chance for good schools, so I wouldn’t settle for NYU at this point. If you don’t get in ED, there is always RD.

My student had very similar stats and applied ED 1 to Columbia and didn’t get in. She is an ORM too. If you want an acceptance by end of year, I’d apply ED1 to NYU. good luck!

I don’t mind when I get in, as long as I knew I had a shot. Do you think I would have a possible chance at Stern ED II?

hmmm…better for ED1, but ED2 might work. If Columbia is your dream school, make it ED1 for sure.

Also out of a class of roughly 150, 13 students went to NYU last year, which could help my chances.

Some other schools I’m looking at: UMich, Berkeley, UCLA, USC, Pomona

You seem like you lean towards NYU Stern, and you also report that you might have a better chance there and that the other kids in your school also tend to get in. I would probably recommend NYU, but I think you should also consider which school you like better and what type of immediate location you want and what type of career you want to set yourself up for.

My top choice is definitely Columbia - I like the slight campus vibe, and I don’t want to dive in too focused on business/finance. I think Columbia’s CORE really creates well rounded students, and I would love that.

I have decided to ED Columbia, if anyone still has any input, thanks

Let us know how you make out. thanks

There were a lot of seniors at my high school that ED to Colombia and got it, I was wondering how you did!

I got deferred from Columbia, but got into Stern ED 2 - hope this information helps someone in the future!