Second chances?

<p>Alright, first of all, I’m not taking this too seriously, I just have some free time and am curious about feedback. I took a year off after attending a competitive public school to work as an intern for a missionary organization. I applied once to these schools as a senior, but was waitlisted and then rejected for the most part. I was going to defer enrollment even if I got in, i didn’t just pout because I was rejected. I started working as a waiter a week after graduation and will soon leave to work with orphans for 6 months in a third world country. What do you think my chances are with all of my AP scores coming in and with what I did with my time off.</p>

<ul>
<li>SAT: 2230 (800 CR, 700 Math, 730 Writing)</li>
<li>ACT: 35</li>
<li><p>SAT IIs: Math 2 – 800, Physics – 800, World History – 790
Literature – 780, US History – 740, Biology M – 740</p></li>
<li><p>Weighted GPA: 103</p></li>
<li><p>Rank: 10/364</p></li>
<li><p>AP: Computer Science AB – 5, World History – 5, Biology – 5, Human Geography – 5,
Calculus BC – 5, Calculus AB subscore – 5, European History – 5, Statistics – 5,
English Literature – 4, Physics C Mechanics – 4, English Language – 4,
U.S History – 4, U.S. Government – 4, Physics C Electricity and Magnetism – 3 </p></li>
<li><p>Senior Year Course Load: Most rigorous available, 5 AP classes and 1 honors
independent study plus 2 varsity sports that went deep in playoffs.</p></li>
<li><p>Awards: AP National Scholar, National Merit Finalist, Texas Academic all-state football and soccer (1 of 19 selected in football), Eagle Scout, Order of the Arrow (Boy Scout Honor Society)State finalist in computer programming competitions</p></li>
<li><p>ECs: Varsity Soccer(2 years) and football, Video Announcements Production Team, TCEA Computer Programming Contest (Team Leader, placed in State), UIL Academics (Computer Science, Mathematics and Science), Community Service Club (VP for 3 years), Young Independents Club (President for 2 years), Student run tech support, Boy Scouts (Senior Patrol Leader), Church Youth Group (Student Leader), freshmen mentoring</p></li>
<li><p>Job/Work Experience: Full time waiter for 6 months, intern for missionary organization for 6 months</p></li>
<li><p>Volunteer/Community service: Tons: Organized Christmas Basket program for local families (huge, fed 1000 families for a month in first year, now up to almost 5000)Mission trip to Peru (5 months, full time)
Mission trips to Dominican Republic (650 hrs)
Eagle Scout Projects(100+hrs)
Helped collect, sort, and send 100 boxes of used library books to three schools in Belize (50+ hrs)
Counselor at week-long overnight summer camp for children and young adults with special needs (120 hrs)
Various other projects (200+hrs)</p></li>
<li><p>Essays: Great, about my faith, community service, and technology in third world countries</p></li>
<li><p>Teacher Recommendation: Good, one favorite student, and one just a good writer</p></li>
<li><p>Counselor Rec: Stellar</p></li>
</ul>

<p>Other</p>

<ul>
<li>State: TX</li>
<li>School Type: Competitive Public</li>
<li>Ethnicity: White</li>
<li>Gender: M</li>
<li>Income Bracket: Mid</li>
<li>Hooks: Missionary in Peru, Community service, not recruited athlete due to injuries but intend to walk on, took senior level science course as a sophomore</li>
</ul>

<p>Reflection</p>

<ul>
<li>Strengths: Test scores (does Math 2 SATII make up for my SAT1?), rank, Community service, Gap year.</li>
<li>Weaknesses: already have applied once and SAT math score</li>
</ul>

<p>Silly question. You are going to pass the smell test everywhere. If you are falling short, it has nothing to do with anything objective on your resume. And, in this case, “falling short” may mean only that you seem a couple of ticks less superfantabulous than the next two or three kids with great numbers, leadership, and missionary work.</p>

<p>My guess – and it’s only a guess – is that you are no more attractive a candidate now than you were a year ago. You are doing interesting things (not yet so much, but in the future) and community-oriented things. But that’s what anyone would have expected if you didn’t go to college, so it doesn’t add any big oomph to your file. And there’s a shadowy question why you didn’t go to college yet. You say that you would have deferred anyway, but you give the impression that you are trying another shot because you were disappointed last year. There’s a huge likelihood that you are going to be disappointed again. It is very, very rare that an elite college accepts someone it has considered and rejected in the past. You are probably going to get rejected from the places that waitlisted you before.</p>

<p>You are obviously a perfectly strong candidate, and if you don’t have lots of good choices it’s because you have pursued and unrealistic strategy. I really hope you (a) have applied to some colleges that haven’t already turned you down once, and (b) have applied to some sort of safety.</p>

<p>Ya…JHS is definately right about it being harder to get in the second time. Though, let me say this. I can tell from what you wrote down that I would really like you if I met you in real life. That in it self, is VERY rare among applicants to colleges. Obviously, your stats are great (SAT may be a little low though you ACT makes up for it…hopefully). The odds are against you. Though, good luck!</p>

<p>Correction, I’ve been in Peru for 2 months already, I’m a lazy typer so I like to copy and paste… and don’t worry, I already have 3 schools I’m trying to decide between, I just applied to Harvard and 2 others again because it was worth the shot. And yeah I know what it looks like, but I wasn’t even planning on applying my senior year; my dad forced me to because he assumed I was trying to get out of writing the application essays. The plan to take a year off had been bouncing around for a few years, and it has definitely changed my life. Also, I wasn’t really ready for another 4 years of school, and taking some time off to work in a restaurant definitely will keep me focused in college.</p>

<p>Rtgrove123, thanks, that’s definitely encouraging. I know the chances are slim, but hey it was worth a shot.</p>