Sonoma State vs Lewis &Clark College vs Knox College

So I’m currently a high school senior and I am deciding on what college I want to go to. I plan on majoring in Art History or Literature with a minor in Painting. I want to either get my law degree or go on to get my masters/PhD and become a museum curator. I am from SoCal. Here are the colleges that I am deciding between:

Sonoma State:
-$9,850/year full cost of attendance
-$44,000 in scholarships
PROS:
-Small town
-Hutchins School of Liberal Studies (highly acclaimed, great to get GEs out of the way with priority registration)
-beautiful campus
-some of the best dorms in the country
-great facilities
-Greek Life
-felt “at home” on the tour of the school
CONS:
-commuter school
-lack of life long friendships
-lack of internships because of the small town
-state school, lack of “prestige”

Knox College:
-$11,480/yr full cost of attendance
-$200,000 in scholarships
PROS:
-they’re giving my lots of money, it’s hard to turn down
-art students get their own studio space
-great english program
-great art history program
-7/10 campus
-good suite style dorms
-amazing professors
CONS:
-middle of nowhere in Illinois, lack of internships
-very cold, not sure I could handle it
-very small school, I’m worried about cliques

Lewis & Clark College
-$10,500/year full cost of attendance
-$250,000 in scholarships
PROS:
-in portland, great city
-amazing professors
-one of the best english programs in the country
-beautiful campus
-great internship opportunities
CONS:
-since i’m coming from SoCal, i’m worried I will be sad in rainy portland
-really out of date dorms
-i’ve heard that the cliques are really bad here, i’m worried about making friends
-school is isolated from the rest of portland

So that’s pretty much it. I’m open to any feedback, thank you!

I can speak to L&C. The school has a bus that runs downtown regularly. Even though it’s a distance the bus allows you to get there pretty much any time. My D had a very broad group of friends. I’m sure there are cliques but you find your tribe.

You need to re-run your financial results including transportation costs and winter wardrobe for Galesburg, IL, and winter-ish wardrobe for Portland. When those are factored in, your COA figures will be different than they are now.

How is it that you describe Sonoma State both as having some of the best dorms in the country, and as being a commuter school? Why are you convinced that you won’t develop any life-long friendships there?

Why do you think that smaller cities means no internships?

How do you and your family plan to cover the remaining COA at each place?
What GPA do you need to maintain to keep the scholarships?
What have the career centers on each campus told you about law school/grad school/career/internship placement?
Have you visited all of the campuses/can you revisit before deciding?

How adventurous do you feel? If the money truly is workable, six years from now will you regret not taking a risk and trying life in the frozen midwest or rainy northwest?

For your potential major, as well as the minimal cost differential between Lewis & Clark and Sonoma, I would strongly vote for L&C. The school is not isolated from the rest of Portland and access to museums, galleries and a vibrant art scene is pretty easy and might mitigate any of the CONS in your list.
The smaller classes and attention from professors will allow for you to be well academically prepared for any advanced degrees in curatorial studies.

I am located in the Bay Area and while Sonoma is a fine school, it’s not what I would consider a powerhouse in any of your stated academic interests. It is a commuter school, so it would be more difficult (than at either L&C or Knox) to find a consistent cohort of like-minded people.

https://www.collegedata.com/cs/data/college/college_pg05_tmpl.jhtml?schoolId=802 says that 90% of Sonoma State frosh live in the dorms, so it is much less “commuter” than most CSUs.

Lewis & Clark for the location and the personal attention you will get at an LAC. Portland has a thriving art scene and you will have many more job and internship opportunities there.

Congrats on obtaining three great opportunities!

One more question to consider is what you need to do to renew the scholarships.

A 3.5 GPA is harder to earn in college than in high school for most students.

@ucbalumnus none of my scholarships are merit based they are all need based and renewable each year, given I keep the same financial status I have now

@happymomof1 I am originally from Delaware so I have a complete winter wardrobe. I would probably have the same costs as I do now because I fly from SoCal to Delaware each winter, so flying from Galesburg and Portland to SoCal would be no problem.

I am concerned about the lack on internships because Galesburg is a small town and the nearest city is Chicago which is 3 hours away.

I am covering the rest of the COA on my own.

All of my scholarships are need-based, not merit based so they are renewable each year regardless of GPA.

Knox has a courthouse across the street to intern at which is great. Lewis & Clark has a law school on campus where I can take extra classes. Sonoma’s law program is nonexistent.

I have visited Sonoma and it was fine. I recently visited Knox and I loved it, but the cost of driving 28 hours from SoCal to campus would be a lot. Lewis & Clark is flying me up for free for Admitted Students Day next week.

Would you need to have a car at Knox?

You indicate that you are meeting all of the remainig COA on your own. Are the federal student loans in your aid packages, or will they be available to help with the remaining COA?

@happymomof1 Yes I would need a car on campus, as I i’ll bring be doing work-study and have an off campus job.

Nope, no loans. I really don’t want to graduate with any debt. I’ll ben making enough each year to pay everything.

P.S. none of my prices in the first post include work-study, earning about $2500/year