Searching for Match Physics School

Stats:

ACT: 34
SAT Subject Tests: Taking in December (Math, Physics)
UW GPA: 3.93
APs: I only took 3 my sophomore year (Biology, Physics, World History), and junior year I got into an early entrance college program so I only take college courses now at the local university

ECs:
Around 120 hours of volunteering
Summer job at fast food restaurant - 11
NASA High School Aerospace Scholars - 11
Space Club at the university - 11,12 (Vice President)
Physics Club - 11,12 (Co-founder and competitions coordinator)
Robotics - 11,12 (Quartermaster)
Choir - 11,12 (Singing lead of the altos)
Recycling Committee Head of my school - 11,12, doesn’t take too much of my time
Newspaper club - 11,12, (Photography Director)

Hello! I’m a prospective physics major (and hopeful astrophysicist!). I’ve been struggling to find a school with a good physics program that matches my stats and that I have a decent shot at getting into. I’m open to both large schools and LACs, but I have a preference for private schools because I’m unable to pay for OOS schools (TX resident). If you could find any for me, that would be wonderful!

STRONG PREFERENCE for schools that accept college credit

Thanks guys! (:

Colgate, Hamilton, Middlebury, Reed and Carleton might represent affordable high-match – or reasonable-reach – schools for you with strong physics programs. However, they may not offer you significant credit for the college classes you have taken while in high school. Neither, however, would most of their peers, so you would need to decide by how much you would accept limiting yourself by this single factor.

Wesleyan (CT) sounds like it would be right in your wheelhouse:
http://newsletter.blogs.wesleyan.edu/2018/10/24/students-hop-into-midterms-with-design-and-engineering-project-presentations/

Is your preference for private schools due to being unable to pay for OOS mean you’re looking for merit aid or need based? Is your EFC affordable for a “meets need” school or not?

To be honest, I don’t really know all that much about financial aid… what would be considered “affordable” for a meets need school?

For this information, IPEDS can be helpful. (Select “Find Your College,” then enter the name of a school, then click on “Net Price.”) For example, this shows the results for Haverford: https://nces.ed.gov/collegenavigator/?q=Haverford&s=all&id=212911#netprc.

MyinTuition can provide you with more specific results as you get deeper into your search.

RPI has a strong physics program.

@spaceperson You need to go online to a gov’t site (FREE - don’t pay) to put in numbers and see what your family EFC comes back as. If that number is affordable, many meets need schools will get down to that if they accept you, though you might have basic student loans too (most do student loans for your skin in the game - a few don’t).

However, EFC is not necessarily the end. Many meets need schools use the CSS Profile for a more complete picture of finances, so if you find your EFC affordable and are looking at these schools, run their own NPC (Net Price Calculator) usually found on their financing page to see if their number is also affordable.

If your EFC is not affordable then you will most likely need to look for merit aid. Some exceptions are a few tippy top schools that have their own way of calculating and give more of their own aid to students. Any college can give as much of their own aid to a student as they want to (need based, merit, athletic, music, whatever). They can not give more than the EFC determines and still have the student getting federal aid though. This is why many schools “stop” there. They don’t have huge endowments so spread things out as much as they can (perhaps with some full scholarships).

You have multiple different issues you need to address. First, the schools that offer the best need-based aid are also the ones least likely to accept transfer credit, or if they do, the credits won’t really reduce your time at the school bc that is not how they apply transfer credit. Second is cost. With a 34 you qualify for automatic scholarships at multiple schools typically covering tuition. If your family can afford to pay room, board, books, you should be able to find multiple schools to apply to.

FWIW, I would not focus on “schools that match [your] stats.” Physics curriculum is pretty standard. Check into course offerings, frequency of offerings, and access to UG research. Those will matter. If you have completed UG in-major physics courses, access to grad level courses in physics should also be a consideration.

UA-H has a relationship with NASA, so internships there might be an option. UA also offers scholarships. (My ds received his BS from Bama and is now a grad student at a top theoretical physics program.) Those are just 2 options.

Re # 7, both price estimator tools I recommended are at no cost to the user. The first is a government site; the second seems to be a college-sponsored service.

https://nces.ed.gov/ipeds/

https://myintuition.org/

@Creekland–
I’ve completed the FAFSA application, and my EFC seems pretty affordable for my family. Would FAFSA be a good enough determinator of how much I’m going to end up paying for college?
I’ve searched up the Net Price Calculators of my colleges and I’ll work through each of them. Thank you!

