Seeking Colorful Intel on Specific Colleges (D27, 4.0, Poli Sci, intellectual, quirky) [<$60k, no need-based FA]

How do folks feel about fit for Dickinson, Gettysburg, Connecticut College, Franklin & Marshall? I am certain she could thrive at any of these schools and find like-minded peers, but in our research we got a sense that overall fit might be somewhat better at some of the other schools on our list.