Secondary Education Degree in English Loyola Chicago vs UW-Madison

Sorry for a long post…

Our daughter is a high school senior here in Illinois. She wants to pursue a career as a High School English Teacher.

She is offered admission at few different universities including Loyola Chicago, UW-Madison and U-Mich. U-Mich is above our budget and so Loyola and UW-Madison are prime contenders.

We have a technical question at this point and will appreciate any guidance in this regard.

State of Wisconsin requires that if you want to teach High School you have to do a Graduate Degree Program to get a teacher’s license though there is no such requirement here in Illinois State Teacher’s License Program. One can be a high school teacher in Illinois with an undergraduate degree but in Wisonsin you need to get a masters for the same.

That means if our daughter goes to Wisconsin most likely she will end up going for her grad program right after she finishes her undergrad and then sit for the Teacher’s license in Wisconsin which also has reciprocity in Illinois. So far so good. She do want to keep the option of coming back to Illinois as all our family is here.

However she has been told by numerous of her teachers that it is actually unfavorable for a fresh candidate to find a high school teacher’s job in Illinois if they start with a graduate degree. This is because per the Illinois state laws the hiring district/school “has” to pay more salary to a fresh out of school Graduate degree teacher than what they can pay to a fresh out of school undergraduate degree teacher. That also means if a grad offer to work on a low salary, then the schools run into labor law issues

So she is being told, that in Illinois, the recommended way is to get you undergrad degree, find a job as a teacher and then after a couple years when you get tenure then start the masters degree and then use that higher degree to reap benefits of salary increments.

There is a small pocket of teachers that acknowledge that though this is the usual pattern these days in Illinois, fresh graduate students can also find starting teaching jobs if they are “really” qualified and the school/district believes they are a good investment for a higher salary. As anyone can see this is a very subjective ballgame at that point.

If anyone has any experience in this regard and can provide some advice that will help us make an informed decision then we will really appreciate it.

Thanks