@Mom2aphysicsgeek–

The reason I put “match” was because I already had plenty of dream schools and safeties that I’m applying to, but I felt like I really only had one college that was a match for me, so I was just looking for more options. But you’re absolutely right! Thanks for the info. (:

@merc81
After reading through Carleton’s website about their physics program, they sound wonderful! Thank you for the recommendation (: (and thank you for the help with FA afterwards!)

@spaceperson Many schools still leave a gap in funding between your EFC and the total cost. Concentrate now on schools that claim to meet needs (or close to it). With a 34 and your stated ECs, I suspect you have a good chance of getting accepted to some of them. You can still try applications at other places and compare later, but try to have at least a couple of likely financial safeties.

My lad loved U Rochester and I’ve seen great financial packages from them (although you will have basic student loans), but do a google search for colleges that meet need and look at some of the news and blog entries. Then look at what they offer for Physics.

I wouldn’t be concerned about their awarding college credit for courses you’ve taken. Many top schools consider those classes to be the basic level of entering students. Their classes will (usually) go into more depth than those you’ve taken. Bio 101 isn’t the same class everywhere.

“Would FAFSA be a good enough determinator of how much I’m going to end up paying for college?”
possibly NO. And it won’t be for most private colleges that require the Profile financial aid application.

If your parents are self employed or own their own business then even the NPC can be deceivingly low.
Have you had the $$ talk with your parents, to find out how much they are ACTUALLY willing to spend on your education?
If not, NOW is the time to have that talk, NOT next April when you might find out that you can’t afford to go to college A, B, or C cause it ends up costing too much.

your SECOND move is to find affordable safety colleges/ U’s that offer guaranteed admission / merit aid based on your stats, such as UA.
those are your safeties, and are the MOST important colleges to research and apply to.
only THEN can you build your list of other colleges to apply to.

look here for colleges that offer merit $$.
http://automaticfulltuition.yolasite.com/
http://publicuniversityhonors.com/2016/04/04/best-major-universities-for-national-merit-scholarships-part-two/

perhaps you should message @Mom2aphysicsgeek , for her thoughts on other colleges to apply to that offer merit $$.

No. That is a misunderstanding of how FA works. The FAFSA EFC is a number the federal govt uses to determine eligibility for Pell grants. I am not positive about the exact #s, but I believe that if your family’s EFC is less than $6000 that you are eligible for a correlating percentage of the max Pell grant of up to approx $6000/yr. If your family’s EFC was greater than the cutoff, you will receive $0 in Pell. All students are eligible for student loans (freshman yr $5500), but based on your EFC, you might be eligible for approx up to $3500 as subsidized (that just means interest does not start accruing until after graduation.)

Only a very, very tiny percentage of schools only use the FAFSA for determining familial cost. By far, the vast majority of schools offer very limited aid and the EFC is meaningless other than for receiving federal aid. Your cost could well be total COA. (Don’t subtract your loans from the total when determining the cost, bc you will have to pay them back.)

The schools that use the profile are all variable in how they determine parental contribution. Running the NPC should give you an idea of what your family’s cost will be at those schools. But, equally, check the transfer credit policy at those schools. The most generous with aid schools are also the ones that only give limited transfer credit.

Merit aid comes in 2 forms–need-based and non-need-based.

Keep in mind that most generous with aid schools also do not allow stacking of aid. THat means that scholarships will not decrease your family’s expected contribution but reduce institutional grant $$ leaving your family’s contribution stagnate.

@spaceperson: For physics recommendations I’ll often borrow a few schools from a Princeton Review category, “Great Schools for Mathematics Majors.” (PR prints no equivalent list for physics.) The sampling includes undergraduate-focused colleges such as Haverford, Hamilton, Bowdoin, Reed and Carleton, as well as technical institutes and universities such as Harvey Mudd, MIT, UChicago, Caltech, Harvard, URochester and Rice. With respect to physics specifically, I’m really glad you like what you have seen at Carleton.

@merc81 How many of those schools accept approx 2 yr’s worth of transfer credit?

Here’s a list of CSS Profile schools. Definitely run the NPC for any of them, but I recommend doing it for Fafsa schools too as many colleges will factor in what sort of merit aid you might get as well.

https://profile.collegeboard.org/profile/ppi/participatingInstitutions.aspx

@Mom2aphysicsgeek: See my first reply.