When applying to colleges, how do fine/visual, film, performing and other arts students determine their level mastery level compared to others in order to select which schools they have a shot at? It probably differs depending upon the specific type of arts. What indicators did you (or your kids) use to determine where you fit compared to peers and which schools make sense in terms of achievement level and talent. Like for dancing as an example, how did you determine if Juilliard or Brockport were targets or reaches? I guess Juillard would be a reach for anyone but how do you know if Brockport is also a reach? With academic majors it seems far easier to determine what level of school makes the most sense and which are likely acceptances or not. But how do those in the arts do it? What did you use as indicators?
My relative sought permission to either watch or participate in (dance) classes. However, she differs from what you’ve indicated, in that she was not primarily seeking an arts program, but rather a college with appropriate dance offerings. Nonetheless, she was able to see how her level compared in a way that might translate to a search for more focused programs.
I wonder how those in the fine arts or in areas where it isn’t possible to review other students figure it out-maybe juried shows in the past or getting parts if in a performance field.
It’s an interesting question.
Asked a friend whose D is applying to art schools (hoping to get into Pratt). She said they had some input from the high school teacher as to where she might aim but mostly they’re kind of flying blind and have no idea how her portfolio will stack up …
One of D’s classmate who just got into NYU Tisch ED for drama does a lot of local theater outside of high school, and partly gauged her success at being cast in productions at the better of those as an indicator.
My D20 is a dancer and her ballet teacher emailed me a list of schools that she felt were good target range for her. Even though my D isn’t interested in those particular schools, it was a good jumping off point for us to gauge if other schools could be a match.
It isn’t always easy, but there are ways. For music, there are a few common strategies, not all will apply to other arts majors but some might, and most cost money - 1) applying to and attending well regarded, competitive admission summer programs where you can get a sense of where you stand compared to others nationally 2) working with a private teacher on one’s instrument who has sent a good number of former students on to college level programs and who can suggest schools/profs that might be good fits 3) taking sample lessons with college professors when you visit (many will give you a decent idea of where you stand and/or what you need to work on) 4) paying for a lesson with a nearby university professor or professional in the field who can assess skill level and recommend good target schools if the private teacher does not have adequate experience/knowledge in the area of music admissions. 5) successful auditions for and participation in local and state level competitive/honor ensembles may be helpful (especially in larger states or cities with strong music programs and a lot of competition). If a student is in those ensembles for a few years they often know where older, similarly skilled students in the group have applied and have been accepted.
I’ve heard of National Portfolio Days where visual artists can bring in a portfolio and get feedback. I also know there are fine arts college fairs that might allow prospective applicants to ask questions and get feedback. There also are specific forums here at CC for mostif not all of the fine arts/performing arts majors. Check out the appropriate one to get more targeted advice.
The Acting/MT board just lightly touched on this this the other day and for theatre it’s hard to know whether you can compete on a national level until you do. I think it’s much less cut and dried for actors and dancers than for musicians as there are more objective standards in music. Maybe for actors at Julliard it might be more objective but I don’t really know - my experience is only watching “non-outlier” acting/singing/dancing kids apply to to mostly well-regarded national programs and seeing their success or lack of success in admissions and beyond.
@SJ2727 mentions casting in local productions as one indicator for an actor, but the quality of the competition for local productions varies tremendously. Some people getting bit parts in one location might be stronger than someone who gets the lead in a different community.
To take classicalsaxmom’s points (all of which make a lot of sense for music): 1. I know an actor who spent the summer at a competitive program, loved it, felt she did well, got good feedback and then was shut out of college programs when she applied, including the summer program where she knew all the auditors. 2. Private voice and acting teachers aren’t always objective. My D’s sophomore year voice teacher always had a senior “star” whose voice training she put more energy into. Her star student went to the most competitive MT program in the country one year and the next year her star was rejected from all of the same programs that star 1 had been accepted to and both teacher and student were shocked. Numbers 3, 4 don’t really apply to actors. 5 is pretty much “it” - you know you can compete when you have competed… but many high school actors don’t have those kind of experiences before applying to schools. So they only know after they have applied to colleges and gotten some responses.
