Interesting to note that two of the senators that signed the letter, Harris and Booker, are likely presidential candidates in 2020. Remember President Obama administrations attempt to do it’s own college rankings? This could make it into the democratic platform in 2020. The real issue isn’t if the government will do it’s own rankings, but if it will link FUNDING to those rankings.
Please, government stay out of undergraduate education. Do we really want politicians, especially those with whom we disagree, setting criteria for universities that reflect the values of those politicians and are used to determine funding? We might like it when our favored party wins elections. What about when that party loses? Which happens, guaranteed.
don’t worry this is just a letter which anyone has the right to compose. Also, government is already heavily into US education, the University of California system, the University of North Carolina system (UNC) etc… There are other rankings that tilt toward more of what the senators are asking for already. Forbes https://www.forbes.com/top-colleges/list/#tab:rank
About 50% of USNWR weighting is great and pretty much every other ranking system uses the same things (retention, rate, graduation rate) but USNWR includes things that are lame (high school guidance counselor reputation). How much they pay faculty (which creates a feedback loop to increase college costs more.
everyone knows many of the flaws of USNWR; Malcolm Gladwell is a fun listen on Ivy league colleges which he compares to talent agencies that select supermodels rather than developing someone’s potential (e.g. boot camp). Others compare USNWR rankings to comparing a chef that uses the most expensive ingredients to make a meal that tastes the same as the dude in the food truck.
I’m not a fan of USNWR college rankings but it is their ranking and we have the ability to determine if it’s important to us or not. The senators can make their request but if they were to start somehow introducing “legislation” concerning this (I don’t know how they could but stuff happens) I would be firmly opposed.
the main beef I have with USNWR rankings is that it drives colleges to do things that improve the education of their students not one bit. What high school guidance counselors think of a particular college has no effect on improving college education. Public school counselors do what 2 counselors at private schools traditionally do with ten times the student load. Our public school counselors barely get by just submitting the forms for common app - they don’t have time to seriously study what the best colleges are and why outside of local state ones.
Faculty pay as a ranking criteria has the effect of driving up the costs of college without necessarily improving education.
They claim they no longer use rejection rate, which was another metric that has no effect on education quality at the school. I think Forbes rankings/methodology shamed them out of using it, cause having a large marketing campaign to attract more applicants when 50% of kids with perfect test scores already get rejected at elite schools suggests this is strictly a ranking gaming scheme.
U. Chicago gamed the system really well for USNWR moving from >20 to #3 in ten years; acceptance rate going from >33% to <8%. Will be interesting to see what the “testing optional” policy means in practice. It might actually raise the numbers for reported scores even higher since only kids with top scores will bother to send them in.
I think, if Wesleyan is any example, the effect may be a wash. Wesleyan requires everyone to submit their test scores upon matriculation and their CDS reports seem to support this. The overall effect seems to be that for every applicant who delays submitting their scores, there are others who see their scores as a “hook” and will submit them. Whether they are truly a hook is anyone’s guess. But, the median scores seem not to have changed.
In terms of the OP, yeah, it’s widely recognized that the USNews poll overly rewards spending per student and that the colleges recognize this by keeping sticker prices high and ladling out discounts like car dealers. The Obama administration had its crack at changing the game a tiny bit and I think it came up with a very valuable resource in the College Navigator website which is administered by the Dept. of Ed. Anything more than that would be overstepping things, IMO.