Smaller Colleges/Universities, Strong Teaching Programs, VA resident, Possible XC/track opportunities, VA,

We are working on tentative lists for our sophomore child’s college visits. I do think it’s early in the process and I also think we’ll have a better grasp on this once junior year grades, SAT scores, and running times are known, but since we’re going to visit a few schools at spring break, I am thinking about this now.

*Right now she wants to be a teacher, and has just completed an internship through her school (first grade) as part of a DE teaching course. Her tentative thought is that she wants to teach middle school, particularly 6th grade, science, but of course this could change. Next year she’ll likely do an internship in middle school. We’re focusing on schools that provide 4 years to licensure and/or a 4+1 program for a Master’s.

*Small high school with (I believe) fairly weak academics–almost no APs offered in person, but plenty of DEs. She makes straight As easily (unweighted 4.0 right now) and has already taken a couple of DE classes. Next year (junior year) she should take Spanish 4&5, Pre-Calc and probably Calc, Chemistry (probably regular–we are looking into whether she can take AP virtually, offerings are poor), DE English (AP is only virtual/online), AP or DE US History (I believe AP is virtual and DE is in person), and the next year of her teaching internship class.

*No test scores yet.

*She’s a distance runner whose times are recruitable right now for mid-tier D3 schools. She’s not sure she wants to run in college and we’re not pushing this (my husband ran at a super competitive D1 and regrets it), but want to keep that option open if she chooses to lean into it. Junior year times will likely push her into top-tier D3 range and/or possibly lower-tier D1 range.

*She has a smattering of extracurriculars, none of which are worth listing here IMO. She plans to get a job this summer working in a preschool program with children whose first language is Spanish–she is good at Spanish and loves kids.

*We favor private SLACs. Her older brother is at Dickinson and we absolutely love the education he is receiving, the personalized teaching, the opportunities–etc. We are smitten! However, the teaching goal may mean that a public school makes more sense. I believe VT, JMU, UVA, W&M are all likely too large.

*I’d prefer to keep the budget below $40K. I know this is realistic at VA public schools (and she’d probably get some auto merit at UMW, Longwood). Based on her brother’s experience, I think it’s also realistic at smaller private schools.

*Would prefer a school that is fully or mostly residential, guaranteed housing all 4 years (or at least the first 3), friendly and happy students, and not a huge Greek presence.

*Need to be within a 4-5 hour drive of Roanoke VA.

So far I’m thinking:

  • Mary Washington
  • Longwood (D1, so running here much less likely–maybe a walk-on)
  • Roanoke
  • CNU (?)

Any others, particularly small private schools, with good education programs? Willing to consider PA, VA, MD, NC, parts of SC…basically anywhere we can get to and back in one day’s drive. Thanks!

First thought was CNU. It’s a gem. If W&M is too big, then so is Salisbury but another low cost.

So you need to find privates that will ‘pay’ for butts in seat.

Washington College is one I thought of.

Randolph Macon perhaps.

Guilford College

Publics -

Elizabeth City State - a N Carolina Promise school

St Mary’s Maryland - Public Honors College

Bluefield State

No clue if that helps but a few thoughts.

2 Likes

I remember your thread for your son, and am so glad that he’s having a great time in college!

My preferred source for doing an initial search (the feds’ College Navigator) is “currently experiencing high traffic loads” and is not working. So the data that’s included below is from the College Board’s college search site.

These are small colleges with education majors that offer varsity track and cross-country, and are primarily or highly residential campuses. If the school is a member of Colleges That Change Lives, I included the link to its profile. The profiles are marketing material, but in my experience give a good sense of the school.

This table is sorted by closest to furthest away. I included Roanoke College and U. of Mary Washington as reference points since they were already on your list.

College Name State Approx. # of Undergrads % of First-Years who Live On-Campus Drive time from Roanoke Note
Roanoke College VA 2800 90% 0m
U. of Lynchburg VA 1800 Unknown 1h9m University of Lynchburg – Colleges That Change Lives
Shenandoah U. VA 2,100 89% 2h41m
Meredith College NC 1200 88% 2h54m Women’s college
Queens U. of Charlotte NC 1,200 91.50% 3h12m Merging/joining with Elon
U. of Mary Washington VA 3600 86% 3h17m
Messiah U. PA 2,300 89% 4h20m 26m from Dickinson College
Goucher College MD 1,000 88% 4h32m Goucher College – Colleges That Change Lives
Loyola U. Maryland MD 3,900 92% 4h39m
St. Mary’s College of MD MD 1,600 92% 4h46m
Elizabethtown College PA 1,900 89% 4h47m
Saint Francis U. PA 1,600 84% 4h58m
Transylvania U. KY 1,000 89% 5h32m
Ursinus College PA 1500 92% 5h52m Ursinus College – Colleges That Change Lives
Saint Joseph’s U. PA 4,900 91% 6h4m

Saint Joseph’s (and Ursinus, which I would probably only include if St. Joseph’s is being considered) were placed on the list because I’m pretty sure that it has a very strong education program. It is known for its services and advancements for students with autism, which leads me to believe their entire education offerings are probably pretty commendable.