All that said - imo the college application process itself and the acting industry itself isn’t completely objective when it comes to talent. The best voice I’ve ever heard on a high school stage got rejected from college programs because he was very shy. Several of the acting/singing kids I know who were shut out of acting programs after BFA applications still did very well where they landed and they are still acting/singing, getting the best parts their schools. I think it’s a balance each artist has to handle - they need to listen to objective feedback received but they also need to have an internal set of standards that “judges” the judges and decides if that feedback is valuable or even meaningful.
Where does that leave a high school senior trying to decide if they can compete? Each senior has to decide for themselves if they want to “go for it”. There may well be coaches who are smart and brave enough to say to a student - “strive for lesser competitive programs” but I don’t know of any. That’s why the standard advice for actors is to “cast a wide net”: both to handle the unpredictability of admissions and to keep a student from having to judge their own level of talent/skill with so little truly objective information available.
@camomof3 yes I take the point about local locations differ - we are in a very large metropolitan area where one of the local theaters specifically that D’s classmate has gotten roles in is highly regarded (enough that a school on the opposite coast will recognize the name easily). It would obviously be different for someone in a smaller rural town, who may have equivalent ability but wouldn’t have the same ability to judge it a priori.
@SJ2727 - I think that helps! My D is also at Tisch (freshman) and the only experience she had was the theatre program she did in high school which is locally very well-respected but certainly doesn’t have a national reputation. Other folks who weren’t accepted to their top choices went to higher profile schools / had won prizes or competitions / did summer programs / etc… so I guess my take on it all is “you just can’t tell” and much of an actor’s ambition needs to be fueled by their own faith in their talent and not on any one piece of external feedback.
These are really good suggestions that I hope are read by younger students as well-especially those living in rural areas or areas where there is less support for the arts and where they might not have access to advice from people around them. I would guess that within each type of art, there are different ways to get some sense about where you stand-but the ways also differ markedly across the different arts.
How much do formal juried shows, competitions, adjudicated festivals and other activities involving direct comparisons across peers contribute to knowing where you stood? And if they did, at what age did you start them? Was there a down side to them? I can see the potential for parents to pressure their kids to do well in these sort of competitions which then could turn the arts into something less pleasurable for the kids. That phenomenon is widely publicized in sports but less so in the arts. Is that because it does not happen with most arts (except maybe with “Hollywood Moms”). The stories I could share about sport parents across quite a few different sports would amaze you. Is it similar in the arts but just not discussed as much or are the parents of kids in the arts more aware/sensitive to that issue? And if the experiences are positive , at what age would you suggest kids enter these sorts of activities?
I have a musician son and an actor daughter – both did summer programs that really helped them see where they stood in relation to others in their field. Both kids did the California State Summer School for the Arts program and were encouraged to continue by their teachers there. My son also did a summer music program at USC and was encouraged to apply to their music school by the teachers there. Another way to gauge your talent is to ask to take a lesson with a teacher at one of the schools and ask their opinion.
As @classicalsaxmom says, National Portfolio Days should be a good indicator for fine arts students. My daughter attended one this year: one school was a bit harsh in criticizing her varied styles while another school was quite effusive in praise. Fortunately, she was accepted to both EA.
Astute12, were the teachers straight-forward about strengths and weaknesses? Honest in terms of their appraisals?
For dance you will likely have an idea if you can be competitive in BFA program auditions by doing summer intensives, many of which are audition-based. That is especially true of the college-based programs which often have already admitted students or even rising sophomores attending.
However there is an enormous amount of randomness in audition outcomes, you may get into a more prestigious program and be turned down at a less prestigious one, depending on what they are looking for and how things go on the day. You may even be able to reaudition and get a different outcome.
So the best advice is to apply widely and audition at a lot of schools. My D18 applied to 11 schools, auditioned at 10 plus a couple of reauditions and got 6 acceptances. She chose the schools to apply to based on their reputation and style of dance, as well as location and cost.
She did apply to Juilliard but treated it as a lottery ticket, just like an academic application to an Ivy League school. At least they have a multi-cut audition process for dance, which feels somewhat more objective than other large group auditions (and much better than those places that do prescreens based on video submissions). And you can potentially feel good about getting to the last 20 or 50 out of 200, even if you get cut before the end.