Schools for kids with higher SATs but average grades?

I am about to start the college process with my second son.
He is a great test taker…SATs mid 1500s but his
grades are in the B+ range.

I just finished the process with my older son who
was an A student and shy of 1500 on the SAT.
He was accepted to schools like Villanova, Bucknell
and Lehigh.

Should I be targeting similar or different schools
for my second son? What schools may value the higher
test scores and be okay with lower grades?

Will this test score/grade discrepancy impact merit scholarships or Honors Program invites?

He is interested in Engineering or neuroscience.

He has varied extra curriculars…3 season sports, camp counselor,
works a lot with special needs kids, etc.

Three great schools. Good start.

Generally GPA rates higher than test scores in admissions algorithms. When you say “B+ range,” what specifically is his unweighted GPA?

One of the things I suggest taking into account is whether the B+ average is because your son gets B+ grades in all or most classes or because he gets As in some and B/Cs and Cs in others.My older daughter got a 34 on the ACT (like me, her dad, and her sister she is a good test taker) and her high school GPA was approximately 3.4 (out of 4.0) when she graduated. She got As in art, English, and social studies classes but scrambled to pass math and Spanish and had no interest in taking more math or foreign language classes in college. Being aware of why she had the grades she did helped her focus on colleges and universities that were appropriate for her.

Offhand, I would say that schools your older son got into with an A average would be reaches with your son with a B+ average and similar standardized tests. While admissions are holistic and unpredictable, many colleges place the highest value on the HS transcript (including GPA and course rigor).

Your younger son’s grades will certainly play a part in where your younger son is accepted, what honors programs he gets into etc. Details of the GPA such as course rigor, if the GPA is improving over the years, what subjects the lower grades were in etc can play a role. IMO you need to start the college search anew and, while you certainly can and should have him apply to some reaches you noted above, I would focus on adding some other choices that appear to be matches and safeties given his GPA.

Union College strikes me as one that fits in with the group of schools you mentioned and is a bit less selective but still outstanding – especially in the engineering/STEM areas.

Look at Clarkson too. They have a Cognitive Neuroscience major, and a range of engineering majors. In addition, they have a graduate program in physical therapy (and an undergrad pre-PT program). Since it’s a fairly small school with engineering and PT as two of its major foci, it’s not surprising that they end up doing quite a bit of rehab engineering research, which might interest your son if he has enjoyed working with kids with disabilities.

Also consider Tulane, URochester, CWRU, RIT, WPI. They will like the high test scores, but as you say his GPA may take a bite out of his merit potential.

Pitt uses test scores only for Honors College qualification, and it’s strong in engineering and neuroscience, so that could be a great choice too.

To clarify his gpa…he is one of those kids always on the edge
Of the next grade up…like 89.3 and he earns the B+.
No Cs. One B- in an elective. Pretty even distribution of A-, B+, B
He is taking honors, ECE and AP classes. I believe his current gpa is about 3.57 UW. It is 5.2 Weighted, but I know the W doesn’t matter. The UW may be higher if the colleges look at only core classes, which I have heard some do.

His grades are pretty steady.

Thank you for the recommending some schools. We are in NE so some of these would be easy to visit.

Next years schedule:
AP Psych
Honors Physics (plans on taking ECE physics Senior year)
ECE Latin 4
ECE Calc 1/Calc 2
Honors World History
Honors English (nothing higher offered until Senior year).

He will be a junior so I guess he has time to nudge his gpa a tiny bit. Taking SAT again this August. We are hoping to be done with SAT for him junior year, so we are starting a bit earlier than we did with our first.

Why would he take the SAT again? Schools will not differentiate between 1500+ and 1600. It’s all the same, and they know it. One wrong question on the whole math section can result in a score between 760 and 800. They are all 99th percentile. I’d suggest he put his time to better use, like making sure he devotes his study time to class rather than another crack at an already great score. That’s not the weakness in his resume.

We were thinking that taking the test twice gives him the opportunity to superscore.

Maybe it would help with an honors program invite or merit scholarship at our state flagship.

Agree though…his primary efforts should be in his classes.

If he’s 1500 plus, the very worst he can be in either CR or Math is 710, with an 800 in the other. You said mid-1500s. That leaves 750 as his worst score. As I said, missing one in all sections combined can result in a 760. How do I know? My son missed one on the math section and scored a 760. :smiley:

I don’t believe a single sitting 1600 will grossly counterbalance his GPA.

I need to look at exact scores…but he scored higher in English which really surprised me because his strength is math.

Wow that is impressive that your son only got one wrong!

The gpa is unfortunate. He is a 2E kid…Gifted (tested) with ADHD.

Union, RIT, and Lafayette are definitely worth looking at, and he could consider the schools his brother considered. That GPA, unweighted, is not bad at all for most schools if the rigor is there. If he can do a bit better senior year, it could also show that he is maturing. His LORs and essays will be important. I would say in that range of score and grades, it’s worth throwing your hat into the ring. Not sure I would invest in another round of testing. I would focus on picking the environment where he will thrive. He sounds quite capable but also like he may need a certain type of environment to succeed and be happy.

Thank you @gardenstategal. Your name reminds me of NJ :slight_smile:

He is definitely maturing and coming into his own. Just this week he is coaching at a soccer camp and he is the only high school kid…the rest are players on the college team. The college coach asked him because he had heard he was great with little kids.

Agree with you about environment.

He is going into Junior year so hopefully he will be able to pull up his gpa a bit. Then take most rigorous classes offered Senior year that fit his schedule.