Should Harvard Switch to Lottery for Qualified Students?

<p>Check out this commentary calling for a more thorough review of Harvard’s admissions policy. Many believe that the school, in conjunction with others of similar caliber, should “consider abandoning the admissions process altogether in favor of a randomized lottery.”</p>

<p>[The</a> Lottery | The Harvard Crimson](<a href=“http://www.thecrimson.com/column/broom-of-the-system/article/2010/11/23/admissions-harvard-students-system/]The”>The Lottery | Opinion | The Harvard Crimson)</p>

<p>Could Harvard remain competitive with a more randomized selection process in place? Could it be just the boost that marginalized students need to get ahead, or does the traditional, merit-based selection process lend the very prestige that we associate with top-tier schools?</p>

<p>No. It’s utterly stupid. H and its peer institutions have risen and stayed in the utmost ranks of academia because they are able to craft their incoming student bodies with a flexible yet profoundly successful methodology.</p>

<p>This lottery would only diminish that – and who does it help? Random applicants? Harvard needs to act in Harvard’s best interest – not some juvenile outsider’s idea of what’s “more fair”.</p>

<p>No, this suggestion is so dumb its not worth more comment.</p>

<p>hahaha what even is this</p>

<p>No. Just no.</p>

<p>“By virtue of being the kind of students Harvard admits, people who go here already have a huge leg-up in life. A student admitted because of her preternatural brilliance would have been rewarded for that anyway. So, too, for a student with an extraordinary work ethic or an exceptional talent for the arts. Given that these students have so much going for them already, why should Harvard devote its resources to helping them even more?”</p>

<p><em>mouth hanging open</em>
Who is this guy?</p>

<p>Just because they write in the school newspaper doesn’t mean they are not morons.</p>

<p>I agree with T26E4.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>I must agree.</p>

<p>Haha, what a "[Modest</a> Proposal](<a href="http://art-bin.com/art/omodest.html]Modest"&gt;http://art-bin.com/art/omodest.html)" =D!</p>

<p>But it raises so many good points nevertheless.</p>

<p>It is a dumb idea, but one benefit would be that all those who constantly assert that Harvard admissions is “random” or a “crapshoot” would finally be right.</p>

<p>Instead of a lottery, what about a nice computer program which could take into account all the requirements for harvard such as grades, test scores, diversity, involvement in ECs, and special requirements such as number of musicians etc…would the resulting admitted class be less qualified or less diverse or less deserving than a population selected by humans deciding on subjective views such as their appreciation of an essay ?</p>

<p>How did Dylan R. Matthews, author of the article, get into Harvard?</p>

<p>On the contrary being admitted into Harvard or any prestigious school is like winning the lottery. Most students end up becoming successful lawyers, businessmen, doctor, researchers, or tenured professors.</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>I would say precisely because he is capable of thinking different, swim against the current and free himself from the ambient dogma</p>

<p>I’m going to be the odd one out and say…</p>

<p>I like it the better applicants should get more entries into it though and so on…lmao what am I saying that’s a plain out bad idea</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Einstein thought differently. The kid next door who eats mud thinks differently. Doesn’t mean they should both go to Harvard.</p>

<p>^no, but not being gregarious could be the reason he stood out in an overqualified pool of applicants</p>

<p>This idea ignores completely Harvard’s institutional needs. </p>

<p>But has anyone read Malcolm Gladwell’s Outliers? He argues for exactly this. A surprisingly poorly thought out argument…</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>Indeed!</p>

<p>This is hogwash. Lottery?!</p>

<p>

</p>

<p>It IS a crapshoot. Definition: “anything unpredictable, risky, or problematical.”
It’s obviously unpredictable.</p>

<p>Anyway this idea is such bulls***. Who does this guy think he is???</p>

<p>^^The current system is not a crapshoot in the sense of being random. A better description would be it has elements that are subjective rather than random. Random would mean that all applicants have an equal chance of being chosen for admission, and the ones that are chosen are picked for no reason at all. Currently every admit is chosen for some combination of reasons, but not all the reasons are evident to outside observers, giving the appeance of randomness. </p>

<p>The game of craps uses dice to determine the outcome. A real admissions craphshoot would occur if they rolled dice to determine the admissions of each applicant - truly random like the proposed lottery device.</p>