One thing that your D may want to consider is the ease of doing her required observations and student teaching time in. Colleges in locations with lots of schools nearby are likely going to have shorter drive times to those placements than the schools that are more isolated. But then again, if there’s a geographic location with tons of education students trying to find placements, that can cause its own challenges as well.

Messiah U.has more of a Christian presence in the everyday life than most schools with Christian affiliations, whether that attracts or repels, but I wanted to include it as it is within a half hour of your son’s college, which could make drop off and pick up a lot easier.

Anyway, looking forward to following along on your D’s college search journey!

3 Likes

If she knows where she wants to teach after college, it’s easiest and best to attend a college in that state.

You have so many wonderful public options there, I would explore those first. Ones with teacher education programs will most certainly make sure your daughter meets the certification requirements for VA.

Another thing to check…I dont know VAs requirements. Some states (like mine) require that all educators major in a content area subject, and take the education requirements for certification on top of that. So in your daughter’s case, she would major in some science, and take the education courses for certification. This varies by state.

She is young and could easily change her mind. But it would be wonderful if she didn’t. We need dedicated new, young teachers. And there are usually secondary science jobs…in my state it’s a shortage area every year.

Another thing she should consider, and many do this…take special education courses as well. When we interviewed for classroom jobs, these folks got consideration first as many special needs students are enrolled in classroom classes.

WRT getting a masters…some school districts do still offer a stipend for masters classes to their employees. So she could work and pursue her masters taking evening, summer and/or weekend classes as many teachers do.

3 Likes

Thank you! We’ve never visited CNU. I tried to convince my son to check it out, but he refused to even visit. I have a cousin in Williamsburg and she has several neighbors who work there–and she’s impressed by what they tell her about the school. Daughter currently matches their recruiting standards for 5k and 1600, too. I’m going to put it on the “definitely visit” list.

3 Likes

This is a great point re: required observations and student teaching time. I hadn’t thought much about that, but good point. I haven’t heard of Messiah and will check it out. She has threatened to go to Dickinson, we love it so much!, but I don’t think the educational offerings quite match what she wants/needs right now.

1 Like

All great points. I have told her the same thing about her masters. I believe our school district offers this for teachers. My own mom was a special ed teacher (middle school) and I agree that taking those courses is a good idea. We are in VA and she says she wants to stay in state, so that is a consideration–the ease of graduating and getting a job in-state.

My daughter may change her mind at any point, but she seems really committed to this idea right now, and having spent most of this semester in an internship role in a classroom for a few hours every day has helped cement the idea in her mind. She’d be a great teacher: organized, mature, inclusive, hardworking, and patient. Of course I think this…she’s my child. :wink: (She’d also be a great running coach.) I am so glad she’s getting this classroom experience because it helps give her a realistic picture of what it’s like–the good and the bad.

1 Like

Nicest college in VA -subjective. I walked it three mos ago. Colleague’s kid going for nursing. Chose over UVA.

Someone posted a glowing review of UNC Asheville the other week. Could work.

Furman, like others, doesn’t have licensure but a path through educational studies. They heavily discount. May be worth a look.

UVA Wise could be another.

She should look into club running at some of these colleges. A lot less “stressful” than being on the varsity running team, but probably would be very fulfilling if she loves to run.

2 Likes

It may be easier but it likely is state dependent as to the difficulty of coming from OOS.

My daughter did not major in education but rather Poli Sci and Intl Studies.

She is in a service teaching program.

Colorado - where she teaches (college in SC) made her and others in her program get licensure. It was a Tues night class for a semester and part of next - inconvenient after a long day but definitely not hard.

If the student wants to come home, you might check out local requirements.

But even the educational studies major or even a non major could work with licensure coursework - especially in an inner city or rural area where there is need.

Good luck

Mary Washington on your list seems like a great fit!

5 Likes

My daughter did track/xc in HS, loved club running in college, they got to go on road trips. Now she runs half and full marathons with people she ran with in HS.

2 Likes

Have you tried the net price calculator at each college of interest?

College Navigator is still down, but I used this source to see how many students majored in any Bachelor’s in education in 2022 (first or second major):

https://public.tableau.com/app/profile/jonboeckenstedt/viz/BachelorsDegreesAwardedin2022/Dashboard1

This is what the colleges in Virginia looks like, and it appears as though Virginia really funnels their education majors into particular public universities, or that whatever was submitted to NCES was off, because there are no ed majors at UVA, Christopher Newport, Virginia Tech, James Madison, etc. Looking at this, it seems as though Virginia may have a more unusual route to certification.

Using that same source, this is the # of ed majors (kept it general to include any majors, whether elementary, science, special ed, etc.) for the colleges I listed above, plus Dickinson, since she loved it so much.

