Should I take a Poli. Sci. course, or a sociology course?

Hi, Comp. Sci. major here. I’m lining up my courses for the next semester, and am trying to decide between taking a Political Science course and a Sociology course for GE credit.

A little bit about me: I care deeply about certain issues related to both government and society. (For example, I hate how the government wants to deny me access to a seat on an airplane or a weapon based on the fact that my name appears on a list because of mere suspicion hat I may be involved in some terrorist activity. I also hate that my government-owned-and-operated college has restrictions on what kind of language is permitted on campus - while I try to use nice language, I think if someone offends someone else, the matter should be kept between the offender, the offendee and any interested third parties (such as the offender’s employer). I also consider myself an advocate for religious freedom.)

Most intro Political Science or Sociology coursework isn’t really going to delve into serious issues; they really only offer a basic introduction to the study of the field as a whole. Your interests in civil liberties really won’t be explored until you enroll in upper division (“300”/“400” level) coursework.

What preamble said.

The kind of discussions you’re looking for won’t come up until very high level courses- perhaps not even until grad level courses.

You might want to consider getting involved in on-campus groups for those types of discussions.

With that said, you might find sociology fascinating. It can be a good introduction into population trends and how and why people do what they do. It can give you a good background if you want to look at things like popular opinion later on.

Taking political science during this election cycle could be interesting, if the prof is willing to bring current events into the classroom.

Yeah, I’d suggest Poly Sci. I don’t think it is a close race.

Pick based off whether you’d rather spend the semester discussing politics and government or wider social trends. Personally I’d pick poly sci, especially since it is an election cycle and you’ll be able to apply a lot of what you’re learning directly to current events, even if it’s not brought up in the class directly. That’s probably not an opportunity you’ll have again while you’re still in undergrad, so take advantage of it now!

Sociology is the study of populations (people en masse) and Poli Sci is the study of power. In a Sociology survey course you’ll be introduced to Malthusian theory and in Intro Poli Sci you will learn basic power structures – government types.

So would you rather learn about the governed or the governors? Both are interesting and worth your time.

I think you should take sociology so you can understand about other people…you certainly seem to need to.

I’d actually lean toward Sociology. The class is fascinating more often than not, and you can apply the knowledge to your every day life!

I started doing a little research for this question. I took introduction to sociology when I was in college and we absolutely delved into serious issues in social stratification, and the second class in the major was Race, Class, and Gender, so I naturally assumed that every sociology major was like this. After a little investigation into the introductory sociology classes and the major curricular requirements across several top schools, it seems to vary a lot by school and particularly the college’s sociology department.

Some colleges seem to incorporate or focus their introductory sociology class(es) on a survey of sociological phenomena, including group differences, discrimination, prejudice, social stratification, social movements, social problems, etc., alongside the less-controversial issues like migration, secularization and religion, law, theory, social mobility, etc.

But it seems that a lot - maybe most? - colleges focus their introductory sociology classes differently, with more focus on sociological theory and much more general themes of sociology. For example, compare Columbia’s introductory sociology class (“The Social World”):

SOCI W1000 The Social World 3 pts. Identification of the distinctive elements of sociological perspectives on society. Readings confront classical and contemporary approaches with key social issues that include power and authority, culture and communication, poverty and discrimination, social change, and popular uses of sociological concepts.

to an excerpt from Amherst College’s intro sociology class description (“Self and Society: An Introduction to Sociology”)

The topics we will explore include: how group expectations shape individual behavior; how variations in the size, structure, and cohesion of groups help account for differences in individual behavior as well as differences in the patterns of interaction between groups; how groups, including societies as a whole, reproduce themselves; and why societies change.

Columbia’s emphasizes more of the ‘hot topics’ concepts through a sociological lens, whereas Amherst’s sounds more like a straightforward introduction to the basic tenets of sociological inquiry.

Haverford’s first-year sociology sequence is simply two semesters of Foundations in Social Theory:

This seminar provides an introduction to sociology, to the doing of sociology, through an examination of selected major works in the discipline. We use these works as exemplifications of how we might do social theory, not as texts to be criticized…Section 001 with Gould will highlight works by Marx and Weber (supplemented by a bit of Parsons, Hegel, etc.

I went to an HBCU and a women’s college, so it probably comes as no surprise that these issues were front and center in our intro sociology class, “The Social Imagination”:

The exploration of a scientific approach to social phenomena, including varieties and uniformities in culture, symbols, beliefs, socialization, family, religion, and government. Focus on social research, social issues and social change. Prerequisite to junior and senior level course in the department.

We didn’t even touch Weber and Marx in our intro sociology class; I learned the sociological theory when I was a bit further along in college (although interestingly, I did read Marx and Weber and some other sociological theorists in another first-year class).

So it looks like colleges vary in their approach to intro sociology. Each approach has its pros and cons - starting with the social issues and problems can draw students into the major before they are introduced to the heavy stuff, but it leaves students without a strong foundation of social theory and they may be disillusioned when they take a 200-level course and get something they didn’t expect. Starting with the heavier sociological theory may discourage some students who don’t realize that it gets (more) interesting later and may lead to fewer majors, but those majors have a stronger foundation with which to approach an analysis of social problems and other sociological topics later on when they do get to talk about them. It’s not all ‘well here’s my experience with X,’ but more ‘here’s what sociological theory and research has to say about X’.

Anyway, to answer this question, take a look at your course catalog and see what the description of the class looks like. If it’s more like Haverford’s and Amherst’s, the class is probably more foundational social theory, research, and methods, and you likely won’t talk too much about the issues you’re interested in until you take 300-level sociology classes. (That doesn’t mean you shouldn’t take the class, though, as learning the tools that sociologists use to discuss and study these issues can be really helpful in framing them later. I use them all the time.) If the description looks more like Columbia’s or Spelman’s, then chances are better that the class will cover those issues, albeit through the lens of a social scientist and not just to talk about how outraged you are about them.

As an additional note, though, many colleges and universities may have additional 100-level classes designed for non-majors that take the social-problems route and discuss those, while the majors may take a more theoretical route. For example, my undergrad has a 100-level political science course (Intro to Political Inquiry) that promises to cover “the disagreement and debate that lies behind major issues and institutions.” However, that’s not the first course for majors - that class is an introduction to national government in the United States. So look to see if your college has something like that, too.