short essays

<p>I’ve written my 2 short answer/essay things for Princetons application supplement, but I was really confused as to what they wanted or how I was supposed to write. A short description, or like a very compacted essay??</p>

<p>These are mine, they’re a bit long, but what do you think? Any other random comments or critiques would be great too.</p>

<p>1) Destiny’s apartment has burned down twice in the last year and both her parents have cancer. She has nightmares of fires. Zachary was abused by his parents for years and lives with one adult- his grandma. He stutters horribly. Stephanie and her four sisters were adopted six months ago. Four months later her sister died suddenly. Jose and his two gang member brothers live with their mother-who is never at home. Since he could walk, Jose has taken care of himself entirely. Jose has the most innocent, mischievous, and brightest smile I have ever seen.
This isn’t an inner-city group for troubled children, it is the low-level reading class for my district. I came into the program excited to help children discover the world of reading that entranced me in second grade. I expected to help students devour the works of L. Frank Baum as I had. Our first day of class, however, destroyed my illusions.<br>
“C-A-T spells what?”
Silence.
“E-R” makes what sound?
Confusion.
In their world it is enough of a miracle to come to school at all. Reading takes the backseat when compared to the daily issues these children face. It’s not fair. Why can’t these kids have what I have, know what I know? Why can’t they be children?<br>
My literary crusade I came fired up with is waiting patiently for right now. Because Jose just brilliantly rhymed three different words with “sat.”</p>

<p>2) The most worn and dog-eared book I own is an old copy of the Joy of Cooking. There is a page in this book that falls open on its own and is stained with a collage of various ingredients. The page has a recipe on it, and although I have long since memorized the words, I still feel a need to open the cookbook to make the process real.
Sift ¾ cup flour. My earliest memories include my dad patiently helping me “cook,” and congratulating me on my (his) newest concoction. Resift with ½ tsp. salt, 1 tsp. soda, and 2 tbsp. sugar. These days I can legitimately claim credit for dishes, but my dad’s words remain with me: “A kitchen is like a book. A perfect one has never been loved.” Beat 2 eggs. I do manage to keep some cookbooks pristine; I can happily pass several hours perusing Barnes and Noble’s baking section without damaging them enough to pay for them. Add and beat ½ cup milk, ½ cup water, and ½ tsp. vanilla. Those very same baking books were the foundations of my juvenile 1st place science fair project dealing with the chemistry inherent in creating fudge. Combine the ingredients. Some people’s idea of science deals with textbooks and equations, but cooking has forever been my favorite way to make sense of it all. Heat and grease a 5-inch skillet. A chaotic world suddenly doesn’t seem so hopelessly confusing when a jumble of ingredients are sloshed together, and instead of a sticky mess, out comes a delicious, complex organic compound. Pour 2 tbsp. of batter. Cooking in my kitchen is my time of peace. Cook lightly and flip. Cooking crepes for my family in the golden hours of a Sunday morning each week is one kind of perfection. Serve with sugar.</p>

<p>i like them. they’re interesting and hold your attention. i don’t think you can say what makes one essay better than another in the eyes of admit officers, but i don’t see any huge issues with yours.</p>

<p>p.s. i like your name, go wicked!</p>

<p>Thanks! Wicked witch of the west rocks! Does anyone else have any comments or improvements?</p>

<p>Wow… very creative!</p>

<p>The first one is good. The second is a little verbose.</p>

<p>I thought it was too, Nobody. I’m going to work on it.</p>

<p>Thanks for reading them guys! I feel a lot better now knowing I’m not totally off target.</p>

<p>Interesting essays! I thought the first one needed more development about your work with the kids and less about what happened to each of them. The second one was unique but I think you need to work on making it flow a bit better - you have several independent comments and you jump from talking about your dad to “making sense of a non-sensical world”. I think the bits where you reflect and comment (in between the recipie ingredients) need to be united around one theme - maybe focus that essay on your relationship with your dad, or your family. They’re both great ideas, but you need to work on them.</p>

<p>I agree. You need to write a little more about YOU in the first one. A little less recipe directions in the second (cute idea, but we get it after the first two times). Don’t worry about going over the word limit a little. I think my short essays were like 380 words long!</p>

<p>I think that staying within the limits is pretty important. I would not make that risk.</p>

<p><em>shrug</em> I took that risk…all my essays were 100 words over and I still got in. I think it’s more important to write a good essay and get your point across than worry about the word limit.</p>

<p>Euhh, a pretty off-topic question. Are those essays for 2010 b/c I haven’t been able to find them anywhere. Your essays sound good, but I don’t have any idea what you’re trying to answer. I’ll read them once I know. (sorry)</p>

<p>The 2010 supplement, which includes the topics for the short essays, are not available yet, but I think the questions stay pretty much the same from year to year. There are two questions that are pretty much open. “Tell us about yourself” and “Topic of your choice”</p>

<p>yeah, I just did either tell us about yourself/topic of your choice. all the prompts were really open-ended anyways.</p>