College Name # of Education Bachelor’s Degrees awarded in education in 2022
Ursinus College 4
Meredith College 5
U. of Mary Washington 6
Queens U. of Charlotte 9
Transylvania U. 11
Goucher College 15
U. of Lynchburg 18
Loyola U. Maryland 21
Saint Francis U. 23
Dickinson 25
Roanoke College 38
Shenandoah U. 38
Elizabethtown College 47
Messiah U. 61
Saint Joseph’s U. 95
St. Mary’s College of MD Not Listed

If a running club works in lieu of being on a varsity team, then I suspect that other options may open up.

In terms of going to college in-state vs. out-of-state for teacher certification, I would take a good luck at the requirements in Virginia. Most states now offer reciprocal certification if certification was earned in a different state, even states that didn’t allow such a thing 20 years ago. The teacher shortage is real, and the opportunity to have young people who are interested and dedicated to teaching is something that many states are trying to make easier.

1 Like

Your daughter could do something like Teach for America, and really whatever state she is chosen to do, the program will deal with licensure issues. It’s one of the pluses about this program.

If she wants to stay in Virginia, it’s my opinion (as a career long public school educator) that attending college in the state is a great choice. The VA colleges that offer teacher certification will be sure your daughter meets all of the certification requirements. Plus, she will be doing her student teaching in VA, and might even make connections which will help her land a job.

I was initially certified in Ohio. I then moved to New Hampshire, where fortunately I had met all of their course requirements, but still had to apply for certification there. Then I went to grad school in Illinois. The grad program insisted that I needed to take a full year of undergrad PE (wasn’t required in OH or NH) and history of Illinois. I appealed that because I didn’t intend to stay in Illinois and didn’t want Illinois certification. Then after a couple more years of working in NH, I moved again, and fortunately, my new state didn’t require any additional courses.

I had a colleague who moved several times to different states. She was required to take the praxis test anew in every state.

I’m just saying…it is sometimes a little more challenging to move to a different state and get certified there.

And VA has lots of great options for educators!

Another thing your daughter should do…see if she can make an appointment to talk to the MS science teachers in her school district. Find out where they went to college. See what they suggest given she wants to stay in Virginia.

In the meantime, explore a variety of colleges. As you said…you are early in this process so lots of time to tease out what kind of college environment she really wants.

1 Like

UVA has a bachelor’s degree program in secondary (6-12) education:
https://education.virginia.edu/academics/programs/secondary-education-bsed-bachelor-science-education

CNU has secondary (6-12) education as a master’s degree program:

Virginia Tech has bachelor’s degree secondary (6-12) education teacher preparation majors:

JMU has a bachelor’s degree middle grades (6-8) education major:
https://catalog.jmu.edu/programs/middle-grades-education-bs/

Note that Virginia teacher licensing for secondary education also requires a subject area concentration like English, math, science, history and social studies, etc..

2 Likes

I think the way JMU works structurally for education maybe doesn’t show up in the same way as other schools?

JMU started in 1908 as a State Normal School and is still an educator of teachers.

Here is a link to the College of Education at JMU website – College of Education - JMU – may not be the best fit for OP child if she is still looking to go to a small school by the time it comes to apply, but sharing in case that shifts over time or for others who may find this thread :grinning_face:

2 Likes

Emphasis added:

Glad that education majors are more widespread at Virginia publics than this data set indicated!

In terms of the particular situation for reciprocity in Virginia, these sites from the Virginia DoE should be illuminating:

https://www.doe.virginia.gov/teaching-learning-assessment/teaching-in-virginia/teacher-licensure/licensing-services/reciprocity-state-comparison-for-licensure

https://www.doe.virginia.gov/teaching-learning-assessment/teaching-in-virginia/licensure-reciprocity

1 Like

Your daughter sounds very much like my D22, who also was in a child development program in high school that placed her in local classrooms. She began working at our local preschool after school and weekends as soon as she turned 16 and kept that job through college.

All of her experience in the classroom setting will make her a stand out once she starts college and student teaching. Many of her classmates will have never stepped foot in a classroom until their first student teaching assignments. Her confidence will allow her to step right in and that will be noticed.

She may not want to stay local, but it has huge advantages. My daughter attended college a little less than a hour away and lived at home during her student teaching. Not only did it save us a load of money, but it was a much better experience for her than student housing where no one else is keeping that schedule. (And I say this as someone that lived on campus during my own student teaching). When it came time to look for a job, most of her classmates were struggling. She was recommended by her professor when one of the best districts in the state called to see if he had anyone they should interview. Since she had already worked locally for years, the recommendation from her job that she held since high school also held a lot of weight.

I’m not sure what you’d have available locally, but D22 went to one of our local (non flagship) state universities that is known to have a good teaching program. I really think those schools tend to provide the best teacher prep. We tend to hire more candidates from those schools than from private universities. The school was a bit “gritty” and not where I originally pictured her, but I think that grittiness made her a much better teacher. She has a much better understanding of different cultures and life circumstances than she would have at some of the schools I put on her list and it shows when she talks about her job.

1 Like

Just here to chime in that we have had a number of friends kids go to CNU and Mary Wash and they all seemed to have great experiences and be very happy. Good luck to your daughter as she and you start your visits and explorations.

1 Like