Select a College/University

My son has been selected in a few universities, he wants to major in mechanical engineering. He has shortlisted the below, finding it difficult to make a decision, which one to go with, International student so really have little knowledge, acquired through internet, about these colleges

  1. Rochester Institute of Technology
  2. Valparaiso
  3. Miami University, Oxford
  4. Kettering

Would appreciate if some parents can provide some guidance and feedback

Congrats on his admissions! For mechanical engineering, and assuming no significant financial differences, I’d recommend RIT or Miami or Valparaiso. Kettering seems more focused on training students for specific healthcare careers. That’s great, but doesn’t seem to align with your son’s interests.

RIT has a very hands-on approach. The campus is a few miles from downtown Rochester, which is also the home of the University of Rochester. The campus is more of a modern (post 1960s) style place, with large brick buildings relatively close together, not spread out like a traditional American college campus. That’s not bad or good, just different. Also noteworthy, it has a heavily male student body, 66% male, according to this article. Most US universities actually have more females, but STEM universities like RIT are the exception.

https://reporter.rit.edu/views/attention-boys-and-girls-gender-ratio

Miami and Valpo are both very good schools and are more traditional universities, where engineering is but one school at the university. I know less about Valpo, especially the engineering program, but Miami is a very traditional university, with a beautiful campus. In terms of the number of students, the size is similar to RIT (about 16,000 undergrads). There is much more of a gender balance (it looks like 50/50 male/female).

Like I said, I know less about Valpo. At least where I live (Washington DC) area, Miami is more well known than Valpo, but I don’t know how they are viewed in the Midwest. Valpo, though, is definitely a quality mid-size university.

Probably the biggest difference between the two schools is that Valpo is much smaller, about 4500 undergrads. Also, it is 54% female, so a big difference from RIT (34%). Some students prefer a larger school, and some a smaller one, where often classes are smaller. USNWR says 95% of classes at Valpo after fewer than 50 students. It’s 90% at Miami. Both seemed highly ranked in terms of teaching.

Winters will be cold and maybe snowy at all these schools, with RIT being the coldest location.

Good luck!

Thanks, very helpful and detailed information

Is there a difference in cost?
Valparaiso and Miami (assuming OH?) both have beautiful campuses and a traditional college experience feel.

I graduated from Kettering many years ago. It would be an excellent school for Mechanical Engineering. When I attended most students graduated with Mechanical Engineering degrees. I haven’t been there in many years so some of what I am saying may be outdated. Back when I attended the school was entirely coop. The school was actually split into two student bodies and Jan-Mar 1/2 the school would be at their coop job and the other 1/2 would be at school attending classes then we would switch for Apr -June. We only had 4 weeks off a year. Two weeks in July and two weeks in December. I earned money at my coop job to help pay tuition. The campus is very very small. It is in a city Flint, MI that is depressed. It is not a traditional college experience. There are no sports teams to root for. When I attended over half the student body was in a fraternity of sorority. I loved it but one thing to remember is your son should be pretty sure he wants to major in engineering as there aren’t many other degree options. I think there are more now but nothing like the options at Miami.

My own son is going to Miami (in OH) next year. I have never visited the school. He visited the engineering department and came home and decided he wanted to switch to the business school there. He really isn’t sure what he will major in. From what I understand Miami is trying to build up there engineering school.

I hope this helps some. If your son is sure he wants a degree in Mechanical Engineering , I would choose Kettering over Miami. Kettering was not an option for my son as it is much more expensive and he really isn’t sure of his major yet. Though they are completely different schools.

https://www.usnews.com/best-colleges/rankings/engineering-overall

I found the campus map to show how small Kettering is. https://www.kettering.edu/undergraduate-admissions/visit/coming-2-campus#campusmap

You can compare to map of Miami University http://miamioh.edu/about-miami/visiting-miami/campus-maps/

Thank you for the feedback, just received the package from Valparaiso and RIT, Valpo has offered him 18k in scholarship, while RIT has offered him, 14k. He is more leaning towards these two unis for now. He got selected in some of the other universities like Hofstra, New Hampshire but has not received significant scholarships. Thank you once again for the feedback, really helps.