Should I go for rigor or financial security?

I am a rising high school senior looking to pursue a BA in Theatre while also take challenging academic courses. I’m currently torn between going to a college for its academic rigor or price tag. If I play it financially smart I could go to Georgia Southern (reasonable theater program, very very cheap, in-state, but not the most academic rigor) but if I want to go to a college with more prestige and academic reputation I would look into Auburn or Ole Miss, which are much pricier for out-of-state tuition and offer limited scholarships. My current SAT is a 1260 but my gpa is a 4.48 with all IB/AP classes, and unfortunately my SAT score would limit the amount of merit scholarships I could get from the more academically rigorous schools (I don’t qualify for tons of need-based aid so I need to rely on merit scholarships primarily). I don’t know what to do, and could really use some advice from parents of students or current college students!

Ideally, you’d want the best possible balance of both quality and cost.
I think Georgia Southern (in state) will be hard to beat on the cost side, so if you want higher quality (however you define that), you’ll probably need to pay more. Have you looked around for other options (besides Auburn or Ole Miss)? Isn’t the University of Georgia within reach?

Other Possibilities:
UNC-Ashville (seems to be a little cheaper than Auburn/Mississippi)
Guilford (merit scholarships, up to $20K/year, might be within reach for your stats … esp. with higher scores)
University of Tulsa (merit scholarships, averaging almost $20K/year, might be within reach especially if you could raise your scores).
New College of Florida (offers merit discounts to OOS students)

These four are smaller and might offer more personal attention than you’d get at a big state university like Mississippi or Auburn. NCoF in particular may be able to offer both lower costs and more academic rigor than either one (but with a very different academic and social atmosphere).
https://www.ncf.edu/admissions/cost-and-aid/scholarships/out-of-state-freshmen/

If you could raise your scores (maybe by trying the ACT), that would open up more options.

UGA? Zell Miller or whatever it’s called still a scholarship in GA?

UGA might be difficult with that SAT score, but the GPA and rigor do count for more. I would definitely give it a shot.

Of the schools OP mentioned, for a theater major I would stick with GA Southern where she/he could exploit the alumni network to get internships (and job interviews) in Atlanta and Savannah.

New College and UNC Ashville would be great choices for this major too if they are affordable.

Sacrificing financial security for rigor probably isn’t a good call - you can make your own rigor, but you can’t print your own money. :slight_smile: Georgia Southern isn’t a bad default - the question is whether you can find something that meets your needs better and is still affordable.

If you feel that you could audition into a competitive BFA program, U of Cincinnati has a highly-regarded theater program and many strong academic programs as well, and you would qualify for the National Outreach Award discount. But I’m not sure it’s somewhere that you could easily blend academics (beyond the core requirements) with theater, as the BFA program is pretty intensive.

You could also get good merit from some test-optional schools, as others have mentioned. Look into Muhlelberg, which is known for theater, gives great merit, and has a test-optional application option with a required interview and writing sample. Sewanee could be another good test-optional school to look into - excellent academics and performing arts, and I think you’d have good merit potential there.

Also, FWIW, there apparently isn’t a Theater BFA program in Georgia, so if you wanted and were able to get into the Musical Theater BFA program at UA Birmingham or U of Oklahoma, or the Theater Tech BFA program at U of Memphis, you could get tuition reciprocity through the Academic Common Market and pay in-state rates. (But then you’re stuck in the major that qualifies - if you change your major to one that’s offered in GA, the cost goes back up.) I don’t think this is what you’re looking for, but just in case! You can also search any other majors you’re interested in: https://www.sreb.org/academic-common-market

Why theatre? Do you think you want this for a career, or is it just a strong interest but you plan to move into a different career after graduation? How good are the other deparmenta and the career placement centers at these two place.

Which aspect of theatre? Acting? Directing? Tech? Design? Stage management? The strength of the overall theatre department or of specific programs insde that department might be what really matters.

Also ask in http://talk.collegeconfidential.com/theater-drama-majors/

Take a look at Point Park in Pittsburgh. It’s a theatre and acting conservatory of sorts but still a liberal arts college. Mil is a acting professor there and she talks about how hard the kids work but with great outcomes.

I’ll definitely look into the colleges you suggested, thank you so much!

“looking to pursue a BA in Theatre”

Avoid debt. After you have graduated, you will be very glad you did.

I recently chatted with someone who used to be a singer/dancer on broadway. It sounds glamorous. However, the pay is barely enough to live in New York. If she had needed to also pay off student loans it would have not been possible. I know a different very recent graduate (very different major) who has been working as a waitress since graduation. She very recently got a good job in her desired field which is very closely related to her major, but it doesn’t pay quite as well as being a waitress. She can get by fine with the “not quite waitress” income, but only because she has no university debt at all. This is the reality of recent graduates in most fields (with a few obvious exceptions, but Theatre is not one of the exceptions).

You can make your own rigor. Jobs for recent PhD graduates are hard to come by, and even “ordinary” universities can attract very strong professors and associate professors. If you stand out, then professors will be willing to give you additional help and motivation in the courses where you are most interested. As someone stated above, you cannot print your own money.